3 ms·
> Unless you’re already a billionaire then that doesn’t serve you The obsession some HN commenters have with billionaires is silly. If more is produced then th
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> Unless you’re already a billionaire then that doesn’t serve you
The obsession some HN commenters have with billionaires is silly. If more is produced then the following can happen:
- your company is more likely to stay in business and thus your job is more secure (although if a competitor does this and your company doesn't, perhaps you could move, although you would be going in at a lower grade than your new, automation-trained colleagues)
- your job is higher paid because your are more valuable to the company; it can have more clients and/or more work from existing clients
- your company's investors are safer and pension funds etc invested in you do better
- your company's budget is bigger and they have more to spend on nonessentials to attract and retain staff
- your customers get lower prices and in turn they can offer more attractive pricing to their customers, which benefits end consumers
I know this all sounds very obvious, e.g. it's why tech salaries are so high: automation allows our work to scale absurdly, but occasionally when I read "only billionaires like productivity!!!111eleven" I need to say something.
I want to say something, anyway.
- Frummy 3y agoThat’s all great. I work five days a week and all. I just don’t want to be oppressed by money. Notice that all points you mentioned are economically related. Maybe I’d use that extra day to paint and read poetry, or smoke cigs and drink beer on the porch. I actually don’t do that but either way I value the freedom to do what I want with my time more than money and power (edit: power as in over the rest, compared to with the rest back from the few). I’m just speaking for myself here, but I would predict a cultural increase for society as well. Others would love what you mention. I still think they would be shortsighted, Ive been fired and manipulated by companies, more stability could even reduce that so I admit my bias, but the second order effects of the elites disproportional capital increase is more social and political power to them which I think leads to oppression. Maybe fifteen years later the people who love your perks wont even notice that they have less rights, potentially from corporate lobbying, worse health from work, and maybe they forgot to have fun and be creative as well since theres no time for that.
- robertlagrant 3y agoWell, the good news is you can't be oppressed by money. Money is just a value intermediary. What you value might require you doing something of value to someone else. That might be employing them at a steady wage, or giving them back more money later than they gave you today, or doing some task or service for someone who contracts or employs you, or whatever it is. In terms of oppression: it's possible. I would just put the blame where it's deserved. Corporate lobbying is not bad. The government, who takes money from you to pay for itself, should be lobby-proof. That might be one of the most important things they do. If they can't just take money and spend it well without being corrupted by companies who'd like it to do things, that is a failure of government. As for being fun and creative: up until not too long ago many lives were short and almost all were hard. Some of us, especially in the West, have been able to break away from that due to various advances. That's great, but it's not something to return to as much as it is to keep improving towards, or settle for the advances we have and enjoy them.
- Frummy 3y agoI’ll be direct: no amount of money will buy back my time. I would like to take power from the state as well, not just corporations, so moving the goalpost to the state is a different target rather than a nullifier. I know what money is, but who has most of it in their hands and what do they value? Get it. As for your third point, time that doesn’t serve capital doesnt equal laziness and enjoyment of the spoils of previous generations. Rather it could increase the likelihood of a new renaissancelike period, for culture and reason. Tech and economy is alright but it doesn’t stop with a day less in the office, those four days become more creative and productive from the extra rest alone. I work much harder and effectively on my own projects, and detest the bureaucracy in state and capital. More time and freedom means more of what humans are supposed to be, not stagnation. There’s a reason our society is based on debt, it forces people to do what they rather wouldnt have.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> I know what money is, but who has most of it in their hands and what do they value? Get it. Sorry, I don't understand this. Who cares who has most of it? My point is money doesn't oppress. That doesn't change if other people have more or less money than me. If we revert to a pre-money society, it's unlikely we lower any levels of oppression that exist. > those four days become more creative and productive from the extra rest alone This doesn't generalise. Does it work for the service industry? Emergency services? Electricians? I get that there are a few luxury white collar jobs (e.g. tech worker) that can probably benefit from this, but I don't think it's normal at all. > There’s a reason our society is based on debt, it forces people to do what they rather wouldnt have. No, it's so that people can have things earlier in their lives. I could work for 40 years and eventually buy somewhere cash, or I could borrow some money and pay it back over years. I choose the latter, and that's why there's debt: almost everyone finds that to be their best option.