3 ms·
Just because there is one traditional way of providing funding for the production of, some, creative works does not mean that we need to keep going back to that
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
Just because there is one traditional way of providing funding for the production of, some, creative works does not mean that we need to keep going back to that same model for the foreseeable future.
There are lots of different models that work. Even today there are models that are working (pay what you want, kickstarter, freemium, live events vs. albums, merch, etc.)
You say this: "One thing is sure: that large group of people whose names scrolled by on the credits would no longer be able to be paid for their work on movie productions as we have known them." but that is NOT in any way sure. Indeed, right this very minute it is trivial for the vast majority of the people who are the core market for that specific movie to obtain that movie without paying any amount of money to the studio, the artists, or the crew. It's honestly hard to imagine a world where it would be easier to do so. And yet... And yet, the world has not collapsed. The movie studios have not imploded. People still pay money for movies. People who make movies still get paid.
Why? How? This is something important worth asking. At this point only the most simplistic of viewpoints could possibly imagine a future where it is impossible for people to earn a living through making art. There are far, far too many counter examples, even of artists going out of their way to challenge the traditional assumptions and pioneer new methods for making money by creating art (Louis CK, Radiohead, Humble Bundle, Double Fine, Julia Nunes, etc.)
Unquestionably the changes in technology that have enabled unfettered sharing/piracy of digital goods will have a profound effect on the financial nature of commercial art.
But will that effect translate to a situation other than a metric crapton of art being produced every year and a great many artists making a living off of their work?
Absolutely, conclusively not.
- davidw 15y ago> conclusively I don't think it's honest to say anything "conclusive" either way in this debate. It's complex and there are a great deal of unknowns. With regards to downloading movies, many people don't do it because it's seen as being wrong, and also illegal, and that does matter to many people. As for the artists going out of their way, you could make an argument that they would not receive so much attention (and thus money) in a world where everyone had to behave like what they're experimenting with. Right now they stand out from the crowd, but eventually a new equilibrium would be reached where there would be nothing novel in what they do, and perhaps at that point, they'd make significantly less money, to the point where some of them would have to find other jobs to support themselves, and thus produce less.