3 ms·
What do you mean shame doesn’t work? America is a country that literally can’t reproduce itself without importing people from countries where mothers shame chil
by rayiner 3y ago
What do you mean shame doesn’t work? America is a country that literally can’t reproduce itself without importing people from countries where mothers shame children for not having children in a timely manner. America had 100,000 people die of drug overdoses last year, whereas societies that shame people for drug use have far lower rates of overdoses. Middle eastern and south Asian countries that shame people for pre-marital sex largely managed to avoid the AIDS epidemic that gripped similarly poor countries in other regions.
And let’s not forget that we live in a country that became a world power under a social structure that was much more rigid and repressive than the one we have today. Our relative decline in economic importance is probably caused by other economic trends, but it’s pretty wild to say “shame doesn’t work” despite the evidence to the contrary.
- selimthegrim 3y agoIf you think AIDS isn’t a problem in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, I have a bridge to sell you.
- rayiner 3y agoBangladesh has a low AIDS prevalence rate compared to the rest of the world. It actually has a pretty good system for screening and reporting as well, so the statistics are reliable. Overall, Southeast/Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and North Africa have the lowest aids prevalence rates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_HIV/AIDS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_HIV/AIDS
- toofy 3y ago> Middle eastern and south Asian countries that shame people for pre-marital sex largely managed to avoid the AIDS epidemic this is absurd, there are plenty of countries who have high levels of shame where aids is still running rampant. and to even imply that we (the us) didn’t have high levels of pre-marital sex in “the good old days when we could shame people” is naive to an extreme. > let’s not forget that we live in a country that became a world power under a social structure that was much more rigid and repressive than the one we have today. if you’re suggesting that i should intentionally live under rigid repression to “be a world power” i say nah, thanks tho. i’d rather we were a middling country where people are free and not living under some authoritarian religious kooks or whatever power would be repressing me “for my own good” because they have deluded themselves that they “know better than we do” what will make us happy.
- oopsit 3y ago[dead]
- happymellon 3y ago> Middle eastern and south Asian countries that shame people for pre-marital sex largely managed to avoid the AIDS epidemic that gripped similarly poor countries in other regions. Are you serious? Pre-marital rape is a massive issue there, as is underage rape, and rape "to just teach those women a lesson".
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI think they take a different approach though, where women are guarded by the family from being in situations where males, who are known and accepted to be violently sexually aggressive, might harm them. Then women who end up in such situations anyway are considered fair game, more or less. I imagine, though, that while the numbers for various rape types are probably relatively high compared to other countries, those crimes still affect a tiny minority of women and wouldn’t move the broader needle on HIV rates. I would guess that date rape is also extremely lower than in the west due to courtship practices being very different (which would work against high HIV rates).
- rayiner 3y agoThere is no evidence to support the assertion that rates of rape are “relatively high” in those countries. You can assume the statistics are vastly underreported—and they certainly are—but you’d have to multiply them by 100x or 1000x to reach the rates of the US. At that point you’re speculating. The (frankly kind of bigoted) assumption here is that being well intentioned and having the “right” attitudes towards female sexuality is somehow more effective at preventing rape than strict social separation of the sexes. And you’re correct that non-consensual sex is a relatively small factor in HIV rates compared to widespread consensual sex with multiple partners.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoYeah I actually have no idea about the stats, just assumed GP wasn’t completely making things up. I would not be surprised if you are correct though, brute forcing the problem does seem like it would work (no pun intended). > Then women who end up in such situations anyway are considered fair game, more or less. Would you say this part is accurate?
- pfannkuchen 3y agoWhat drugs are you thinking of that are prone to overdose and are also socially accepted? I can’t really think of any… > And let’s not forget that we live in a country that became a world power under a social structure that was much more rigid and repressive than the one we have today Great point, it’s interesting how eager people are to perform large scale social experiments in rapid succession and with no roll back button.
- alienbeast 3y ago>What drugs are you thinking of that are prone to overdose and are also socially accepted? I can’t really think of any… Alcohol?
- pfannkuchen 3y agoAlcohol was very popular when western society was still big on shame though, so I’m assuming that isn’t what is being referred to.
- ffhhttt 3y ago> let’s not forget that we live in a country that became a world power under a social structure that was much more rigid and repressive than the one we have today. Was it significantly more rigid and repressive than in other countries at the time? I don’t think so. Also your AIDS and sex related crime statistics seem to be imaginary?
- selimthegrim 3y ago> > let’s not forget that we live in a country that became a world power under a social structure that was much more rigid and repressive than the one we have today. These sound like the arguments I hear from people that wish BD should have stayed East Pakistan.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> What do you mean shame doesn’t work? America is a country that literally can’t reproduce itself without importing people from countries where mothers shame children for not having children in a timely manner. Not sure why you are trying to invoke shame for something that is a well-known effect of economic conditions, and which has been observed to change with those conditions much faster than (and likely driving rather than driven by) cultural change. > America had 100,000 people die of drug overdoses last year, whereas societies that shame people for drug use have far lower rates of overdoses. So do countries that shame people less, like most of the rest of the developed world. > Middle eastern and south Asian countries that shame people for pre-marital sex largely managed to avoid the AIDS epidemic that gripped similarly poor countries in other regions. Which is some good luck for them, but one of the reasons it spread so much and i nterventions were so difficult jn Africa was strongly shame-centering cultures interfering with both prevention and treatment (and even acknowledging the fact and nature of the problem.) So, kind of not helping your argument.
- rayiner 3y ago> Not sure why you are trying to invoke shame for something that is a well-known effect of economic conditions, and which has been observed to change with those conditions much faster than (and likely driving rather than driven by) cultural change Ascribing it to “economic conditions” blinks reality. Americans are economically better off now than they were in the 1960s, when TFR was much higher. Wealthier states like Massachusetts have much lower TFR than poorer states like Idaho and Nebraska. And whites are much more affluent than Hispanics, but have much lower TFR. The effect of culture is apparent even when you dig further into subgroups. Asian Americans have the lowest TFR, despite being the most affluent and educated. But Muslim Americans, who are also wealthy and educated, have a much higher TFR than whites and other Asians. Both are more collectivist and less individualistic cultures, but there’s a long history of population control ingrained into East and south Asian culture, while there is a strong emphasis on procreation in Islam. Frankly, it makes me laugh when I hear it. Poor Hispanic and Muslim immigrants are hard at work raising the next generation, but college educated white Americans “can’t afford kids.” Right.
- 3y ago