4 ms·
CBT is the ‘gold standard’, but is that just for white people?
- lesserknowndan 3y agoCBT = Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
- bratgpttamer 3y agoIs there a name for this phenomenon I've noticed in things like evidence-based practice: Phase I: On average, our averages show that X is successful/X does Y. [The Science™ sez X! We must all do X now!] Phase II: Wait! Those averages only apply to a specific subset of the cases and don't consider the outliers, which, to our complete and total surprise, behave somewhat differently!
- shortrounddev2 3y agoCherrypicking?
- bratgpttamer 3y agoI associate that with bad-faith attempts to prove a point, which I don't think this is. It feels more like a communications problem where a finding like 'Most (65%) cases respond favorably to X', followed by lots of hype around X, only to see a bunch of surprised pikachu faces when a subsequent paper looks at the 45%. Maybe it's just hype cycles, but it feels like there's gotta be some professional obligation to proactively consider the outliers/edge cases/minority group(s), rather than waiting several years for the "woah wait, turns out not all X are Y" paper.
- mozman 3y ago[flagged]
- RugnirViking 3y agoProvocative title. Still, I'm not convinced CBT works very well at all for just about anyone. Obviously all anecdote, but literally anyone I know that has had cause to interact with therapists has seemingly independantly come to the conclusion that they need to immediately stop any psychologist trying to explain CBT to them and ask if they know any other techniques, and if the answer isn't an alternative, to just find a new therapist. It's laughably bad.
- derbOac 3y agoYou're not wrong. The preponderance of evidence suggests CBT isn't more effective on average than other methods and they're all overestimated due to publication bias: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medicine/article/abs/effects-of-psychotherapy-for-adult-depression-are-overestimated-a-metaanalysis-of-study-quality-and-effect-size/6541520535092D2C3FF0CC3DE45F189E https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medici... To be fair, there's also evidence of publication bias with medication, and there's good evidence psychotherapy works in general. But your hunch isn't too far off; there's stronger evidence for common factors in psychotherapy mediating effects. The idea of CBT being the gold standard as stated in the article says more about how the field and public discusses the research than the method itself.
- thrawa8387336 3y agoI'm not sure about this. What are people's experience with CBT? Personally I've gained a lot of insight from psychoanalysis in a more traditional framework. If anything CBT has some weird religious undercurrent, Protestant flavored, "don't sin! Think the right things"
- porkbeer 3y agoHonestly it seems like bs with a good clinical air about it. I have seen zero indication it outpreforms any other non quackers therapy. Turns out the act of deciding to get help and your optimism about its effectiveness, not the help itself, is the biggest predictor of success in threatment.
- junon 3y agoFor those checking comments first, this is about cognitive behavioural therapy, not marijuana or that other thing.
- freediverx 3y agoThank you for this much-needed clarification.
- code_duck 3y agoIt seems the actual question is “Does CBT work better for non-white people when therapy is culturally adapted tlfor them”.
- HDMI_Cable 3y agoThis article makes no claim as to why CBT may work better for white people—except for a few one-off muses about authority or family structure—which I find to be more interesting than what they're actually talking about. Maybe CBT is more effective for white people because it operates on a set of assumptions that align with Western values, in which case, since most white people are western, it would work better for them. One way to test that would be to find non-white people who broadly follow western norms, have a native language of English, and are assimilated into american culture, and see if there's a difference. Perhaps this difference is also caused by wealth, many of the examples listed are of refugees and recent immigrants to the US, groups who are probably poorer than the average American. Maybe since white people are simply richer (*on average) and have less cognitive stress from being poorer, CBT tends to work better for them. In this case, design a study to see whether the race effects persist when adjusting for income.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoStable, well off white folks can talk about their problem and have the distance and capacity to reflect and change. I got outta the Marines and worked 2 jobs just to get by for a while, and I'm sure no amount of talking or cognitive work would have helped me address my problems. Few years later, living in a comfy house in the burbs, yeah, it's easy to talk through the trauma.
- sverona 3y agoTherapy, especially something very surface-level like CBT, is less efficacious when your daily life actually generally sucks. Depression is a rational response to a shitty life that doesn't seem to be getting better any time soon. Anxiety and hypervigilance are rational responses to some kinds of difficult-to-escape toxic relationships. It didn't start working for me until I separated from my birth family. I completely buy that, in addition to what the article says, minorities have a rougher time with cognitive therapy because their life tends to suck more on average, in ways that you can't think your way out of.
- 1MachineElf 3y agoThis article was valuable to me. My fiancee's close family, and myself, have been trying to convince her to go to therapy for anger issues. She's always refused and stated that therapy is just for weaklings / white people. If her mom could survive near-death experiences during the Khmer Rouge and not need therapy, then she didn't need it either... So the opening example of Khmer Rouge survivors receiving CBT was a perfect introduction to this article. I really hope she connects with the topic and considers giving therapy a chance. Also, about this example further in: >One study (an unpublished doctoral thesis) mentioned in the review found that cultural adaptation – in terms of the languages used and the ethnicity of people involved – led to worse therapeutic outcomes. Hispanic college students who had phobias around giving speeches went through a video-feedback-based treatment in either English, or English and Spanish, and they practised giving speeches either in front of a white or a Hispanic audience. The participants who gave speeches in English to white audiences showed greater reductions in anxiety than the other groups. One possible explanation is that the Hispanic speakers felt a greater amount of anxiety from a Spanish-speaking audience due to greater cultural expectations. So rather than English being some kind of special anxiety-lessening language, it's more likely (IMHO) that any language other than their first one (e.g., Spanish) would have resulted in an audience with lower speaking standards expectations for the speaker to worry about. Tangentially, Slavoj Zizek often tells an anecdote of how while in India, some less-affluent people told him that they preferred English because their native Hindi dialects are just embedded with hierarchy and class stratification. I don't know if this is really the case, but if it is, then Zizek's assertion that revolutionary thought can require new language is an interesting one. Even more tangentally, I am reminded of how I can type better in Dvorak, not just because it is more efficient than QWERTY, but because learning it forced me to drop the bad habits I had carried with me over the years from when I first began using a keyboard to play simple computer games in the late 90s. Overall the theme is apparently a clean slate / new environment / blank canvas / fresh perspective can be instrumental for transformation.