3 ms·
It is pretty obvious that most people who comment here are not aware that while superconductivity implies diamagnetism, diamagnetism does not imply superconduct
by adrian_b 3y ago
It is pretty obvious that most people who comment here are not aware that while superconductivity implies diamagnetism, diamagnetism does not imply superconductivity.
This is not mentioned at the linked tweet, so I believe that it was necessary to remind everybody of this, to avoid misunderstandings about the meaning of the "successful replication", which for now only proves strong diamagnetism, supposing that no errors have been made.
Even if LK-99 were only a strongly diamagnetic material, without being a superconductor, that would still be a very interesting and useful discovery.
- jacquesm 3y ago> It is pretty obvious that most people who comment here are not aware that while superconductivity implies diamagnetism, diamagnetism does not imply superconductivity. I would expect the opposite. Because there are plenty of known substances that are diamagnetic but not superconductors. And this has been covered in other threads about this subject. How interesting it would be if it was 'just' diamagnetic depends strongly on how that diamagnetism then comes about. There are ways in which it would be a 'meh' and there are ways in which it might still be a pathway to a room temperature superconductor.