9 ms·
> Study Deep Blue’s 1997 defeat of world chess champion Garry Kasparov, and your excitement about how quickly this technology would take over other cognitive wo
by roenxi 3y ago
> Study Deep Blue’s 1997 defeat of world chess champion Garry Kasparov, and your excitement about how quickly this technology would take over other cognitive work would wane as you learned just how much brute human force went into fine-tuning the software specifically to beat Kasparov.
That was ~26 yeas ago. In the intervening 26 years humans have been curb-stomped so hard at chess that certain microwaves might be competitive against human grandmasters. Anyone who doesn't think that was an exciting moment for AI research has impossible standards, we're living in a tiny window of existence where humans were at the top of the intellectual food chain and are now dropping to also-ran status along with the rest of the meat-based animal kingdom.
All these moments are the real deal. The idea that somehow this particular step change is even unexpected is missing the forest for the trees. The trends that have been observed since the beginning of computers are chugging away so quickly the whole process may well happen in a single generation.
- bombolo 3y agoWhen you have to manually input the scores for the various board positions, feels much less exciting.
- lawn 3y agoMonumental progress is very rarely done in one giant step, but with many incremental improvements.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThat is just the physical layer. Robotics is behind in making a 'human'. Even AlphaGo had a human moving the pieces, and nobody would say that was evidence of any 'lack' in the AI. It's just an interfacing issue, engineering will eventually solve. Edit> What I was getting at. Take Robots as the physical interface layer for the AI. AI advancements are currently outpacing advancements in Robotics. So potentially AI could use real humans as the 'hands and feet' to do things in the physical world, by giving directions. Something will be needed to bridge the gap until Industry can be done completely by robots. Until then, AI wont be able to manufacture itself.
- RunSet 3y agoPlenty of practically mint human bodies just sitting around waiting to be repurposed. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna9816703 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna9816703
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThis is the scary scenario. What if AI does out pace humans, but the physical side does not, we don't succeed in making vast quantities of easy to build and maintain robots. Thus to keep industry going, the AI does need humans, and it gives the directions. If you have ever worked in a modern warehouse, it is very evident, the humans are just following instructions from the system. Now scale that up to a manufacturing facility, it is already happening. Everybody with an ear-piece or 'phone' type device, following instructions.
- ido 3y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manna_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manna_(novel)
- crabmusket 3y agoThis is what Doctorow refers to as the "reverse centaur"
- johnnyworker 3y ago> The problem here isn't automation, it's power. The workers whom the robots could benefit are instead harnessed to the robot to the benefit of the shareholders. > Workplace democracy, AKA unionization, AKA the thing Amazon has pulled out every dirty trick to prevent, is the difference between centaur utopia and reverse-centaur dystopia. -- https://pluralistic.net/2021/02/17/reverse-centaur/#reverse-centaur https://pluralistic.net/2021/02/17/reverse-centaur/#reverse-...
- Analemma_ 3y agoAgain, your information is tremendously out of date. AlphaZero crushes grandmasters and had no human training whatsoever as to board evaluation functions.
- bombolo 3y agoAgain? When else? Also, we were talking about deep blue. Perhaps trying to not go OT would be beneficial to a productive discussion.
- ZiiS 3y agoThe are microwaves fully in on the curb-stomping https://www.tomsguide.com/news/ges-kitchen-hub-is-the-smartest-microwave-ive-ever-seen https://www.tomsguide.com/news/ges-kitchen-hub-is-the-smarte... My back of the envelope suggests most digital microwaves with a smart defrost but no connectivity are probably more in the 2000 ELO range (i.e. can beat most players but not grandmasters). Mainly due to not having enough storage for large opening/endgame books.
- guhidalg 3y agoI for one welcome measuring compute power in chess ELO over FLOPS. Let's me know which devices I can trounce and which ones to pay respect to.
- SonicScrub 3y agoAgreed. Although my ego might not be able to take it if it turns out I can be outplayed by my IKEA smart lamp.
- ZiiS 3y agoI can program an IKEA smart lamp to be better at chess then I am; I see this as a win.
- ChatGTP 3y agoCurious why you needed to inject the violent overtones in your comment, "curb stomped? We're building tools to help us augment our intelligence, I don't see anyone getting "curb stomped"? If intelligence leads to more violence, then I don't think it will be as useful as we'd have hoped.
- Plyphon_ 3y agoIt's just a turn of phrase that means you got 100% beaten without challenge.
- jjoonathan 3y agoNo, no it isn't. It's a very particular violent act designed to maximize ongoing physical pain and social disadvantage in the victim. Sort of like throwing sulfuric acid at someone's face.
- nyolfen 3y agowait until you hear such idioms as "punched in the gut", "made a killing", etc.
- ChatGTP 3y agoPunched in the gut vs curb stomped...hmmm
- thefurdrake 3y agovs made a killing, hmmm...
- goatlover 3y agoMichael Jordan was a stone-cold killer on the court.
- johnnyworker 3y ago
- somewhereoutth 3y agoExcept that human + computer beats either on their own, known as Centaur Chess.
- theonemind 3y agoeverything so far looks to me like improvements on the pocket calculator, bearing in mind that an order of magnitude difference in scale really still is a difference of kind, they're still orders of magnitude improvements on pocket calculators (which admittedly is something of a different kind). There's a very important particular kind of human intelligence that machines can't seem to do at all, like Einstein discovering general relativity or Fleming discovering antibotics...which sounds like I'm cherry-picking human intelligence at its best, but I'm really pointing out a kind of information synthesis on the basis of reacting to unexpected information. I have trouble articulating it, but I can see that LLMs and chess engines don't do the slightest hint of it. I'll be concerned when machines show the slightest hint of it, but we're playing a ball game in a sphere they can't even touch yet. I'm genuinely continually boggled that people are not seeing this difference and feeling threatened by machine "intelligence", although they are encroaching on something thought uniquely human, and I don't think the brain is doing some kind of information processing that can't be done in any other medium, but the number of connections and kind of processing in the human brain may make it hard with current technology. The number of connections in the brain is staggering, and we certainly can't simulate anything of its scale on the scale of computer we have now, so I don't know what it will take to get any bootstrap on the kind of intelligence computers aren't doing.
- aarong11 3y agoI mean you might think AI can't currently affect humanity but it really does. A lot of people are now using AI to write code and to answer questions they probably should be asking a doctor or lawyer. A lot of people seem to think it's some all knowing and psychic thing and will take its advice blindly.