5 ms·
Falsifiability means that a claim is presented with specifics that could be proven wrong in some universe, not that they have to be shown wrong in this one (whi
by kazinator 3y ago
Falsifiability means that a claim is presented with specifics that could be proven wrong in some universe, not that they have to be shown wrong in this one (which is absurd). You're hanging on to the wrong meaning of "falsify", like to falsify a passport.
One example of something that is not falsifiable is a deductive argument. Deduction isn't science; it is logic. A deductive argument is true regardless of the truth values of its constituent propositions. So in the most literal sense of the world, a deductive argument is not falsifiable.
Another example of non-falsifiability is verbal bunk that refers to poorly defined or undefined concepts. The claims are not specific enough that they can be investigated and found true or false.
E.g. "The world didn't exist yesterday; it came into being moments ago, with everything in it, including all your memories, and all of civilization and its apparent historic record." Okay, great; by what means of investigation can you tell that this is right? If this claim were false, how would the investigation inform you?
Claims about gravity are falsifiable if they are specific and testable. E.g. "If I release this rock, it will move toward the ground and come to rest" is falsifiable because in some imaginary world, it could happen that the rock instead flies up and away when released. The claim is specific: we can construe what kinds of events could be observed which would make it false, like that the opposite of what is predicted happens. If a proposition is falsifiable, and we are not able to find it false, then that gives us confidence that it may be right.
- 10g1k 3y agoThere have been smoke-filled blow-hards in academia for generations, such as Hegel, whose entire opus consisted of deliberately nonsensical word salad, and whose careers in income depended entirely on confusing people in such a way as to seem profound, with word salad intended to be impenetrable and non-specific so nobody could clearly point out the myriad ways they were full of crap. Schopenhauer had a good go at explaining it, if you're interested. Popper was one of those people. He was not a scientist. He never had anything to do with science. He was a sophist. He talked rings around people in such a way that they never knew what the hell he was talking about, but they assumed it must be profound and amazing. Karl Popper himself based his ideas about science not on actual science, but on the philosophies including Marxism and Freudian psychology. Karl Popper's own words: "A theory which is NOT REFUTABLE by any conceivable event is non-scientific." Therefore the theory of gravity is not a scientific theory because nobody has yet conceived of an event or experiment which refutes it. I realise this will cause a negative reflex among those who are addicted to internerding and have held tightly to the unfounded belief (picked up from other internerds) that "Science must be falsifiable!", but it's just not reality. It's just a little thing that people saw on Wikipedia, latched on to, and figured it was really significant and legitimate. But it's just Popper's nonsense. There are plenty of extensive criticisms of Popper's sophistry out there by actual scientists and philosophers. Feel free to read some. As for the scientific method, if you can't do a web search and find out what they actually is, well, nobody can help you.
- kazinator 3y ago> if you can't do a web search A True Scotsman's power web search, not just any old search that lands on some little thing in the Wikipedia or its ilk.
- j16sdiz 3y agoGuess why there are a few branches of philosophy of science do study on this? It go much deeper than that. Falsiblity is not the defining concept of science method. There are quite a few schools on that.
- kazinator 3y agoNobody said it's the defininig concept in the scientific method. It's just a characteristics that scientific claims (by whatever method they were produced) must have. Suppose we have not done any scientific investigation at all yet, and just have a hypothesis about something. That hypothesis should be a falsifiable statement, otherwise it is not something that can be investigated (e.g. by a scientific method). It doesn't define the method, but it defines the characteristics of some of the inputs and outputs.