3 ms·
> But, as the article points out, the impacts of these plastics in real life is completely unknown, and considering that these plastics have literally been in u
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> But, as the article points out, the impacts of these plastics in real life is completely unknown, and considering that these plastics have literally been in use for the better part of a century, that puts a pretty strict upper limit on how bad they can be.
From this we know that they don't instantaneously kill you.
Does it cause cancer? Endocrine disruption? Long-term cognitive issues? That's hard to say, because we don't have much of a control group that hasn't been exposed to these things. But it seems unlikely that it's good for you, and when the cost of avoiding it isn't that high, why volunteer to be a test subject?
- MostlyStable 3y agoThe ceiling on how bad it can be is much _much_ lower than "it doesn't instantaneously kill you". It also doesn't dramatically decrease fertility, or cause significant increases in cancer rates, etc. etc. etc. Any effects it has, by definition, _have_ to be subtle and minor or else we would know. Subtle like "doesn't obviously appear over the course of decades and across tens of millions of people". That is _extremely_ minor. And because I mentioned fertility and two other people have already mentioned sperm counts, I'm gong to get out in front of that one: We aren't even sure sperm counts are actually decreasing [0], let alone that they are caused by plastics [0] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/declining-sperm-count-much-more-than https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/declining-sperm-count-...
- TylerE 3y agoI was with you right up until you mentioned cancer. We haven't understood cancer long enough to know what historical rates actually were, and even if we did, we wouldn't know for sure what a delta (or lack of delta) actually indicates. Like, maybe microplastics are actually pretty cancerous, but overall cancer rates haven't changed that much because as plastics became commonplace, we were getting away from exposure to things like radium and asbestos.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoBut the same is true of all of the other things. Maybe sperm count is actually decreasing, maybe it's just staying the same because microplastics make it worse but getting away from exposure to things like radium and lead and mercury make it better. The best you can say is that we don't know, not that we know it doesn't.
- TylerE 3y agoSperm count you can at least approximate by looking at per-capita birthrates.
- freedomben 3y agoThat's a bad metric because there are many other things that can affect per-capita birthrates. There are birth control products that make it so even the most virile man with an explosive sperm count getting laid isn't going to result in a birth. People have have choosing less and less to have children, and deferring those choices to later in life, and I don't think that has anything to do with microplastics.
- taylodl 3y agoHere's a counterpoint: since the mainstreaming of plastic 100 years ago the average life expectancy has increased dramatically. In the US the average life expectancy was roughly 55 years in 1920, and in 2020 that average life expectancy had increased to over 78 years. Is anyone going to argue that plastic has increased life expectancy? Probably not. But at the same time it's a kind of hard to say plastic is so awful for human health when the average lifespan has increased nearly 50% since the widespread use of plastic. Come to think of it, I think one could make the argument that plastic is prolonging life, but that doesn't necessarily mean plastic should be consumed.