4 ms·
The economic games I've seen all were terrible simulations of markets, and would teach the wrong messages. Monopoly is one such example. (One of its major fault
by WalterBright 3y ago
The economic games I've seen all were terrible simulations of markets, and would teach the wrong messages. Monopoly is one such example. (One of its major faults is one must roll the die and do whatever you land on says.)
I expect a banking simulator would hew to the ubiquitous propaganda that the Fed is there to stabilize the money supply. (It's actual purpose is to inflate the money. See Freidman's "Monetary History of the United States")
- nucleardog 3y ago> One of its major faults is one must roll the die and do whatever you land on says. Monopoly was based on “The Landord’s Game” and was never meant to teach economic decision making. It was meant to promote Georgism and demonstrate the power of landlords, for which that “fault” is a feature.
- WalterBright 3y agoExcept it doesn't actually do that, because the game has all kinds of rules to prevent the functioning of the market.
- HWR_14 3y agoWhat rules prevent the functioning of the market? You mean how it just baked the results of market forces into the rents?
- simple-thoughts 3y agoMarkets are fundamentally about choice and trade offs. Monopoly is about runaway power dynamics created through random chance and force (you have to pay rent, you can’t choose not too).
- HWR_14 3y agoThe market isn't in landing on the properties, it's about buying them, trading them and improving them.
- mrguyorama 3y agoPlease tell me which part of the real economy means you don't HAVE to pay rent
- Obscurity4340 3y agoCan you expand on that?
- WalterBright 3y ago1. you cannot increase the supply of property, or build something bigger than a hotel 2. rents are rules. You cannot be creative with rents. I.e. rent control 3. there are no predictable expenses to owning property 4. the only business you can engage in is property 5. there is no supply & demand at work 6. what properties you acquire is completely random 7. the outcome of the game is controlled by a roll of the dice. There is a strategy to Monopoly, but it is very simple, and soon everyone learns it and that ceases to be a choice 8. Not being able to collect rents on mortgaged properties is quite unlike any actual business 9. No interest is paid on debt The biggest divergence from an actual marketplace is it is designed to be zero-sum. Markets are not zero-sum.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoBut if all players work together and vow to not buy any property, they will just keep accumulating money (the odd card aside) and eventually bankrupt the bank. (I'm aware you can't technically bankrupt the bank but you get the idea).
- WalterBright 3y agoSounds boring to me.
- pyuser583 3y agoWhen I was a kid I played “business simulation” games. You win by taking out lots of debt and getting lucky. Pretty much like real life.
- WalterBright 3y agoYou forgot the part of putting that money to work in a way that returns exceed the cost of debt service.
- Aunche 3y ago> It's actual purpose is to inflate the money ... during economic crisis... to stabilize the money supply.
- WalterBright 3y agoNo, it's to inflate the money whenever the government needs to spend it. Which is what it has done continuously since its inception. The same has happened in every other country that switched to fiat money.
- Aunche 3y agoMonetary policy isn't fiscal policy. Perhaps monetary policy is preventing politicians from facing the consequences of bad fiscal policy, but the alternative is suggesting accelerationism. It's not countries that relied on gold never overspent themselves to ruin.