3 ms·
> There are not "bugs". There are "defects". Priceless, I've been trying make that point for years but nobody seems to want to listen.
by jacquesm 3y ago
> There are not "bugs". There are "defects".
Priceless, I've been trying make that point for years but nobody seems to want to listen.
- resonious 3y agoWhat's the difference? I'm not sure how this renaming would change my behavior.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe difference is that a bug implies that it is an outside influence, a defect is something that has to do with making the thing in the first place. A bug you can see as happenstance, a defect implies liability. Huge difference.
- resonious 3y agoI guess I've over-corrected in the other direction. All of the "bugs" I've ever dealt with were caused by engineers, so perhaps the original meaning (similar to "glitch"?) was lost on me.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe word comes from an insect that got caught in the wiring of one of the earliest vacuum tube computers. This caused the thing to malfunction and removing the insect became 'debugging'... the rest is history. I think it's a fun term but defect is far better for the man made software issues.
- photochemsyn 3y agoA defective device in my mind would have some obviously fatal flaw - it wouldn't even start up, parts would be broken and dangling off, etc. QC immediately rejects it and it doesn't get incorporated into more complex systems. A buggy device is much worse for any critical application - it appears to work under inspection, and even limited testing, but 1% of the time it develops some fatal data race condition that causes it to fail erratically and cause havoc, e.g. the Therac-25. So buggy is a subset of defective but it's even worse?
- zmgsabst 3y agoDefects in, eg, pressure vessels can be hard to spot and then suddenly explode when the product is used — sometimes only after a period of seemingly normal operation. They’re still defects.