3 ms·
This is a race that I earnestly hope either someone wins quickly, or everyone loses... again rather quickly. For incredible claims you typically require incredi
by Simon_O_Rourke 3y ago
This is a race that I earnestly hope either someone wins quickly, or everyone loses... again rather quickly. For incredible claims you typically require incredible evidence, at the moment we're slightly better than hearsay but we've a long way to go get conclusive proof.
- m463 3y ago> everyone loses... again rather quickly that's the thing - if it is hard to manufacture and works maybe 1:10 tries, how can it lose quickly experimentally? In other words, what is a satisfactory proof that it doesn't work, apart from analyzing the original apparatus?
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y ago> that's the thing - if it is hard to manufacture and works maybe 1:10 tries, how can it lose quickly experimentally? Simple, given enough (say > 3) fully accredited labs trying and failing to get a result with the published process, it's a fair conclusion to say that the results cannot be replicated.