3 ms·
Court case here: https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/#!/details?id=ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:11254 https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/#!/details?id=ECLI:NL:RBDH... I fin
by jeroenhd 3y ago
Court case here: https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/#!/details?id=ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:11254 https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/#!/details?id=ECLI:NL:RBDH...
I find court summaries of the Dutch courts to be quite readable. Google translate also seems to work quite well.
It should be noted that this is a "kort geding", which i believe translates to a "preliminary injunction" but I don't have the legal education to say what the differences between the two may be.
Some anonymous user claims that the person who started legal action committed gross sexual misconduct. The judge ruled that there's little evidence to back these claims and that the plaintiff is suffering an impact significant enough to warrant further action.
It should also be noted that Dutch law considers defamation to be a crime (as in, illegal under criminal law), not a civil law issue.
This isn't the first time a company has had to hand over subscriber information because of libel or slander either. I don't really see what the big deal is.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoDunno if this is the case in the Netherlands, but it's worth noting in some legal systems defamation is defined something like spreading harmful accusations as opposed to spreading harmful lies. The intent being that if you have an accusation that is true, you settle it in the courts rather than in the press, with an angry mob, on social media, or the like. Since the whether or not the accusations are true doesn't factor into such a crime, it can be enforced on the presence of harmful accusations alone, which has fairly big implications for the sort of social media witch hunts that we've seen cropping up in the recent decade.
- jorams 3y agoThe Netherlands has both. "Laster" requires the accusation to be untrue. "Smaad" is the broader form that does not require the accusation to be untrue. Justifications defined in the law are "necessary defense" and "common interest". The second one is specified as "believed in good faith that the charges were true and that the public interest required the charge." IANAL, but I think this can apply to social media witch hunts to at least some extent.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThat makes the courts the sole deciders of truth, which is extremely bad in all ways. The press can for example discover and publish evidence of corrupt dealings of a politician, while there is a minimal chance any prosecutor or court would be interested in the case.
- flangola7 3y agoMost Dutch would not agree with this opinion.
- jeltz 3y agoThings like political corruption are exempt from this due to "common interest". So, no, that is not an issue. As a someone from a country with similar law I think it is a good thing. Social media witch hunts are not good for society and they often fall under our defamation laws but people are still allowed to write about corrupt politicians.
- metalcrow 3y agoHave the Netherlands never had a case where the courts ruled against the interests of the public? Or favored the corrupt system? It seems trivial to imagine a case where a rape victim can accuse someone, but the attacker can beat the case by technicalities and then silence their accuser.
- hobo_in_library 3y agoThat's where the "make the accusation in the courts, not the press" rule is most important! If you have a legitimate accusation to make, prosecute. Don't merely complain on social media.
- metalcrow 3y agoMy example was in the case where the prosecution failed unjustly. Or are you allowed to talk about a failed prosecution and still claim that you believe the individual in question did it? Even if so, that also poses a problem in cases where the action was immoral but not illegal, not to mention if the case cannot be prosecuted for financial or other reasons. It's confusing from a US perspective, where we believe free speech is important since it allows the bringing of injustices to light. Are courts in the Netherlands trusted so much that they leave almost no injustices for others to speak out on?
- noirscape 3y ago"Kort geding" is more akin to a small claims court. A preliminary injunction afaict is more of a request to the court for the defendant/plaintiff to stop a certain action until full judgement has been made. A kort geding is a civil court with the specific aim of solving cases that don't require a full blown legal investigation (which can take months). Usually it's either for urgency reasons (ie. public and obvious defamation on public TV need a correction issued very quickly to prevent tarnishing someone's reputation) or because the matter simply isn't that huge (your neighbor cutting the tree on your property down doesn't and shouldn't take a full year to resolve). A kort geding can be escalated into a full legal proceeding if either party is unhappy with the outcome however.
- Someone 3y ago> A kort geding is a civil court with the specific aim of solving cases that don't require a full blown legal investigation (which can take months). FWIW (probably not much; legal terms rarely match 1:1 between jurisdictions), Wikipedia thinks a “kort geding” is a preliminary injunction. https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kort_geding https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kort_geding disagrees with the “don't require a full blown legal investigation” claim, saying that the primary reason is urgency: “Interlocutory proceedings (in Belgium often interim relief or référé) is a short-term civil procedure for urgent cases that by their nature must be decided quickly. […] Matters that by their nature are urgent are, for example, the request to ban a strike or the request to prohibit a publication, because it is incorrect and harms the interests of a directly involved person.” I think that’s more likely to be true. (iOS Translation)