2 ms·
This experiment design feels pretty useless to me. The T-shirts were collected, sealed in plastic bags, and stored at room temperature in the dark, so
by JohnBooty 3y ago
This experiment design feels pretty useless to me.
The T-shirts were collected, sealed in plastic bags,
and stored at room temperature in the dark, so
bacterial growth occurred
[...] The bags were kept at room temperature (20°C)
in the dark for 28 h.
Bad experiment, IMO. This is not a remotely useful approximation of what happens when you are actually wearing and using the clothing.
It's more of a simulation of what happens when you accidentally leave wet sweaty clothes in your gym bag, or are forced to wear sweaty clothes for multiple consecutive days without a wash. (It certainly be nice to have fabrics that could survive such conditions without stinking, I admit)
When actually wearing synthetic "moisture-wicking" fibers, I find they stay much fresher smelling as long as they are exposed to air so that they can actually do their job by encouraging evaporative cooling. As opposed to cotton, which soaks up gallons of sweat and takes ages to fully dry.
Remember, fresh sweat doesn't reek -- that's why you don't smell bad in a sauna, with fresh sweat pouring out of every pore. It's stale sweat that reeks. Specifically, it is the waste products of bacteria living in stale sweat. That is what eventually smells bad.
- Eisenstein 3y ago> This is not a remotely useful approximation of what happens when you are actually wearing and using the clothing. They are trying to correlate materials with biological growth that causes BO in clothes in order to find out if certain types of material or treatments to material could be used to construct activewear that doesn't stink when you sweat in it. What about the process seems useless to that end?
- JohnBooty 3y agoThe benefit of "moisture-wicking" synthetic materials is that they promote evaporative cooling relative to cotton, which tends to retain more water and takes longer to dry. In this experiment they've placed sweaty clothing into sealed bags for 28h before studying them, so that's pretty different than real-world usage. I will admit, though: if they cook up a fabric that stays fresh after such a torture test it should certainly perform well in the real world.