4 ms·
These days, would you use any public WiFi? Even on extended travel, I carry a portable router that plugs into the hotel/stay router/port and then use my own Wi-
by Brajeshwar 3y ago
These days, would you use any public WiFi? Even on extended travel, I carry a portable router that plugs into the hotel/stay router/port and then use my own Wi-Fi. Yes, I do have VPN/DNS filter/protection etc on the Phone but you have "too many devices" that will pick that up and every one of them will try to connect to that WiFi. Easier to take care of a Laptop but it becomes a hassle/irritant.
For India, Internet over the phone is so cheap (and OK quality) that most people don't care about WiFi outside of their home/office.
Would love to know more how you deal with these situations?
- nunez 3y agoYes but I use Tailscale and route through my exit node
- delta_p_delta_x 3y agoWhere I live, most of the mass rapid transit stations are underground, and connection is sometimes spotty. The country has launched a secure public Wi-Fi service. Users on smartphones can authenticate using EAP-SIM[1], or laptop users can use an app developed by the agency to authenticate with WPA2 Enterprise PEAP MSCHAPv2. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensible_Authentication_Protocol#EAP_Subscriber_Identity_Module_(EAP-SIM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensible_Authentication_Prot...
- xobs 3y agoThe implementation here is rather annoying, because as soon as you enter the tunnel the wifi cuts off. But there's a 10-15 second latency where network connections just fail as the phone decides the AP is actually gone before it cuts over to LTE. Then the whole process repeats again once you get to the next station. Since LTE is usually reliable even in the tunnel, I usually remove the wifi connection. Granted it might help that I don't normally travel during peak hour, so the mobile network is usually fine for my needs. It's made even more annoying by the fact that "Forgetting" the connection only works until the phone is rebooted, at which point the behaviour returns.
- TheHappyOddish 3y ago> It's made even more annoying by the fact that "Forgetting" the connection only works until the phone is rebooted, at which point the behaviour returns. That seems odd. My phone doesn't connect to a network unless it's toggled to auto join, and certainly not post "forget". Can you not control this?
- toast0 3y agoI'm not familiar with the networks in question, but I've run into a couple wifi networks connected to my lte carrier, and my unlocked phone pushes them hard. I imagine there's something coming from the SIM, and I could see the OS picking up SIM affiliated wifi networks on boot or sim insertion. Unless special care were taken, it makes sense that forgetting a network isn't remembered.
- xobs 3y agoAs far as I can tell, it's because the configuration comes from EAP-SIM (https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/RFC4186 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/RFC4186) which gets refreshed on every reboot. This cannot be controlled - it will always regenerate when you restart the phone.
- lmm 3y ago> These days, would you use any public WiFi? These days I treat my home network the same as a public network. Too many "smart" devices to be worth trusting, so the devices I care about are locked down the same as they would be if I connected them directly to the internet - and sometimes I do. Frankly I have more trust that I can keep my phone or laptop up to date than any consumer-grade router (do you know which version of linux it's running? How often do you even get updates?)
- pclmulqdq 3y agoPutting IoT devices on your guest network is a very common home security/privacy thing to do. They very often snoop when they can, and your router shuts that down on the guest network.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoI want my router to allow my IOT devices to send out mDNS beacons, and for other devices to connect to them, but otherwise they're restricted and logged. This is an order of magnitude more complex than I trust a home router to do, though...
- bdavbdav 3y agoEven on my UniFi gear its still a bit of a faff every time a manufacturer does it slightly differently (and still raises my suspicions when controlling google home devices doesn't work / not receiving mDNS broadcasts etc).
- Caligatio 3y agoBeyond mDNS "snooping", has there been reporting of non-compromised IoT inappropriately listening on networks? To be clear, I agree that putting IoT devices on a separate VLAN is a good idea but I do that because they're black boxes, not because they're malicious.
- TheJoeMan 3y ago
- nine_k 3y agoYes, I pretty often use WiFi in airports overseas, because roaming data rates are not fun (or data does not work), and whatever slice of free access the airport WiFi allows is usually enough to check mail and connecting flights, chat a bit over IM, upload a few photos, sometimes even review a PR or push a PR. Hotel WiFi is usually so-so, even paid, but still much better than 10 years ago.
- gumby 3y agoIn India you need a local phone number just to use wifi. I think this is a law
- midasuni 3y agoI get free international roaming nowadays, but 5 years ago I was in China and accidentally plugged my phone in to my laptop to charge. Laptop started syncing something that had been blocked all week (Dropbox maybe), and the SMS flooded in. The connection was so fast that within a minute or two I got the following message: From Vodafone: So far you've used 83MB of data today in our Rest of World Zone, and spent £255. It'll cost £15 for each additional 5MB you use. We'll next let you know when you've spent £495 today but, if you'd prefer us not to, please contact your account administrator. Sent OCT 15 @10:45 UK
- mulmen 3y agoThe network is compromised. Any other assumption is lunacy. This is why we have TLS. Plugging your own WiFi into a hostile network (read: any) does precisely fuckall to improve your security.
- ahoka 3y agoYou can filter out broadcast, multicast and other kind of link local nastyness. Also a single tunnel obscures traffic if one’s super secretive.
- gumby 3y agoThis is the way. Also good for those hotels/conference centers that give you a small number of “allowable” devices — when you have kids with multiple devices, maybe a game console, etc plus maybe an appletv you quickly run out. Instead the router authenticates and that’s that. I terminate my VPN at one of my own machines mainly for (marginal) security but conveniently this lets me stream the same stuff as home since the services can’t tell the exit is a VPN
- Fnoord 3y agoYes, I would. I use Wireguard client with kill switch. If I don't have a Wireguard connection, nothing works. The only caveat is the Wireguard server runs on my home connection. If down, 'my internet is down'. If slow, 'my internet is slow'. But actually it appears to be pretty reliable. Another downside is all the traffic is tunneled through my home IPv4 and I might not want other people to know such. But that too seems to be an edge case. Against a possibly hostile or hacked WLAN network which I decide to use, it works fine, though I generally use it over mobile (which I've configured to only use LTE / 5G NR, not lower as these are easier to MITM and I don't want a downgrade attack although in theory in such a case, too, Wireguard client w/killswitch would protect).
- ceejayoz 3y agoI’ve never had issues with four phones and two laptops on Hilton wifi when we travel as a family.
- DistractionRect 3y agoI do something similar, with a router flashed with openwrt. If there's a physical router/ethernet port I can plug into great, if not I run one of the radios in client mode to connect to the wifi. All traffic is secured with wireguard to my home router, and then goes through my ISP. The wireguard tunnel is wrapped in an error correcting tunnel; it makes a huge difference on the usability a lot of public APs.
- muppetman 3y agoEdit: I apologise I see you have answered this below. What is your error correcting tunnel? Given that Wireguard is UDP and that any tunneled TCP that gets dropped should just be handled by TCP, why encapsulate Wireguard in something else? I certainly find Wireguard itself improves many Public Wifi networks, I've never thought to encapsulate it further.
- DistractionRect 3y ago> any tunneled TCP that gets dropped should just be handled by TCP, why encapsulate Wireguard in something else? That's the thing, TCP doesn't really handle lossy connections well. A moderate lossy link might do udp traffic like video fine, but be practically unusable for TCP traffic.
- Helmut10001 3y agoI think these setups are fantastic. Here [1] I wrote about my IPSEC-setup on a portable private Wifi network based on a Protectli that I connected to someone's Wifi. [1]: https://du.nkel.dev/blog/2021-11-19_pfsense_opnsense_ipsec_cgnat/ https://du.nkel.dev/blog/2021-11-19_pfsense_opnsense_ipsec_c...
- bane 3y agoOut of curiosity how do you deal with situations where the public wifi has one of those middle pages that you have to type in or click something (captive portal?) before the access point grants access?
- 3y ago