5 ms·
The underlying hostile technology is "remote attestation" and it's what we should all be fighting against. People justify the latter by speaking about companie
by userbinator 3y ago
The underlying hostile technology is "remote attestation" and it's what we should all be fighting against.
People justify the latter by speaking about companies wanting control over employees' environments, but IMHO that shouldn't be allowed either. This is also why "zero trust" is problematic; they want to replace humanity with centralised control.
- fruitreunion1 3y agoI think in internal environments like within a company it's fine. Just not in the public, user-facing web.
- QuantumG 3y agoYeah, cryptography is bad and consumers shouldn't be allowed to prove their browser hasn't been modified or have safety when using biometrics or making payments.
- userbinator 3y ago"modified" according to whom? Users should be able to use software the way they want, not the way Big Tech dictates. Governments are scared because they realise cryptography is being used against them. Now users should realise the same. Strong encryption is classified as a weapon for good reason. Just like you'd want a gun in your hands, but not one pointed at you. Then again, the fact that you call them "consumers" instead of "users" already shows what side of the debate you're on.
- QuantumG 3y agoI'm sorry but there's a class of users who want to be able to prove they haven't made modifications and they refer to themselves as consumers. They're the people who don't jailbreak their devices for exactly that reason and this protocol will support them. Oh, and they happen to be the bulk of the users.
- Zuiii 3y ago> I'm sorry but there's a class of users who want to be able to prove they haven't made modifications and they refer to themselves as consumers. [..] Oh, and they happen to be the bulk of the users. No they don't. No single person on this planet wants this. What they want is to be allowed to buy/stream/consume stuff with as little friction as possible. You're barking up the wrong tree mate.
- QuantumG 3y agoYou know how you can pay for stuff at stores with your phone? That didn't just magically happen. It wasn't just "the technology got better" or whatever you tell yourself. That was called Tokenization and what made it possible was cryptographic hardware being rolled out to the masses. They love this stuff.
- always2slow 3y agoYou've got this all backwards and you even proved their point. People don't _love_ tokenization, or DRM whatever. They LOVE the removal of friction, like buying things with their phone removes friction of carrying a wallet or a card or whatever I guess. On the other hand DRM makes things easier on the company, but as a consumer I don't really give a fuck about them or what extra work it causes them. In fact, they better have to do something otherwise I'm not paying for anything and they're just collecting rent for something I should be able to attain for free.
- QuantumG 3y agoDRM makes it possible for customers to rent products they don't want to own. If that isn't "removing friction" I dunno what is. Tokenization similarly makes it possible to buy stuff and not have to worry about what the merchant will do with your info. All possible because of cryptography hardware. The alternative is subscription platforms, where the payments happen behind the curtain.
- 3y ago