5 ms·
Exports only help if new services support imports. And some of those wouldn't be particularly helpful; @tags would lose a lot of meaning as you migrate, especi
by pavel_lishin 3y ago
Exports only help if new services support imports.
And some of those wouldn't be particularly helpful; @tags would lose a lot of meaning as you migrate, especially if others on the destination platform already have that handle.
- klardotsh 3y ago@tags are just one of many features, and the lack of a matching user on the import side isn't a critical issue: a link back to the original post instead suffices. And regardless, Twitter-alikes aren't the only thing worth considering. Exporting all of one's video data from YouTube, or all of one's comments from Reddit, or all of one's search history (and Google Voice texts, and Docs documents, and etc.) from Google are all usecases that fall under these data moats that are useful to be able to take with you and move to another service. There's probably more usecases I'm not even thinking of, but the point is that by exposing all the data by mandate, we don't have to be limited by the imagination of today, we have the data, we can build whatever future frontends and replacement services and etc. we want.
- arielcostas 3y agoTo be fair, Google is one of the few services that best support taking your data away by using their "Google Takeout" tool. YouTube videos, Photos, whatever, downloaded from a single website in ZIPs, TARs or whatever. Microsoft doesn't have such tool for OneDrive, Outlook or their services in general, so downloading 1D docs means going to the website, selecting then and pressing "download". For Outlook emails... well, good luck
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoYet even Google itself lacks import capabilities, even for the very portable export formats they generate. And this is understandable, because en masse imports are undoubtedly a security issue. As for OneDrive and Outlook exports, if only there were a way to synchronize data to a client. Oh well.
- arielcostas 3y ago> Yet even Google itself lacks import capabilities, even for the very portable export formats they generate. And this is understandable, because en masse imports are undoubtedly a security issue. Depends... Under their POV, why would anyone want to import stuff to a Google account en masse if they already have it on their "original" acc? > As for OneDrive and Outlook exports, if only there were a way to synchronize data to a client. Oh well. There are OneDrive clients for Windows, Android (and I guess Apple systems too), but it's still less convenient than downloading a single ZIP. Using the official client means I need to copy the stuff to my local drive first, and then compress it if I want to store it in a more efficient way.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago> why would anyone want to import stuff to a Google account I have 3 personal Google accounts, and that doesn't count my work and school Google accounts. It is conceivable that I'd want to move at least a few things around among them. Also, it is conceivable that someone could write up a utility that prepped arbitrary types of data for import into an arbitrary Google property. Whether it's JSON or XML or whatever, I could see there being use cases for importing data that has not yet been in a Google account at all.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Google is one of the few services that best support taking your data away by using their "Google Takeout" tool. YouTube videos, Photos, whatever, downloaded from a single website in ZIPs, TARs or whatever. Agreed. The bigger issue is relying on a broadcast-esque provider as your sole storer of video. If your account gets blocked somehow (or locked out) then you're done for. Have a separate, storage-only video account and push to YouTube as well.
- arielcostas 3y agoYeah, I mean, you should totally store your videos somewhere that can't lock you out for no reason. Whether that is a hard drive, an S3 glacier bucket (which I believe must give you at least 24 hours warning before they can cut you off) or anything else, you should keep a copy that you and only you control, instead of being at Google's mercy.
- poisonborz 3y agoExports help always. Someone in the future could write a tool. Someone can finance writing a tool. AI could be used to create a tool.
- veave 3y ago>Exports only help if new services support imports. Of course I can understand why a service wouldn't want you to be able to post thousands of posts in a matter of minutes, or to fake timestamps, or... The whole idea of massively importing stuff is complete nonsense.
- kelnos 3y agoFair-ish. Certainly some types of services have an incentive to allow you to import, as a way of making it easier to move to them. Like an email hosting service would want to make it easy for you to move your old emails to them when switching. I could understand why a Twitter alternative might not want you to be able to import a ton of old posts at once. But this is why we need open standards and open source. Some random large Mastodon instance might not want to allow imports, but you should at the very least have the option to spin up your own instance, import all your old Twitter posts, and still participate in the ecosystem. As others have pointed out, an @tag can still be useful by linking back to the original service. Or the importer can support a username mapping so it can rewrite names from the old service to names to the new service. Sure, all of this requires extra work, but it can be possible if people care enough. Regardless, export functionality at the old service is the first necessary step. Even if there's no import on the other side now, someone might build one eventually. And even if that never happens, being able to archive your old data is useful by itself.