6 ms·
> “If he contacts me asking for removal, I'll remove this.” Lykon said. My interpretation of the article is that the entire reason this person created this was
by neilv 3y ago
> “If he contacts me asking for removal, I'll remove this.” Lykon said.
My interpretation of the article is that the entire reason this person created this was because the artist had objected to being in a generative model. When the artist was removed from the popular generative model, this person created a model/tuning specifically to put the artist back into one, and distributed it. They seemed to do this well aware that the artist didn't want to be in a generative model.
That sounds aggressively adversarial and abusive, and so the quote above sounds disingenuous.
Consider the analogy of a bully who is hitting a victim, and the bully demands that the victim ask the bully nicely to please stop. Humiliating the victim, and making the victim acknowledge the bully's power over them. Also, this is only after much damage is already done to the victim. And, in this case, after the bully has called over a mob to also beat the victim, and knowing that, even if the bully stops, the mob will continue.
The person in this case might not have the self-image of a bully, but is instead thinking of it as the usual Internet get-out-of-jail-free card: such as when you post someone else's content, when you're pretty sure they don't want you to, and without even trying to get permission, but you think it's all OK if you say "I'll take this down if they ask me to". (Related: The YouTube copyright violation disclaimer "I don't own this! All rights to the owner!", maybe even referencing the "All rights reserved" of a traditional copyright notice.)
Wherever you stand philosophically on copyright and related matters, and whatever jurisdiction and economic conditions you're under, it's maybe also helpful to consider the bullying question. One can stray into that accidentally, and that's harder to justify.
- arjun_krishna1 3y agobased
- wccrawford 3y agoIf this person was genuine, they would have asked permission first. It wasn't like they had to ask a lot of people who are hard to contact. Just 1 person. I'd have had more respect for this person if they'd just said "Sorry not sorry." instead.
- olaulaja 3y agoThe thing is, most styles don't have names, only artists using them. If you remove artist names from the training data, you lose the ability to describe those styles, including as combinations (so you can't even do "influenced by rutkowski" styles). This obviously sucks for the user, and I don't think artists should be able to deny control over style just because it makes imitation easy. In this context, putting an artist back in the model is a pretty sensible form of disagreement/protest. I admit the "I'll take this down if they ask me to" is strange, but mostly because its too weak; the LoRA should just stay up, not demand another no from someone who already made their opinion clear.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> If you remove artist names from the training data, you lose the ability to describe those styles Do you? With base SD1.5, “by greg rutkowski” produces extremely similar results to “detailed realistic muted fantasy”. Except for the case where what you are actually trying to do is directly mimic the work of an artist with a strong unique style that is very heavily represented in the source data (Rutkowski, IIRC, has extremely little representation in the SD training data, leaving aside question of whether the other parts of that description apply), I don’t think you are losing the ability to refer to styles without artist names.
- caconym_ 3y ago> most styles don't have names If you want to educate yourself on how to refer to different art styles you can start here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_art_movements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_art_movements > If you remove artist names from the training data, you lose the ability to describe those styles It's almost as if artists develop their own styles that are just as uniquely theirs as any one work produced by them in that style, if not more so! When people put "by Greg Rutkowski" in their AI art prompts, they are not asking for results in a style that exists independently of Greg Rutkowski despite his name somehow being the only way to identify it. They are, in fact, asking for results in the style of Greg Rutkowski in the sense that works by Greg Rutkowski were labeled as such and fed into the training process, programmatically creating a digest of works by (at least) Greg Rutkowski that we call a "model", and that model is as a result capable of mimicking the style of Greg Rutkowski specifically. They are asking for results that look like they were painted by Greg Rutkowski, and they care enough to ask for Greg Rutkowski specifically because Greg Rutkowski is a highly skilled artist who developed his own distinctive style which is the central pillar of his intellectual property as an artist, and his competitive advantage. Intellectual property law as it stands today obviously couldn't have anticipated this technology, and didn't. However, if this kind of thing is still legal in ten years, that will represent a major systemic failure of copyright and trade secrets law to protect the core intellectual property of artists in the same spirit as it currently protects intellectual property in other domains.
- thulle 3y agoI think Civitai, where the Rutkowski LoRa is hosted and where the screenshot in the article is from, in part set the tone during the earlier conflict with Sam Yang/@samdoesarts. I think Yang posted about someone on r/StableDiffusion making a LoRa trained on his work, which prompted Civitai to host a contest to see who could make the best samdoesarts-model. And send him a mail: https://files.catbox.moe/adyb0x.png https://files.catbox.moe/adyb0x.png