4 ms·
At Caltech, I had the opportunity to get to know a real genius or two. They are for real. Hal Finney was one. There were no discernible environmental or cultur
by WalterBright 3y ago
At Caltech, I had the opportunity to get to know a real genius or two. They are for real.
Hal Finney was one. There were no discernible environmental or cultural factors at play. He was just off the charts.
- fragmede 3y agoI've had the opportunity to meet a few too. Thing is, privilege looks that way. Would a Hal Finney, crippled from debt since childhood, a drug habit, a total lack of a high school education, never mind CalTech, and traumatized from a horrible childhood, with an abusive alcoholic deadbeat father who never worked an honest day in his life, instead of being a petroleum engineer; would that Hal Finney still be Hal FInney, world renowned computer scientist who helped develop Bitcoin, among other achievements, and who later developed ALS from which he later passed? You are entitled to your own opinion. I never met the guy. I don't disbelieve his genius, but I have my doubts that there weren't invisible environmental and cultural factors at play to get him to where he was.
- entropicgravity 3y agoAnd then there's Walter Pitts. Imagine what else he might have done if he grew up in a nuturing environment.
- WalterBright 3y ago> A drug habit That is self-imposed. You can destroy anything with drugs. If you'd spent some time with Hal, you would know he's an innate genius, not created by his environment.
- fragmede 3y agoThe visibility of his genius to us is a result of his environment though. If Hal (whom, I reiterate, I never had the pleasure of meeting, though I have had the pleasure of working with some that I would consider geniuses) was born brown, into the kind of upbringing where he had a drug habit (self-imposed or otherwise), and was never deeply exposed to computers at all (eminently possible back then), never finished high school, never mind CalTech. His innate genius could still be there, but hidden behind a haze of drugs, depression, and mental illness, living homeless on the streets, how would we know it? Even harnessed, his genius in a different environment would have lead him to be Richard Dawkins or Linus Pauling or Walter White, and not Hal Finney.
- WalterBright 3y agoIn a word, nope. There was another fellow in the dorm, Renee, who was a genius, too. He was brown. It's a very humbling experience being around these two. You cannot train that into people. Few Caltech freshmen were exposed to computers. This was 1975. > drugs Again with the drugs. Drugs destroy your mind, they are irrelevant to what I'm talking about. I know of no drugs that will turn you into a genius. A little story about Hal. Hal rarely bothered to ever go to class. He'd pick up the textbook at the end of the semester, flip through it, and would ace the exam. Again and again and again. He did not know this material beforehand. It was just effortless to him. Renee, too. Me, and most everyone else, had to work very hard all through the semester to have a hope of passing the final. No, environment doesn't create geniuses. They are born that way.
- fragmede 3y agoDrugs are something that you've acknowledged as being able to tear down a brilliant mind, so I keep bringing it up to illustrate how its about the environment. It would be great if there was a drug to turn you into a genius, we'd all be on it! (Erdos comes to mind. There is also research with magnetic fields and brains being done that looks promising.) Being brought up by a narcissistic mother, a selfish father, and a broken home environment would do just as much, if not more, harm to somebody as drugs could, but is much harder to see. What drove him to go to CalTech, and not MIT? Or CSUN? Or even let him graduate high school? How did that education even get paid for? Where would he be if he couldn't have afforded it; if there were no loans to take out? If he'd had a drinking problem and then slept through his exams? No amount of smarts could help him pass the test he wasn't there to take. I don't ask this to tear the man down, may he rest in peace. I ask to challenge your notion that geniuses are just born that way. There's absolutely a genetic component, and they are born that way, but in the wrong environment, they fail to launch. Genius needs to be nurtured and cared for, in just the right way, to happen, and when it happens, it's magical. To put an extreme example upon that, if the environment lead to him being shot dead at the age of seven, we'd be talking about someone else.
- WalterBright 3y ago