3 ms·
I think you're right. There's a lot of comments I've responded to and the alignment isn't always clear who's responding to what, so I use context to fill in the
by godelski 3y ago
I think you're right. There's a lot of comments I've responded to and the alignment isn't always clear who's responding to what, so I use context to fill in the gap. My bad. You are totally right about your comment making more sense haha. (I'm known to be an idiot, so people should question if you really want me reviewing your papers lol) But as your last line is suggesting, I think this is just a human thing and when a comment gets a lot of attention and someone tries to respond to a lot of different people. Too many trains of thought to juggle around in a format that isn't super explicit. It's why I like my code to have colors and group chats to have colored bubbles for identification. I need the aid lol.
> In reality the real peer review is in the back and forth discussions within the community, spread out over many papers, and sometimes even over generations.
This is 100% what I believe and I'm surprised others don't. Like how arxiv exists because people were already sharing papers outside the walls of journals. For some reason people are acting like this sharing means these are drafts rather than the actual publications themselves. As if arxiv and what's published are different versions. Maybe a lot of non researchers are participating in these discussions and assuming things?
I'm sure you know this, but others might not. Newton is the perfect example here because many of the works at these times were "published" years or even decades after the original work was done. Which is the whole Leibniz and Newton debate thing. I'd also highly recommend the podcast "Opinionated History of Mathematics". It's hilarious and well done. By a mathematician but for the general nerdy public
https://intellectualmathematics.com/opinionated-history-of-mathematics/ https://intellectualmathematics.com/opinionated-history-of-m...