10 ms·
Genius minds are rare but not that rare. Everyone is much better educated than they used to be too. So a lack of geniuses can't have anything to do with the peo
by roenxi 3y ago
Genius minds are rare but not that rare. Everyone is much better educated than they used to be too. So a lack of geniuses can't have anything to do with the people who get labelled as such. Similarly, as the article points out, genius does not appear to be a result of economic forces. Therefore I imagine 'geniuses' are made when the cultural conditions are ripe for people to sit around listening to each other and trying to improve. That is, the culture of the listeners than the nature of the speaker.
It is conspicuous how little time human society puts in to identifying and then learning from its most capable members. The academy is the big exception, but people generally only get exposure to academic thinking when they are young and in a poor position to influence the world.
- RajT88 3y ago> Genius minds are rare but not that rare. We only believe certain time periods had more, because of the lasting impacts of many of those people. Why did geniuses during these periods exercise so much cultural force? Probably just good timing, based on where that society was at. The author probably has the "cart before the horse".
- BSEdlMMldESB 3y ago> Why did geniuses during these periods exercise so much cultural force? because of "historical leverage". the same basic idea as a lever but instead of 'amplifying' over space, it does so over time.
- theelous3 3y agoWhen society is so imbalanced in terms of intellectual opportunity, and the fields so green for those few who have the chance, of course those few will have such a lasting impact. Furthermore, if we were to say, rate these people out of 10 on the potential-to-make-breakthroughs scale, I would expect that any time a 9 or 10 comes along, that contemporary 6, 7, and 8s who may not have made some initial leap will be at the ready to drive that progress forward. Clustering of geniuses seems natural, given we typically rate someone's genius by their contributions rather than their standalone grey wattage. It would be surprising if some Norwegian was building off greek philosophy principles back in the day. It's not at all surprising that Greek contemporaries and their students did the same, some of which are then labeled "genius".
- sdwr 3y agoThat's the flip side of pointless bureaucracy, wheel-spinning and busywork. When something properly important comes along, everyone is ready to make it happen.
- nathias 3y ago> academy is the big exception sweet innocence
- zh3 3y agoNote that when most people were poorly educated, those able and motivated to self-educate would stand out more. So could it be that the level necessary be considered a 'genius' has increased over time, as a result of most people being so much better educated than in the past? Effectively, narrowing the gap between them and those considered genius-level?
- Izkata 3y agoI'd pretty much agree with that, with the possible distinction that the gap may not have narrowed exactly, but they have less opportunity to show it. The difference is time scale rather than ability: This may sound weird or arrogant, but I have notebooks from back in school where I got bored and ended up on my way to inventing basic calculus concepts a year or two before I was introduced to them. Given enough time I'm sure I would have gone further, but then I took the classes before having the chance.