4 ms·
All this drama greatly reduces the likelihood this will turn out well.
by pfdietz 3y ago
All this drama greatly reduces the likelihood this will turn out well.
- yellow_postit 3y agoI was thinking the opposite — all the posturing, fighting for credit, all seem like they truly believe they have something. Still believe the safe bet is this is spurious. But it’s some drama that feels a lot more enjoyable and less consequential than most things in the news recently.
- bandyaboot 3y agoObviously the drama isn’t great. One thing that piqued by interest from this story though is that after the initial paper was shoved out the door to arxiv, you had this other guy HyunTak who didn’t think the paper was ready and who is apparently well known. He apparently then thinks it’s worth it to push his own version out presumably so his name is attached to the work. Perhaps it’s good sign that he appears to be that motivated to have is name tied to this? I may be grasping at straws because I want this to be the real deal…
- ChuckMcM 3y agoThe drama does give it kind of a cold fusion vibe. But the motivation of the "industry guy" is pretty text book. If you wanted to scam your way into a Nobel Prize this might be a way to do it right? Still I don't think the Nobel committee would buy it but who knows right? Going to be really an interesting August and even if it doesn't pan out to be "superconducting" the theory is one that leads to more structural investigations into crystal structures that "might".
- pfdietz 3y agoThe Nobel Prize committee would do nothing unless this was well confirmed. There is no "scamming them".
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoMight want to ask Rosalind Franklin about that (you’ll need a ouija board).
- readthenotes1 3y ago[flagged]
- dredmorbius 3y agoNobels are not awarded posthumously.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI'm sure that's the only reason. I have a friend that worked for years at CSH. Watson is an ... interesting ... chap. Good at bringing in the money, though. It's amazing how we can be quite forgiving of people that make money. Maybe there's an [ig] Nobel prize for me, if I can figure out why.
- dredmorbius 3y agoRather than skirting around the issue with vague insinuations, how about if you commit to a specific reason why the Nobel Committee would violate its proscription on posthumous awards, in this specific case?
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoNah, I'm fine with the vague insinuations. Have a great day!
- CamperBob2 3y agoThere are countless examples of people who clearly deserved to win or share a Nobel but were overlooked by the committee. But can anyone think of a hard-science laureate who arguably should not have won? Note the "hard science" qualification -- obviously the Peace and Literature prizes have a controversial history, but disregard those for the moment.
- TechBro8615 3y agoWhy? It has no impact on the validity of the results, and as others have mentioned, the fact scientists are engaging in drama arguably makes it more likely they believe in the results. The drama is about receiving credit for the work, not rushing fraudulent results.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt makes it less likely this was the result of careful scientific work. It increases the likelihood there was a screwup somewhere. The more outrageous a result, the more likely that was anyway.
- loxias 3y agoI don't care about any of this drama. I could be wrong but as I understand it the claim is that lanarkite and copper phosphide, when ground together at a 1:1 ratio, sealed under vacuum in a quartz tube, and heated to 925C, become a *room temperature superconductor*. This claim is incredible and verifiable, so much so that it annoys me to hear any side chatter. We should know "soon" (c.f. https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/breaking-superconductor-news https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/breaking-supercond...)
- xeromal 3y agoI don't know anything about science but it sounds like from your comment that the best thing about this claim is that it's not smoke and mirrors. It either works or it doesn't and there are a set of instructions that shows how to do it.
- loxias 3y agoYup. It either works or it doesn't. Unlike many other claims, this one doesn't require anything rare or super hard to do. The furnace, tubes, materials, could be bought for around $10k. I'm only a hobbyist scientist. When I saw the pre-print my first thought was "if this works, why the f- haven't we noticed before!? Someone should have done this accidentally freshman year!" The good news is we shouldn't have to wait long. The bad news is that we have to wait at all.
- hilbertseries 3y agoVery different than the six years it took before the mathematics community found a flaw in Mochizuki‘a abc conjecture proof.
- renewiltord 3y agoHaha I have that bias too but CRISPR had insane drama.