3 ms·
> Agree or not with that judge but he makes a good point about favouring the validity of an argument over the ability of the debater. This is not correct; for
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
> Agree or not with that judge but he makes a good point about favouring the validity of an argument over the ability of the debater.
This is not correct; for an argument to be valid, the conclusion must follow from the premises.
That judge is saying he will vote based on the conclusion regardless of the premises.