4 ms·
>Or rather, if you do the labor, you don't get to have it. Labor is just another input that goes into making a product. I don't see why they should be entitled
by gruez 3y ago
>Or rather, if you do the labor, you don't get to have it.
Labor is just another input that goes into making a product. I don't see why they should be entitled to perpetual income any more than the company that supplied the film should be entitled to perpetual income. If you want perpetual income, create your own enterprise, or become an investor yourself. Most of the headline members of the AMPTP are public companies.
- pluto_modadic 3y agothis is a good argument for not letting companies have perpetual IP based income :)
- gruez 3y ago1. Outside of trademarks, "IP" typically isn't "perpetual". Copyrights last a long time, but they're not perpetual either. 2. If you sell a widget, that item gets irreversibly transferred to the buyer. If you sell your time (ie. what you're doing as an employee) the same thing happens with your time. If you "sell" a movie, that doesn't happen. Well, technically that happens all the time between companies, but doesn't apply to the typical consumer transaction. "perpetual IP based income" is a way to make products that are infinitely copyable have a viable business model. Otherwise if you want to watch a movie, you'll have to pay for the whole thing.
- lapcat 3y ago> Copyrights last a long time, but they're not perpetual either. For the creators, copyright is effectively perpetual. It expires eventually, but rarely until after you're dead. "As a general rule, for works created after January 1, 1978, copyright protection lasts for the life of the author plus an additional 70 years. For an anonymous work, a pseudonymous work, or a work made for hire, the copyright endures for a term of 95 years from the year of its first publication or a term of 120 years from the year of its creation, whichever expires first." https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html
- lapcat 3y ago> I don't see why they should be entitled to perpetual income any more than the company that supplied the film should be entitled to perpetual income. Why do you think of it in terms of "entitlement". Residuals were negotiated between actors, writers, and the studios. Just like stock options are negotiated for some software engineering jobs, for example. And many companies in various industries have forms of employee profit sharing. This is no different. The issue here is that the market has changed, and the preexisting deal for residuals didn't take into account the streaming services. So the writers and actors are naturally looking to renegotiate the terms. What's wrong with that? It's a contract negotiation. Now, if you want to completely overturn capitalism and institute some kind of Marxist labor theory of value, we can argue over that, but it seems a bit tangential here.
- gruez 3y ago>Why do you think of it in terms of "entitlement". Because that's the angle that the OP was going for, pointing out how it's some sort of injustice that capital gets a perpetual income stream but labor doesn't.
- lapcat 3y ago> Because that's the angle that the OP was going for, pointing out how it's some sort of injustice that capital gets a perpetual income stream but labor doesn't. Well, "injustice" aside, doesn't it seem somewhat arbitrary, inconsistent, bizarre to be ok with capitalists having perpetual income from their products while ridiculing labor (the "snarky shots fired at you") for wanting perpetual income from their products too? You said this, which seems to deny even the possibility of perpetual income for anyone except the owning class: > If you want perpetual income, create your own enterprise, or become an investor yourself.
- scarface_74 3y ago> Well, "injustice" aside, doesn't it seem somewhat arbitrary, inconsistent, bizarre to be ok with capitalists having perpetual income from their products while ridiculing labor If I bought a car and used it to drive for Uber are you okay with paying the factory workers a share of your income? If you owned a mom and pop restaurant should the people who built the restaurant get a share of your profits? If you started a software business are you okay with the authors of every library you used getting a share of your profits?