5 ms·
Who would have guessed... the problem is that police and especially police unions became behemoths in themselves, effectively being ungovernable and unauditable
by mschuster91 3y ago
Who would have guessed... the problem is that police and especially police unions became behemoths in themselves, effectively being ungovernable and unauditable. And you can't even change that because police can simply refuse to do their job without any repercussions and have done so multiple times [1].
Under the current set of rules, ACAB until proven otherwise. Police, in terms of the institution police, the theories behind policing, and its staff, need to be torn down completely and replaced by something entirely new, based on an actual legally defined purpose which was democratically decided and with clear metrics, transparency and accountability on all levels. No charlatans like Dave Grossman ("Killology") and his ilk should be allowed anywhere near a police precinct.
[1] https://www.propublica.org/article/what-can-mayors-do-when-the-police-stop-doing-their-jobs https://www.propublica.org/article/what-can-mayors-do-when-t...
- inamberclad 3y agoI find it amazing that the police of a given city will protest anything they think is unfair refusing to work. How is this not armed mutiny?
- influx 3y agoI was with you until you used the inflammatory ACAB term. It’s incredibly offensive and doesn’t help your argument.
- kacesensitive 3y ago[flagged]
- gruez 3y agoSo? How is that relevant to this discussion? You're the first person bringing the phrase up.
- mschuster91 3y agoOf course it is offensive. But so are all the "cops" who follow the Korpsgeist and keep their mouths shut when they see their colleagues openly break the law. Or those that spend 80% of their work time on "traffic stops" aka harassing Black people and other minorities. Remember George Floyd or all the others who died under suspicious circumstances without a bystander live-streaming their deaths.
- zgluck 3y agoObservation: Your profile says: You call it "alt-left", I proudly call it "Antifa".
- robotresearcher 3y agoAttack the argument, not the person making it.
- zgluck 3y agoWhere was the attack? Does mschuster91 consider being associated with antifa (that's how I interpret it) an "attack"?
- kergonath 3y agoHow is it relevant?
- zgluck 3y agoHow is it not relevant?
- mschuster91 3y agoIt should not matter if one is on the right, center or left end of the spectrum to recognize that police should be an instutition that is accepted by all members of society - and that in most Western countries, public distrust in police is only growing over the last years due to (severe) misconduct, incompetence, selective enforcement and a lot of other problems. Of course, as someone associating with the far left side of politics and being politically active in general, I may be a bit more opinionated than many other people - but that fact alone is sad, given how important governmental institutions are for our daily lives.
- asimovfan 3y ago[flagged]
- megabless123 3y agoCounterpoint: it's not offensive at all and helps lots of people to understand the inherent problems with policing.
- mycologos 3y agoIt is offensive in the sense that most people don't like being called bastards, and it doesn't "[help] lots of people to understand the inherent problems with policing" because it is just a heightened way of saying "I think cops are bad". There's no information in it, just opinion. The idea that making a strong emotive statement and assuming your interlocutor is going to fill in all the reasoned arguments behind it is somehow brave or worthwhile is, I think, a problem with a lot of modern discussion.
- yellowapple 3y ago> It is offensive in the sense that most people don't like being called bastards Their employment in a bastardizing profession is entirely voluntary, and they can forego that employment in favor of earning an honest living at their leisure.
- smokelegend 3y agoWell said! That's a critical point in the discussion, this is a job is a voluntary occupation. Nobody forced them to take the position. At anytime they can quit and find other employment, but all it seems to often that most are complacent and complicit in the terms of their employment. Boss says do this, this and that, and they do it lockstep. There should be more discussion on the policy and procedures they use. i.e. "broken windows policy", "stop and frisk policy", "Tuesdays & Thursday" [ I have experienced this one personally, in New York city there is a known tactic that nyc police undercover (plain clothes officers) would stalk the streets harassing citizens in the name of crime prevention[Washington Heights, which is north of Harlem], and if you're darker skin, or just in a irradiated mood for being harassed weekly by these "crime stoppers", you can find yourself in handcuffs, and the drama that follows it.] Again there are lots of people who say " but, but the police are there to protect you" or "if your not doing anything wrong you have nothing to be afraid of" when the cold hard truth is, it's selective enforcement of laws and selective outrage on "blue crime" that creates these false narratives. Case in point, the policing in Witchta, KA is different from Las Vegas, NV or Los Angeles, CA or NYC. But those differences do not green light racist or elitist policy that protect chosen few communities and while systematically injuring the majority of the other communities. [i.e. Greenwich Village vs. Harlem NYC, this is small atom of the picture of disfunction that is NYC, that I am trying to relate.] Respect for your fellow human should be transparent and universal, Dr. King's speech "I have a dream" is achievable, but we're not there yet. I often wonder if it's capitalism in the US that keeps Dr. Kings dream just that a dream...
- ryaneager 3y ago[flagged]
- ddq 3y ago[flagged]
- james4k 3y agoTime and time again this kind of civility check, often arbitrary, reinforces the existing social order and the everyday violence underneath it. But that's okay because if you don't pass the civility check, you are deemed undeserving of humanity.
- eschaton 3y agoWhat are you, a bootlicker?
- throwaway649302 3y agoI feel like this perspective comes from not having coming face to face with the nihilistic, sociopathic behavior of a decent percent of the underclasses. Some people don’t understand anything but immediate pain. It’s tragic, the life circumstances that got them to that point, but that’s where they are. Maybe we can do things to prevent more kids from growing up into that. But right now, millions of good people, who can’t afford to move to a nice suburb far away from the problem, need cops who are willing to bring that pain, and if that doesn’t work, lock the criminals up until they’re old enough to be docile.
- Eisenstein 3y ago[flagged]
- mschuster91 3y ago> I feel like this perspective comes from not having coming face to face with the nihilistic, sociopathic behavior of a decent percent of the underclasses. I got more experience in that than one might believe on a tech forum, from working as a bartender in soddy half-casino half-bar locations. The entire point of dismantling and rebuilding police from scratch obviously includes creating actually sustainable structures to help people with issues: expanding mental health care access, housing-first programs, financial/food aid and safe injection sites would be the top priorities. Someone with mental health issues and a drug addiction on top isn't going to get helped by getting arrested and thrown into jail repeatedly, and yet that seems to be the common approach to such people worldwide.
- rocqua 3y agoSo the job of police is (or at least should include) not crime fighting, but beating some sense into the underbelly of society? You talk about preventing kids from growing up and becoming bad people, but consider what it does to a kid (or any person for that matter) to see the government only interact with anyone through violence. Is that not going to exacerbate the problem?
- hotpotamus 3y agoMy suspicion is that society would be much nicer if we could find a way to reign in the nihilistic, sociopathic behavior of the upper classes much more than the lower ones.
- concordDance 3y agoThe British police (apart from the metropolitan police) are just fine thank you very much. Please don't try and generalise problems from (parts of) the USA to the entire world.
- mschuster91 3y agoI'm not even American, I'm German. Our police are better than in the US, but still nowhere near the quality one generally observes in your police officers. IIRC, you Brits run a completely different, community-based approach, in contrast to almost anywhere else. And unlike even us Germans, there are barely any guns, which is a serious game-changer in how cops can interact with citizens safely.
- holbrad 3y agoThe British police don't do anything.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- croisillon 3y agopolice behave essentially the same problematic way in france, germany and a lot more countries
- yellowapple 3y ago> The British police (apart from the metropolitan police) are just fine thank you very much. That the phrase "All Cops Are Bastards" originated in England suggests otherwise.
- kergonath 3y ago> The British police (apart from the metropolitan police) are just fine thank you very much. They are really not. The whole thing is dubious and the several recents scandals in local police forces show it (the latest example being the chief constable of the Devon and Cornwall police being suspended for misconduct a couple of days ago). I do agree that it is still way better than in the US, in that you don’t expect to be killed just or having interacted with a cop and they are not vengeful thugs.
- isitmadeofglass 3y ago[dead]
- ukuuru 3y agoDespite the article is on US data, it is no different in other countries, which many of them don't have the structures regularly held responsible for in the US. It is by the nature of the very system we have in common; central government. Law enforcement is primary goal of police, not crime prevention, it is nuanced and magnified in practice by the sophistication of our societies and more grift nature of everyday violent crimes.
- specialist 3y ago"Become"? Did US law enforcement ever "serve & protect" the people? SCOTUS forceably rejected that theory. The entertaining book Seattle Justice details how Seattle's police was conceived to protect business interests and quickly morphed into a protection racket. With drugs, gambling, and sex trafficking as side hustles. Adorable! I now assume that's the norm (in the west). The stated purpose of our "well armed miltias" was to repel slave rebellions (in response to Haiti as well as some domestic agitators). The job of sheriffs et al was to catch slaves. The job of Texas Rangers was to exterminate the Comanche. This is just what I remember from popular media. I'm sure an expert has many more examples.
- selimthegrim 3y agoSheriff comes from shire reeve in the UK, was their entire job keeping villeins down?