7 ms·
Why should they get residual checks? Most other professionals get paid for the hours they work and then we either have to keep working or invest some of our ea
by scarface_74 3y ago
Why should they get residual checks? Most other professionals get paid for the hours they work and then we either have to keep working or invest some of our earnings to have enough to live on.
Of course in the startup world, you may be willing to take a lower compensation for equity that will pay our later. But hopefully you understand the risk.
If anything they should negotiate a higher up front payment.
- esalman 3y agoWhy do authors receive royalty every time their book is sold?
- Crunchified 3y agoLikely because it's less risky for the publisher, as opposed to a big up-front payment for something that might not sell as well as expected. As an author, which approach would you prefer?
- esalman 3y agoDefinitely I'd want residual income. To avoid the opportunity cost in case one of my works become bestseller.
- scarface_74 3y agoWould you take less money up front in exchange?
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd that’s something that everyone here fails to understand. For me there are three levels of risk. 1. Getting all of my compensation in cash (least downside/least upside) 2. Working for a publicly traded company where part of my compensation comes from RSUs vested over a schedule 3. Working for a startup where I get “equity” instead of my market value in cash. The writers are negotiating based on 3. I would be negotiating based on 1.
- lapcat 3y ago> The writers are negotiating based on 3. I would be negotiating based on 1. Are you, anonymous internet rando "scarface_74", claiming to know the interests of the Hollywood writers better than the writers themselves?
- scarface_74 3y agoNo I’m anonymous scarface_74 who knows finance and risk/rewards ratios based on being an MBA drop out. I have had the same choices: 1. Being risk averse by taking cash up front and choosing to negotiate based on a maximum up front payment 2. Taking less up front and dealing with a higher risk/reward return like accepting lower payer for equity by working for a startup
- lapcat 3y ago> No I’m anonymous scarface_74 who knows finance and risk/rewards ratios based on being an MBA drop out. It's truly a wonder that you haven't been made the President of the Writer's Guild of America. > Taking less up front and dealing with a higher risk/reward return like accepting lower payer for equity by working for a startup Hollywood studios are not startups, and residuals are not like startup equity. Writers and actors are not hoping for some BigCo to come along and buy the Hollywood studios, or for the studios to go public, leading to a massive single payday. The studios are the BigCos, and they're already public. Residuals are more analogous to BigCo stock than to startup equity.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe choice for the writers are the same. Take less up front for a higher risk/reward if the show is successful and get a continuous income stream or take more up front and don’t the studios have the risk of the show being successful in returns of higher rewards. Whether the studios are public is irrelevant. What is relevant is the success of the movies/tv shows being successful.
- 3y ago
- scarface_74 3y agoBecause that’s the contract they sign and they own the rights to the book. Actors don’t own the rights to the movies.
- esalman 3y agoActors and writers deserve meaningful residual income just like the authors. And they actually did, as a result of a similar strike in the 60s. The model was disrupted due to the advent streaming as the dominant media, so they are merely asking for a correction.
- scarface_74 3y agoAre the writers of the libraries software developers used owed a continuous royalty based on how profitable the software built using it makes? The author of a book could just as easily negotiate a large payment up front to give up rights to their book in exchange of one lump sum and invest their money and let the publisher both take all of the upside. But get all of the downside.
- Draiken 3y agoYou keep repeating this as if it was actually an easy feat. No, aside from already famous established actors you won't just "negotiate a way better perfect contract upfront". This is where the capital power imbalance cannot be defeated. They always have the upper hand against any single individual.
- madsmith 3y agoI would think it has to do with the IP owners using the likeness of the actors to continue to market the show year after year.
- scarface_74 3y agoDoes your employer get to use code you wrote after they pay you? Do they get to market features you worked for after you leave? Do landlords get to collect rent on buildings after the architects are paid to design it?
- aezart 3y agoBoth of those things are also bad.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo you are saying that landlords should have to pay the original architects of the buildings part of their rental income? Are you okay with paying residuals to every library author when you use an npm package?
- aezart 3y ago1. There shouldn't be landlords. 2. Copyright shouldn't exist at all, but until it's abolished I am not opposed to a system where revenue is shared with the developers of any libraries you use. Although I think such a system would be difficult to manage and track.
- pluto_modadic 3y agobecause once made, distributing the thing and making more money is trivial. So, getting an ongoing cut of the proceeds is important. side note, this also means software engineers at large companies are getting screwed and should unionize. imagine it takes $2M to make something, and in the first year it makes $4M. Then, every year after it, it's made $.5M. Either: A) we give actors residuals or B) copyright should expire and movies should be free after the initial crowdfunding.
- gruez 3y ago> because once made, distributing the thing and making more money is trivial. So, getting an ongoing cut of the proceeds is important. But why are you so fixated on "getting an ongoing cut"? Thanks to finance, we can calculate the net present value of any perpetual income stream. There's nothing really different between getting paid $1000, and getting paid $500 + perpetual income stream that has a net present value of $500.
- angmarsbane 3y agoI’ve always viewed it that replays keep their face in the public arena disrupting privacy. If you film something 20 years ago, and then all of a sudden it becomes hugely popular again via streaming you will also be propelled back into the public arena which can have negative effects on your life (unable to go out without paparazzi, interference from strangers etc).
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd that’s also a choice that should be factored in.
- feoren 3y ago> Most other professionals get paid for the hours they work and then we either have to keep working or invest some of our earnings to have enough to live on When people talk about the rich pitting the working class against each other, this is exactly what they're talking about. Rather than saying "yeah, fuck the man, we're all in this together!", you've chosen "why should they get out of eating the shit of our owners? They should learn to eat shit just like the rest of us!"
- scarface_74 3y agoIt’s not “the man” who all should get residuals? Building architects every time someone stays in a building they designed? Software engineers every time you use a library? Are you okay with software patents and licensing? Do you think library makers should get a residual every time you pull a library down from npm?