9 ms·
Other comments asked how incarceration rates could be reduced in the United States. One way would be for many of the forty-some other states to follow the examp
by tokenadult 15y ago
Other comments asked how incarceration rates could be reduced in the United States. One way would be for many of the forty-some other states to follow the example of the few states, including Minnesota, which have set up determinate sentencing based on severity of the offense of conviction and the criminal history of the convicted defendant.
http://www.northfieldnews.com/content/understanding-minnesotas-determinate-sentencing-guidelines http://www.northfieldnews.com/content/understanding-minnesot...
http://www.doc.state.mn.us/crimevictim/terms.htm http://www.doc.state.mn.us/crimevictim/terms.htm
I toured a prison in Minnesota in the mid-1980s, as an interpreter for an official visitor from another country. The visitor was amazed to learn that Minnesota then (and now) spends LESS per taxpayer on putting convicted criminals into prison, while spending substantially MORE per prisoner. Only the most serious criminals with long histories of offenses are imprisoned. Most convicted criminals receive sentences that involve community corrections but not imprisonment. Minnesota's maximum-security prison, the one I toured, had a population of inmates 97 percent of whom had killed at least one other human being before being put in that prison. The foreign visitor was a human rights lawyer, and he was actually amazed at how humanely the prisoners were housed and treated in that prison. (He had visited many prisons in his own country, and none were as well funded as the prison in Minnesota.) A prison can be properly staffed and funded, and not too crowded, if a whole state's criminal justice system is geared toward imprisoning only persons who must be kept out of general society, responding to most forms of criminal behavior with sentences that don't include prison time.
- moldbug 15y agoBut what if our system is actually erring in the other direction? There are undoubtedly quite a few Americans who are in correctional supervision but shouldn't be. There are also quite a few Americans who should be in correctional supervision, but aren't. (For a bare start, suppose we believe the commonly quoted meme that there are 1 million gang members in America.) In either case, I think the most basic question is: why are there so many criminals? What about the present-day American system of government is so amazingly criminogenic? For instance, one commonly quoted "root cause" is our proverbial callousness to important issues of social justice. Is an absence of social justice the problem? Let's consider some evidence. Robbery is a pretty good "index crime." For instance, in 1900, there was about 1 robbery per day in all of England (source: http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/lib/research/rp99/rp99-111.pdf http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/lib/research/rp99...). This is roughly a factor of 35 lower than current reported crime rates (same source) in the ol' Sceptered Island - assuming you trust HMG's statistics. And all crime statistics in all countries everywhere are generally admitted by all informed observers to be utterly buggered to hell. (example: http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-04/news/the-nypd-tapes-inside-bed-stuy-s-81st-precinct/ http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-04/news/the-nypd-tapes-i...) In any case, you may compare the public concern for social justice in England, in 1900 and 2000, and note precisely the reverse of the correlation predicted by the hypothesis. Japan has extremely low crime as well, and is probably the least Americanized of all First World nations today. Clearly, it is physically possible for the State to eradicate crime. Clearly, the American system of government, at home or abroad, seems to carry with it unusually high levels of crime and disorder, at least by historical First World standards. But why? If what we need isn't more social justice, what is it? (edit: I just checked and this parliament.co.uk link isn't the right one for my robbery numbers - I'll have to look. Still, money graf - "The number of indictable offences per thousand population in 1900 was 2.4 and in 1997 the figure was 89.1." Two orders of magnitude any way you slice it.)
- moldbug 15y agoSometimes I think the way HN should work is not that you can't both downvote and comment, but that you can't downvote and not comment.
- Retric 15y agoViolent crime in the US and around the industrialized world has been on a long downward trend for literally thousands of years. Trying to analyze any current system without at least looking at how much things have improved over the last 20, 200, AND 2000 years completely misses why things are the way they are. PS: There are far more laws to break now than in the past which again shifts the picture greatly. Also, Island nations have less drug crime because it's harder to bring the stuff in.
- moldbug 15y agoHas the industrialized world existed for "literally thousands of years"? I'm not sure any statistical trends are consistent in this timeframe. How do you separate crime and war, for instance? Actually, law enforcement in the Edwardian period was much more strict. At that point in history the "broken windows" theory of crime is not a theory - it is a piece of everyday common sense which it has never occurred to anyone to question. Juridical punishment in the Anglo-American era decreases more or less monotonically since (at least) the Elizabethan age. America is in all eras notorious for endemic crime. In general, by the end of the 19th century there is no significant criminal underclass in Protestant Europe. Of course, in Naples you can get knifed in an alley at any time since the 5th century BC, so everything is relative. This book (1921) is a pretty good look at American and European police systems in the prewar era: http://books.google.com/books?id=Q90qAAAAMAAJ http://books.google.com/books?id=Q90qAAAAMAAJ. Fosdick was later head of the Rockefeller Foundation so you know he's legit. (Edit: book link was wrong.)
- moldbug 15y agoFrom Fosdick's book (p. 14): "The chief constable for Edinburgh in his annual report for 1915 wrote as follows: 'I regret to state that while crimes against the person have considerably decreased, a number of serious crimes under the heading of homicide were reported during the year, namely one murder, one attempted murder, and five cases of culpable homicide. The one murder was an abortion case; two of the culpable homicides were cases in which infants had died from neglect; a third was a vehicular accident case; and two others, after full investigation by the Crown Authorities, were not proceeded with.' Edinburgh is a city in excess of 300,000 population. Surely a chief of police in an American city of equal size would have reasons for pride rather than regret if he could point to such a record." In 2012, said American chief of police wouldn't have reasons for pride - he'd probably be committed to an insane asylum. But even a century ago, American crime is an order of magnitude above British crime. Yes. New York 30 years ago was insane. Giuliani cleaned it up. This is a case of mistaking the exception for the trend. Moreover, all chic New Yorker-reading New Yorkers are now free to think like Gopnik, as they stroll around Central Park at midnight or whatever - a blatant invitation for the trend to resume. Remember, it took the Dinkins era to get these people to elect a Republican in the first place. But if you asked their great-grandfathers of Fosdick's era, they'd have been quite astonished to learn that Central Park could ever become a predator's den, day or night - and would associate such an outcome with the complete collapse of American civilization. Which obviously hasn't happened, so nobody's perfect.
- shasta 15y agoWell, according to Chris Rock, the only black people in Minnesota are Prince and Kirby Puckett. What percentage of the white population is in prison there compared to other states?
- BudVVeezer 15y agoI wonder if he knows Kirby Puckett died in 2006. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirby_Puckett http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirby_Puckett
- tptacek 15y agoNot without a time machine, since he said that in 1996.
- wmil 15y agoState by state stats are available here... http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/rd_stateratesofincbyraceandethnicity.pdf http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/rd_statera... Table 4. Minnesota has the 6th lowest white incarceration rate, 0.212%
- danssig 15y agoYes, it's always seemed really bizarre to me that anyone would be locked in a cage unless they were a physical danger. Now there's talk of locking up people for sharing files! Insane. If you believe that file sharing harms the economy (I'm pro-copyright to an extent) then fine the people, garnish their wages, watever. Locked in prison and chance of having a normal career ruined forever? What could be more cruel and unusual?