3 ms·
I can't help but think that, given this quote: More than half of all black men without a high-school diploma go to prison at some time in their lives. The fir
by sliverstorm 15y ago
I can't help but think that, given this quote:
More than half of all black men without a high-school diploma go to prison at some time in their lives.
The first step is simple & straightforward. Fix education (or what is preventing them from getting an education) first, then tackle other problems with prisons.
- hariananth 15y agoSure, education is a great indicator for incarceration. But "fixing" education is neither simple nor straightforward.
- sliverstorm 15y agoCertainly education is not a simple problem, but if it is the root cause of incarceration then the simple answer for incarceration is fix education, no?
- anigbrowl 15y agoYes, but it's not the root cause. it's a factor in criminality, but criminality and incarceration are imperfectly correlated.
- sliverstorm 15y agoImperfectly correlated is somewhat of a misnomer, IMO. Nearly every observed correlation is "imperfect". Hell, that's basically what "correlation" implies.
- anigbrowl 15y agoPoorly correlated then. Lots of people are incarcerated for things most people consider inappropriate because the criminal justice system is so awash in perverse incentives.
- tsotha 15y agoCriminality and lack of education are correlated, but the relationship isn't necessarily causal. It's just as likely they're both influenced by other factors.
- cullenking 15y agoFixing education will take twenty years, whereas fixing 90% the prison problem could be as simple as pardoning all non-violent drug offenses. Of course, you have to do that across 50 states plus the federal level, however it's a single concept. If we are going to start somewhere, that's easily the most appropriate place.
- disc 15y agoYour first step is simple and straightforward just like saying "go fly to the moon" is simple and straightforward. Above and beyond the limited resource distribution we struggle with today (where does increased educational spending come from? Medicare? Defense Spending? Police?) there's an anti-education attitude that has worked it's way into lower socio-economic culture. I think combating this culture component is just as large (if not larger) a job as providing the educational resources.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- crusso 15y agoI'm not googling for them just now, but I know I've seen graphs that show that as we've spent more and more money on education, we've seen no affect on educational metrics (test scores, basic competencies, etc.) I don't think it's a money problem. It's a problem with an intractable public education system in this country that's only really concerned with its own power and growth. We could solve that problem with the stroke of a pen by eliminating the monopoly that the current public education system has upon our educational tax dollars.
- rsheridan6 15y agoIf it's so simple and straightforward, why hasn't it been done after decades of effort and countless failed or marginally successful programs? It's probably somewhere between difficult and impossible, not simple and straightforward.
- unicron 15y agoPerhaps they do not wish to be educated? That is my impression. Don't sort out education, sort out the social stereotypes and cultural issues that turn people into pieces of shit. Education will fix itself then.
- ars 15y ago> Fix education Lack of education is not the cause, it's a symptom of the same thing that causes the incarceration, i.e. it's a confounding variable not an independent cause.
- tokenadult 15y agoThe first step is simple & straightforward. Fix education (or what is preventing them from getting an education) first That is not simple and straightforward because powerful interest groups don't want education to be reformed along those lines. "The education system is a formalised, bureaucratic organisational structure and, like any bureaucratic organisational structure, it strives for maximum autonomy from external pressures as its cardinal principle of survival. While ostensibly devoted to the education of children, teachers, school administrators and local education officers must nevertheless regard parents acting on behalf of children as a force to be kept at bay because parental pressures in effect threaten the autonomy of the educational system. . . . I would hold that the stupefying conservatism of the educational system and its utter disdain of non-professional opinion is such that nothing less than a radical shake-up of the financing mechanism will do much to promote parental power." -- Mark Blaug, "Education Vouchers--It All Depends on What You Mean," in Economics of Privatization, J. Le Grand & R. Robinson, ed. (1985) It would be a distinctly good idea, and would surely reduce crime rates, to reform education along the lines of ensuring that all pupils in schools in the United States learn fundamental literacy and numeracy. According to the PISA international education studies, some countries do much better than the United States in this regard. http://www.pisa.oecd.org/dataoecd/17/26/48165173.pdf http://www.pisa.oecd.org/dataoecd/17/26/48165173.pdf http://www.pisa.oecd.org/dataoecd/50/9/49685503.pdf http://www.pisa.oecd.org/dataoecd/50/9/49685503.pdf
- twoodfin 15y agoWe tried requiring schools to ensure each and every student achieved literacy and numeracy, under penalty of having the school labeled as "failing" and potentially being forced to allow its students other options. It was called "No Child Left Behind", and sadly is now overwhelmingly unpopular. The kind of disciplined (and occasionally rote) learning that leads to success in some of our peer nations is called "teaching to the test". Well-to-do parents don't like hearing that their children's school is "failing" just because poor children are being shuffled from grade to grade without learning much. I really don't know what can be done. Money isn't the answer: Look at the DC public schools.
- harshreality 15y ago
- diogenescynic 15y agoI think the problem is systemic in nature “More African American men are in prison or jail, on probation or parole than were enslaved in 1850, before the Civil War began” "Growing crime rates over the past 30 years don’t explain the skyrocketing numbers of black — and increasingly brown — men caught in America’s prison system": http://www.laprogressive.com/black-men-prison-system/ http://www.laprogressive.com/black-men-prison-system/ "As a consequence, a great many black men are disenfranchised, said Alexander — prevented because of their felony convictions from voting and from living in public housing, discriminated in hiring, excluded from juries, and denied educational opportunities." I read this and think there must be something more complex going on than just graduation rates. Too many interest groups are getting rich trying to fix a perpetually broken education system and the same goes for prisons.