3 ms·
For me it's things like iCloud Photos having no API to access them and no reasonable way to pull them out or back them up. So very much a trap. Among other thin
by lazide 3y ago
For me it's things like iCloud Photos having no API to access them and no reasonable way to pull them out or back them up. So very much a trap. Among other things.
- filoleg 3y agoThere was a thread on HN in the past few days linking this[0] post about a tool that seems to solve just that problem. 0. https://eclecticlight.co/2023/07/17/how-does-icloud-work-plus-a-new-version-of-cirrus/ https://eclecticlight.co/2023/07/17/how-does-icloud-work-plu...
- lazide 3y agoThanks! I looked into it when that article got posted actually, and near as I can tell that isn't a solution to this problem - and that is fully intentional on Apple's part - because: 1) That article is for things in iCloud Drive, which is everything EXCEPT iCloud Photos. Though you can put photos in iCloud Drive (as files), they just won't be seen as photos, visible in iCloud Photos (or the Photos app), etc. without importing them on an Apple device manually into the Photos app. Where they'll then be synced into iCloud Photos. The photos that are imported/stored in the Photos App on Apple devices also are not visible in iCloud Drive after being imported into iCloud Photos. 2) It only works on Mac/Apple devices. And only locally. So you'd need to sync to a Mac device, then backup the mac device, then hope it all works. No direct backup is available. So even if it did allow syncing iCloud Photos, it is a really awkward and brittle way to back them up. 3) There ARE APIs for iCloud Drive. But not iCloud Photos. The web iCloud Photos interfaces also only does manual per-album level downloads (no Takeout or global download equivalent) of photos using the web interface), which stops working at scale VERY quickly. Notably, Google Photos stopped providing the Google Drive interface to Google Photos shortly after Apple made this their standard operating procedure. So it's a common theme. Though Google Photos does have APIs and Takeout, so it's lockin is less 'firm', and they're definitely less obnoxious about it. The Takeout data requires some significant massaging to get equivalent from what is visible in Google Photos though. This is the kind of sneaky trap I've learned to be wary of, as Apple does this a lot for lock-in purposes with their hardware too.
- Tagbert 3y agoI back them up on my Mac to BackBlaze and TimeMachine . They are just local files at that point.
- lazide 3y agoDo you see all the photos in the photos app (and hence iCloud Photos) in iCloud Drive? Near as I can tell, they're separate and this is by design. This impacts pictures or videos taken on phones, iPad’s etc by default; as they go into iCloud Photos, not iCloud Drive.
- Tagbert 3y agoThe photo library on a Mac can be in any local drive. You could put it on iCloud Drive but that would be redundant. You iPhone or iPad take photos and store them in a local cache that syncs to iCloud. It is separate from iCloud Drive but the storage comes from the same iCloud capacity that you have subscribed to. On your Mac the files are stored in a library folder that can be on any local drive. Those files can be backed up like any other file. Any changes you make to those files, like in the Photos app, are synced to iCloud Photos. The photos in the local library are accessible but they are not really meant to be accessed. The meta data about the photos is stored in a database, not the files. There are original files, modified files, and thumbnail files. If you want to you can export some or all photos to separate files and do what you want with them.
- lazide 3y agoIf you do your backups on the mac, do they include all photos in iCloud Photos? Or only ones you manually export?
- Tagbert 3y agoI do the backups from my Mac. Photos on that Mac is configured to download all of the photos in iCloud Photos. It is the source of truth for my photos. The photos are stored in a library directory as discrete files and the backup software has no problem backing them up. It would be trivial to restore the whole set of photos. It is more complex to restore specific individual photos as you would need to know the file name of that photo. If you want to generate an alternate photo store you can export some or all of the photos but that is not necessary for backups.
- meroes 3y agoI will fully admit this is a big problem with Apple. God forbid you have two iCloud accounts and want to merge (not just the photos) My sister has two from living in another country for a decade and me, our dad, her husband, and her gave up after hours and hours and multiple trips to the Apple Store. I see there are some software out there but it shouldn’t require it to merge what are essentially files, and who knows if they will merge everything. I think we’d have to download individual documents, maybe in batches of 10, from what I remember.