3 ms·
"Supplement with gas" implies dual fuel heating. Supplement either with less loss or more use of direct electric heating at higher cost surely? What gets lost
by ggm 3y ago
"Supplement with gas" implies dual fuel heating. Supplement either with less loss or more use of direct electric heating at higher cost surely?
What gets lost here is the goal of removing gas entirely. If you stop at reduction, sure your logic makes sense. But it implies a gas economy at scale with fugitive emissions, reticulation (bottled or piped) production and pollution consequences.
- jacquesm 3y agoI'd love to be able to remove the gas completely. But the reality is that in the winter the sun doesn't shine enough and the price of electricity is such that gas still wins out economically. So I'm happy to convert any surplus electricity to heat but after that the gas burner comes on, as much as I hate it.
- ggm 3y agoNo disagree either with your logic or decisions, it leverages the best outcome for you over sunk costs and existing infrastructure (basically the same) but at scale, it's going to have to change unless something else mitigates the total system costs of gas. You cannot force the change alone. A willingness to assume communal cost is probably required in classic "privatise the profits socialise the costs" outcome.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, absolutely. But in the case of this house that would require a teardown and rebuild, and that would be even more wasteful. My goal is essentially to shift the time the gas heater has to come on to mid November and the time when it can be switched off completely again to early March. That leaves several months where it will run - intermittently - versus how it used to be: from September through late April. The house was badly insulated and had a very inefficient heater. Triple glazing, foam in the wall gap and lots of measuring and tweaking later as well as a new heater so we should be doing much better than before. Our monthly pre-pay went from something astronomical to zero and averages out to about 300 / month before the latest batch of improvements. I'm curious to see how we'll manage this winter. Incidentally, that's why I over-installed on solar: I didn't care all that much about the overproduction in summer, that just gives a tiny bit of money. But it will help to substantially offset the amount of gas consumed in the winter. Even so I have no illusion about being able to do entirely without gas, but compared to how it was it is already much better (est. -70%).