4 ms·
It's important to remember that rights are meaningless if they are not exercised and defended, and that often means uncomfortable placement of walls. Not every
by dsr_ 15y ago
It's important to remember that rights are meaningless if they are not exercised and defended, and that often means uncomfortable placement of walls. Not every case will be as media-friendly as a 12 year old girl posting to Facebook that someone was mean to her. The Miranda decision that established the right to be told your rights when under arrest -- the right to remain silent and so forth -- well, Ernesto Miranda was found guilty of kidnapping and rape in the second trial. Not a great person.
- ComputerGuru 15y agoIsn't that a huge non-sequitur? What do the Miranda Rights have to do with the first half of your sentence?
- saryant 15y agoI think he's trying to say that defending our rights will sometimes mean defending bad people. Not every case will be in defense of an innocent 12-year-old, sometimes you have to stick up for rapists too.
- joedevon 15y agoInnocent 12 year old? LOL. Try being a teacher. Then read that article from the perspective of the educator and it reads completely differently.
- redridingnews 15y agoMaybe 12 year olds aren't THAT innocent, but come on. What about privacy? And as an adult, how would you feel if the boss of your boss asks for your facebook's password so they can have an eye on your boss and co-workers?
- saryant 15y agoI wasn't trying to make any judgement about the 12 year old in the article, just differentiate this situation from that surrounding the Miranda case.
- zem 15y agookay, if you're looking at this from a teacher's perspective and actually finding some sort of justification for what the school did, imagine that it was the administrators asking for your login and password, because you worked for the school. if it's not justified for you, it's not justified for the student.
- joejohnson 15y agoMaybe he's referencing the minor being interviewed by the Sheriff and Principal without her parent's consent.