39 ms·
Sinead O’Connor Condemned Church Abuse Early. America Didn’t Listen
- dredmorbius 3y agoArchive / Paywall: <https://archive.is/4NFGj https://archive.is/4NFGj>
- Clubber 3y ago>The backlash to her actions — tearing up a picture of Pope John Paul II on “Saturday Night Live” and then shouting “Fight the real enemy!” — was swift. I watched that in person (on TV meaning I was alive when it happened). It was such a coded message, it would have been better if it was more direct.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago"Katniss, remember who the real enemy is!"
- hoistbypetard 3y agoWhat more direct message do you think would've been better, and how would it have been better? Is there a specific channel, statement, or way of phrasing it that would have materially changed something, in your view? I don't think you're engaging in this at all, but it was quite a tactic back in the day to tell people who'd been harmed that they needed to speak more directly, and that if only they had done so, the powers that be would've addressed their grievances. Spoiler: that was never the case.
- Clubber 3y ago"Priests are sexually abusing children in the Catholic Church," would have been nice and probably way more effective at stopping it sooner.
- stevenwoo 3y agoShe may have been talking about the Magdalene Laundries in Ireland of which she was a victim, and for which the Irish government apologized for a few years after the photo ripping incident (and a thorough investigation). It's a different scandal where Catholic dioceses made money off of young women and girls by institutionalizing them and making them work, and would have been more difficult to explain to Americans in the nascent public internet times. Also the photo was her mother's, who also abused her so a lot going on there symbolically.
- Anthony-G 3y agoI’d with this comment. In an interview, she said that the photograph had been prominently displayed in her mother’s house where she had been abused. After her mother died, she took the photo with the intention of destroying it some day (as a symbol of the hypocritical abuse she suffered).
- pyuser583 3y agoSo did I. It was not all clear what she was trying to say. It wasnt even clear she was attacking Catholicism. Seemed she was mad at John Paul II. I kind of assume it was about women’s ordination, although I don’t know where that idea came from.
- anigbrowl 3y agoShe sang a whole song immediately beforehand explaining quite straightforwardly what she was angry about: https://www.lyrics.com/lyric/16021642/War https://www.lyrics.com/lyric/16021642/War
- gottorf 3y agoA good example of what happens when an individual runs against powerful institutional forces, and a good reminder of why individual rights, like the freedom to speak even when it offends or hurts, must be protected, both in law as well as in culture.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAbsolutely. And, I'll argue again as I have multiple times in recent days, on Internet discussion sites. (HN repeatedly tone-polices those who speak truth to power, when that speech becomes heated, not only through user actions but in official moderation. I'm aware of HN's justifications. They are extraordinarily insufficient.)
- rootw0rm 3y agoand yet, to make your point, all you had to do was upvote the parent to make it more visible.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThere are a significant number of instances when this isn't the case. A comment is killed by flags, and dang will comment on how it violates HN guidelines. This isn't super-frequent, but does occur at least a few times a year that I see it (both through my own browsing of HN and by following up on dang's moderation comments, the overwhelming majority of which I agree with, just to be clear). Often what's being criticised in the comment is also being practised either in a parent comment (which generally isn't flagged or admonished by dang), or in the source article itself. Abuses by the Catholic Church are one somewhat typical case, there are a few others. Climate / resource discussions that I see, though I think that's becoming less the case with time. Virtually always it's a truth-to-power situation, with truth getting emotional, as might be expected in cases of long-standing abuse. Dang's consistent response is that HN's prime directive is to satisfy intellectual curiosity, and that there are a set of stories (and discussions) that just don't do that. Fluffy floofs, sportsball, celebrity, and horse-race politics are a large fraction of these, and I'm OK with that. I see significant spillover into hard problems as well, though. These are hard to discuss productively, and it's even harder to move that discussion along (new points, new insights, deeper mutual understanding), but my complaint to HN is that it doesn't seem to want to try, or at least, not as hard as I'd like it to. Sinead is a case where Celebrity intersects with Hard Problems, as it occasionally does. Also: for all that this is a fairly consistent complaint of mine, HN does far better than any other general online forum of which I'm aware. There may be some less-frequented corners, and I'd like to check out how, say, MetaFilter scores in this regard. But of major social sites --- Birdsite, FB, Reddit, and even the Fediverse (which shares some characteristics of its larger cousin) --- HN is well above mean IMO. I'd like it to be better. And some latitude in the case of truth-to-power conversations seems one route there.
- selcuka 3y agoAmerica should have probably listened, but unfortunately her conflicting story [1] around religion didn't help much. To be clear, I don't think she wasn't being sincere in any of these. - During an appearance on "Saturday Night Live" in 1992, the Dublin-born singer tore up a picture of Pope John Paul II - In 1999, she was then ordained as a priest by a breakaway church in France. After her ordination, O'Connor said that she wished to be called Mother Bernadette Mary - "I'm sorry I did that, it was a disrespectful thing to do," she said, according to the BBC. "I have never even met the Pope. I am sure he is a lovely man. It was more an expression of frustration." - In an interview with The Guardian later the same year (2010), she labeled the Vatican as "a nest of devils and a haven for criminals." "Do we need a fucking pope? Why do we need a pope? Christ doesn't need a representative," she said. - In an open letter to Pope Francis in August 2018, O'Connor asked to be excommunicated from the Catholic Church. - In a statement on a since-deactivated Twitter account in October 2018, O'Connor said she had "become a Muslim." - in September 2019, O'Connor said that she "had been a Muslim all my life and didn't realize it." [1] https://www.insider.com/sinead-oconnor-islam-muslim-shuhada-sadaqat-explained-2023-7 https://www.insider.com/sinead-oconnor-islam-muslim-shuhada-...
- dredmorbius 3y agoO'Connor's story is a complex one. As with many people who've come from toxic environments and cultures, she was hurt, flawed, injured, and often contradictory. She suffered from mental illness as well, though whether or not that was a cause or consequence of how she manifested her experience is really unknowable. It's been obvious to me even as a largely casual outside observer, and whilst familiar with some of her more popular musical performances, not a close follower of her work, that she was under immense pain and suffered greatly. Her death this week is gutting though long expected. Among many other aspects, what she shows is how one who goes up against the entertainment machine, against culture, and against long-abusive institutions all but inevitably pays in immense price. And for her having done so I have none but the most immense respect, not despite, but because of the many ways in which that fight scarred and flawed her.
- tsol 3y agoWhat's conflicting about this, except that she converted to Islam? She pointed out abuse by the catholic church, the next night Joe Pesci went on SNL and said if it was his show he'd have hit her[1] to a round of applause by the studio audience. She was lambasted by the public and many fellow Catholics, until eventually she and all the children were proven right on the abuse claims. She later left the religion to join Islam which she spoke highly of. It's not entirely surpassing given how she was treated, that she would join Islam(a religion without any intercessors between God and man ex the pope) 1- https://twitter.com/DamJef/status/1684272963325943815?t=9Ii7syEtQsDg_fYD-4ulDw&s=19 https://twitter.com/DamJef/status/1684272963325943815?t=9Ii7...
- rayiner 3y agoAmerica still isn’t listening about the rampant sexual abuse in schools—which unfortunately isn’t any less in proportional terms than in the Catholic Church and is a much bigger problem in absolute terms: https://sites.law.duq.edu/juris/2019/03/16/catholic-priest-sex-abuse-scandals-how-the-media-shapes-the-public-perception-of-child-abuse-in-the-catholic-church https://sites.law.duq.edu/juris/2019/03/16/catholic-priest-s.... My affluent, progressive private school had to hire a law firm recently to do an internal investigation, because of all the teachers that were abusing students in the 1980s and 1990s. There’s a larger conversation here about abuse by people in positions of power over children that we aren’t having.
- tsol 3y agoIt's odd how silent people remain about this. The CDC said there was an epidemic of "sadness and violence"[1] among teen girls to.. basically no response. I've brought this to in conversations and most people don't seem to care very much. I don't understand it to be honest 1- https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/teen-mental-health-cdc-girls-sadness-violence-rcna69964 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/teen-mental-healt...
- rayiner 3y agoComparing like with like in these data sets is difficult. The Department of Education reports over 14,000 sexual assault complaints over a two year period: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/protecting-children-from-sexual-abuse/202305/educator-sexual-misconduct-remains-prevalent-in https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/protecting-children-.... Meanwhile, a John Jay College of Justice Study estimated about 11,000 sexual assault allegations against priests from 1950 to 2002: https://newrepublic.com/article/163905/france-catholic-church-abuse-scandal-american-reckoning https://newrepublic.com/article/163905/france-catholic-churc.... Roughly speaking the rate of complaints to the DOE is about 25 times higher per year than against Catholic priests. Meanwhile, almost a quarter of the country is Catholic, of which 40% attend church weekly (as of 2018). At the very least it’s not clear that sending your kid to Catholic Church every week is especially riskier than putting your kid in any environment where adults exercise authority over them, such as school or sports. The unfortunate fact is that adults sexually abuse children in significant numbers all across society. I suspect the special focus on abuse in the Catholic Church is more a byproduct of America’s longstanding anti-Catholicism. The idea that the Catholic Church and its top-down hierarchical structure is especially conducive to child sexual abuse is an easy story to sell to a Protestant majority country.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> “She had already seen what happened to spirited girls and gay kids in Ireland, and to her it wasn’t an abstraction, it was her biography,” said Mr. O’Doherty, who grew up gay in rural Ireland and moved to the United States in 1996. “She came out of an era of silence that swallowed spirited girls and gay boys, that consumed Irish life, and that you could vanish into. And she nearly did.” This leaves me with a sense that "spirited girls" has some sort of specific meaning which I am not aware of. Does someone know what it is?