3 ms·
I'm familiar enough with HN and your moderation to know that that was the chief complaint here. Know two things: - Economics was my own major field of study.
by dredmorbius 3y ago
I'm familiar enough with HN and your moderation to know that that was the chief complaint here.
Know two things:
- Economics was my own major field of study. I've since taken on a strong interest in sociology (despised by both economists and "real scientists and engineers"), particularly the work of Charles Perrow and Robert K. Merton, which offers insights into organisational behaviour which economics fails to account or allow for. Other significant study was in hard sciences, environmental studies, and ecology. I'm well aware of the conflicts between orthodox economics and these fields, and have spent much of my post-uni life trying to understand why and how this emerged. The works cited by Mirowski, Oreskes, and Conway go a long way to explaining why and how.
- That economics is at odds with basic physics, thermodynamics specifically, and ecology, is extraordinarily well established. It's the foundational basis for a number of heterodox economics disciplines, notably biophysical and ecological economics. There are widely-respected bodies such as the Institute for New Economic Thinking and the more popular Evonomics blog (itself featuring many notable economists as well as other critics) which address this as a major point of study. The mainstream profession periodically goes into hand-wringing mode itself, usually after some economic crisis, usually signaled by The Economist announcing a resurgence of interest in Karl Marx. I've been around the profession long enough to have seen a few cycles of this myself, as I commented here three years ago: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23941770 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23941770>
Despite its attitudes and behaviours, Libertarian / Austrian economics is not mainstream, though it certainly tries to portray itself as that. It has had a profound influence on both popular discussion and the economics profession, however, much of that as a deliberate and decades-long (approaching or exceeding century-long) project. Again, Mirowski, Oreskes, and Conway all describe this, amongst many other authors.
The quip was far less a cheap shot than a shorthand. And again, my principle issue is that HN tone-polices criticisms, ignoring its own advice to "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."
Could the comment have been better? Sure. Most can, certainly my own.
Does it deserve flagging and censure? No.