5 ms·
Namibian fairy circle debate rages on: Sand termites or Turing mechanism?
- Zanni 3y agoTuring "mechanism" is a bit misleading, but I'm fascinated to learn about Turing patterns. [0] I'm not swayed by either side of the debate (and don't really care), but learning about Turing patterns was worth the read. [0] https://www.chemistryworld.com/features/turing-patterns/4991.article https://www.chemistryworld.com/features/turing-patterns/4991...
- digging 3y agoI was pretty confused here. The article should have explained the meaning of Turing patterns sooner. It's a much drier (heh) article than expected without the premise of unconscious biological systems performing computations in sand.
- brainbag 3y agoWired has a good introductory article about them from more than a decade ago. https://www.wired.com/2011/02/turing-patterns/ https://www.wired.com/2011/02/turing-patterns/
- gowld 3y agoHow is it misleading?
- alpaca128 3y agoTuring mechanism sounds a lot closer to Turing machine than a chemical process discovered by Turing which does not have the word mechanism in its name.
- guerrilla 3y agoClickbait will continue to escalate until it's outright lies and everything is a tabloid.
- omnicognate 3y agoChecking the first 30 or so results from a google search for "Turing mechanism" every single one is about Turing patterns and the mechanisms that produce them, and not one refers to Turing machines or any other aspect of Turing's computer science work. Many people don't know Turing did other things. Doesn't make it clickbait.
- zabzonk 3y agonot obvious to me from the ars article, but the circles are > 2 and 12 metres (7 and 39 ft) in diameter according to WP
- permo-w 3y agoimpressively attention-grabbing headline aside, could they not both the true? a Turing mechanism where termites are the "activator chemical"
- kuhewa 3y agoBut then what's the inhibitor? Termites and water scarcity would be on the same side of the equation, no?
- ahmedfromtunis 3y agoThis isn't mentioned in the article (or I hope I didn't miss it) but did they try to dig into the patches to check if there are termites or not? They said they measured moisture at different levels beneath the surface, but that can be done without actually digging.
- Loughla 3y agoRight? Isn't it super simple to see if there are termites there? I was lost about that.
- RC_ITR 3y agoThe argument from the article is that the fairy circles live longer thank the termite colonies persist, so you’ll always only see termites at some of them (both sides agree termites are sometimes but not always found).
- baerrie 3y agoThe article says that the damage to the grass roots is hard to discern and requires magnification. Also, the termites apparently are hard to observe but have been found
- WaitWaitWha 3y agoSeveral paragraphs in, and I am waiting for the explanation how the aliens are testing us if we are intelligent. Bit of a let down, but I do want to know how I can get a job studying sand circles. Think of the stress, or lack thereof.
- digging 3y agoIf you're thinking of the stress: There are exceedingly few positions open for studying sand circles, and probably not much money for it.
- dylan604 3y agoNo, this is the result of the tractor beams when the collect earth samples. It's not actually intended as a test in that manner. That's just a bonus
- buyx 3y agoHimba bushmen It's rare to see an error in the opening sentence of an article, and maybe a nitpick but I believe "bushmen" usually refers to San hunter-gatherer nomads, not Bantu language-speaking pastoralists.
- armadsen 3y agoUnless “bushmen” is being used in some generic “people who live out in the bush” sense? That stuck out to me too. (I’m very closely connected to one of the foremost Western experts on the Himba and have spent time with them myself. Definitely not the same as the Bushmen.)
- alienthrowaway 3y ago> I’m very closely connected to one of the foremost Western experts on the Himba and have spent time with them myself This is such a strange sentence that makes it sound like they're some exotic, uncontacted people. Give it a couple of hours until its waking hours in Namibia, and we're going to have Himba people in this thread.
- armadsen 3y agoI’m not really sure what you mean. There are Himba people on the internet, of course. But there just aren’t that many of them in the world period, and there aren’t exactly a ton of non-Namibians who know any. And I thought it was implied, but I was talking about Himba people who live traditionally, which sort falls under the “out in the bush” heading. Not too many of them hanging out on HN.
- gargablegar 3y agoSan is a derogatory word to describe them. In general it refers to several language groups that extend all the way from South Africa to Namibia and Botswana. So is bushmen. Which does attempt to refer to the San people. It is also considered rude. It depends on how it is used though. The San council in SA is ok with it’s use in positive contexts. They have other names by which they refer to themselves.like !Kung. These represent their individual nations. Himbas don’t have the same language or history as San/Bushmen. Also Himbas raise cattle .. So you are correct that the term “Himba bushmen” is very off. (Although I’m not familiar with Himba’s preferred names) It’s a very western / German thing to talk like this with out knowing the full context and just assuming “hey they live in the bush lol bushmen”
- inasio 3y agoBy Turing mechanism they likely refer to reaction-diffusion systems (also pioneered by Turing), rather than his better known Blade Runner material
- satori99 3y agoThe Australian native tribes who have lived among their Fairy Circles for at least 50,000 years, seem to be on the termite side of the argument. https://theconversation.com/first-peoples-knowledge-of-mysterious-fairy-circles-in-australian-deserts-has-upended-a-long-standing-science-debate-202956 https://theconversation.com/first-peoples-knowledge-of-myste...
- RajT88 3y agoThey probably are right. It is mind boggling the time period over which tribal knowledge develops.
- dilawar 3y agoAntiquity can't be substitute of truth. Granted many of these claims may have strong correlations but I also hear a lot of nonsense that is as old as the civilization itself. Witchcraft is only one of them.
- dylan604 3y agoYou mean the sun isn't really a god riding in a chariot pulled by horses of fire? But it's been told for all of history, it surely must be truth
- defrost 3y agoNot if you read the actual link above. The 50,000 year deep indigenous knowledge being discussed there isn't magical sky friends, it's deep ecological knowledge about plants, animals, and where to find food and water where no outsiders would think to look.
- RajT88 3y agoExactly. Such as how the aboriginal Australians know how to do controlled burns to keep megafires from happening. The government is starting to listen to them on how to do that.
- tommykins 3y agoOh interesting - in Australia the current go to theory is Hydrogen leakage.
- taneq 3y ago> it was plant water stress that caused grasses to die inside the bare patch of fairy circles This seems like the simplest explanation, especially with desert plants with high water efficiency. I’d think that would give groups of such plants a higher ‘surface tension’ leading to a more defined, circular boundary.
- RagnarD 3y agoI'd think that marking off a square maybe 5-10 meters on a side and dumping pesticides onto it for a year, would answer the question. If they still form inside the square, it's probably not due to insects.
- dylan604 3y agoThat's a brave stance to take on this forum. Leeching isn't a problem in dry earth is it? Sounds like a perfectly rational thing to do. Maybe dump a bunch of PFAS in that square, or an entirely different square, you know, for science. Since we're just suggesting whack science, let's get soil from the Bermuda Triangle and replace it with the fairy circles to see if they are spawn points.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI’m confused why it can’t be a combination of the two? Termite damage and colony over growth and collapse combined with water damage over taking the plants in colony zones
- mahathu 3y agoI'll stick with the underground toxic dragon hypothesis.
- mutatio 3y agoSlightly off topic, but in the UK we call rings of fungus "fairy rings" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairy_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairy_ring). Myself and others have witnessed these at native orchid sites and one pattern is that orchids don't grow within the ring; it seems the expanding ring consumes nutrients within, eating outwardly as it expands. This in itself is interesting because typically terrestrial orchids have a heavy symbiotic relationship with fungi. There are interesting physical similarities I can see here; a robustness on the perimeter due to higher nitrogen availability, and more barrenness within the interior.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoI see these in the forests around where I live quite often in the autumn. In Norwegian they're called "heksering", translates to witch ring, and have historically been thought of as a bad omen. Specifically a remnant of gathering places for witches, hence the name. The species in this case is Leucopaxillus giganteus, which is edible, and due to the unique fairy rings, unusually easy to identify. Though I still don't dare try them because only young specimens are edible and mature ones are known to contain KCN...
- 8bitsrule 3y agoNot quite on the scale of the Great Debate of 1920 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Debate_(astronomy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Debate_(astronomy) settled by Hubble in 1925 ... but still amusing!
- kuhewa 3y agoI don't see why circles would necessarily be the most parsimonious shape of it was indeed water scarcity (then again im not sure termite colonies or home ranges are necessarily circular either)
- LiquidPolymer 3y agoSometime around 2002 I chartered a small plane to photograph the landscapes around the bunch grass prairies in NE Oregon. These are one of the last remaining ecological intact bunchgrass prairies in North America. One of the features I caught on film are “mima mounds”. To this day I license these images over and over again because the mechanism that shapes the mounds is hotly debated. I had no idea what they were at the time, but it is fascinating. It’s also fascinating that conversations and debates around these kinds of mysterious features just keeps on going.