If the universe is cyclical, like has been proposed as a possible theory, then "before the Big Bang" is a perfectly reasonable phrase. Sir Roger Penrose has hel

If the universe is cyclical, like has been proposed as a possible theory, then "before the Big Bang" is a perfectly reasonable phrase. Sir Roger Penrose has helped bring attention to the idea, and more recently suggested it may be incorect. It's been around for a while (proposed in the 70's maybe, I think?). --- I'm disappointed by the ease at which people seem to dismiss the phrase as unreasonable. Is it being overly critical without actually knowing enough detail in the field? --- Normally I see very thoughtful responses, so I wonder if there's some collective exhaustion going on. Maybe give a think to some down-time or self-care today? I recommend a light ale or blonde lager with lunch. :)