3 ms·
Thames Water to datacenters: Cut water use or we will
- joshstrange 3y agoAccording to this article, due to bad pipes Thames Water leaks up to "250 Olympic-sized swimming pools" worth of water every day. That's 625 Million liters, compared to the 1-5 Million liters these data centers use daily. I still think that much water for a data center is crazy (why wouldn't they use some form of closed-loop cooling? Or do they and they need 1-5M liters to top it off? Just seems excessive to me but I also don't know much about how data center cooling works.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoAs to why I would hazard to say that water is dirt cheap when compared to running a closed loop system (you need pumps and heat exchangers to cool that water and those cost electricity).
- darkclouds 3y ago1/3 of a data centres energy consumption goes on cooling. They are end of life Victorian pipes, in a massively built up and down part of the world. It was always going to cost lots, which is why the govt privatised the problem before people realised what was involved. Renationalising it would put up taxes for everyone in the country not just Londoners, thats why London is so expensive to live in. If labour get in, and they renationalise it, labour will be exploiting the stupidity of their voters. Hanlon's razor, never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity except stealth Govt planning.
- deepsun 3y agoWhere does the other 2/3 of energy go? I thought it's all converted to heat.
- darkclouds 3y agohttps://cc-techgroup.com/data-center-energy-consumption/ https://cc-techgroup.com/data-center-energy-consumption/ "the amount of power needed to run data centers on a global scale, which amounts to 416 terawatts, or approximately 3% of all electricity generated on Earth." "Making massive-scale changes to data center operations to enhance the efficiency of energy usage can be a complex, costly, and time-consuming venture. But changes don’t have to be extreme to be effective, and they don’t need to happen all at once. By utilizing the following sixteen methods, data centers can quickly start to efficiently lower their power usage without significantly impacting their bottom line." More at the link for a more detailed explanation. Personally I think this is Thames water looking to shake down the IT sector. Good luck with that considering the brains that run the IT sector! LOL.
- yodelshady 3y agoIt's all converted to heat. (nearly) 2/3 is used for computation, which produces waste heat, 1/3 is used to move that heat out of the building. Presumably HVAC designers are smart enough to ensure their waste heat is made outside, and so doesn't add to the total cooling load.
- ReflectedImage 3y agoThe plan is not to have water in London? I'm not sure where you are going with this?
- darkclouds 3y agoNo not saying there should not be any water in London, thats rather melodramatic wouldnt you say? Likewise, where are you going with this, if you think that?
- pixl97 3y ago>That's 625 Million liters, compared to the 1-5 Million liters these data centers use daily The number of pipes and infrastructure that need replaced to fix that likely represents decades of work and funding.
- tetris11 3y agoThe report from the "Uptime Institute"[1] the whole thing is based on: https://uptimeinstitute.com/resources/research-and-reports/sustainability-strategies-in-colocation https://uptimeinstitute.com/resources/research-and-reports/s... 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/451_Group#Uptime_Institute?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/451_Group#Uptime_Institute?wpr...
- hellotomyrars 3y agoUnsurprising that Thames Water wants more money considering their financial situation. The state of their infrastructure is wretched. The fact they saved themself from forced nationalization is depressing as well. It’s pretty nakedly obvious that they’re run poorly by design.
- lol768 3y agoWater privatisation has been a complete failure. Water isn't a commodity, and private equity has no business being involved in water companies. We all have Thatcher to thank for paying an extra 350% since privatisation. Thames Water just illustrates how poorly this can play out.
- hellotomyrars 3y agoI agree. A natural monopoly doesn’t make sense to be private in any circumstance. Thames Water is like the poster child for people who say anything government run is inherently bad because only the free market can optimize it and make it profitable. Except for the part where it’s private.
- blargey 3y agoThe majority of this water is just for cooling, right? If the only thing entering or leaving the water is heat, why can’t the pipes just be arranged so it’s all “supply” pipes just passing through the datacenter, with the contents never being “used” at all?
- _boffin_ 3y agoWithout any knowledge of this subject, I’m going to wager that there’s some additives being added to reduce corrosion or other stuff to maximize utility or heat transfer from hot things to water. Again, I’m just an idiot on a forum.
- nayuki 3y agoEvaporative cooling can be very cheap compared to closed-loop cooling. Look at how coal and nuclear power plants release steam into the environment.
- yodelshady 3y agoFor those that are, for example, in CA, Thames Water probably rivals PG&E or various telecoms for Examples Of Neoliberalism Not Working Very Well. Billions in dividends paid out to the private equity that bought it, terrible performance, zero investment, zero competitors, and skyrocketing debts, that the taxpayer may well have to fix because the alternative is millions of voters no longer have a resource necessary for life. On top of that, you of course have a rising population, competing for land (reservoirs and sewage works take up space, almost all the land in South East England is built or farmed, less farming means more sensitivity to the global ~~dumpster fire~~ food market), said population objecting to improvement works (even when improvement works are necessary for the aforementioned life stuff to be delivered), and climate change, which means, er, less water. Or more. Don't actually know. If you did know it was less, you could build desalination. If you know it was more, reservoirs and upgraded sewage systems. But don't know. So build neither, because you're private equity and fuck it, voters aren't your problem. If there's a slightly amoral upside, datacenters are probably one of the best customers to rinse. Profit margins are high, politically not that popular, and being close to London matters. Maybe it could also be one of those kicks I've seen dreamt of a lot of HN, that forces developers to be a bit more efficient rather than throw racks at the problem.