3 ms·
Would it be a major hardship to require an EEG test to certify brain death? Seems like the biggest problem would be that not everyone would have the equipment,
by andrewflnr 15y ago
Would it be a major hardship to require an EEG test to certify brain death? Seems like the biggest problem would be that not everyone would have the equipment, but surely they would have it in a hospital doing organ transplants? IANAD, though.
- Craiggybear 15y agoAn EEG cannot and does not provide conclusive evidence of brain death. Far from it. It is merely a diagnostic tool to assist a diagnosis -- the actual diagnosis of death is medically and legally dependent upon a physician. There are criteria for establishing death but they are often out of date (drowning and freezing spring to mind) and can be poorly interpreted. They have also got it wrong before -- times too numerous to mention. Caution is very necessary here. Its a complicated subject (legally, morally, ethically, scientifically and medically) and questions do need to be asked about organ transplant practice and ethics from time to time.
- andrewflnr 15y agoRight. It just seems like it would be very helpful, as long as we're standardizing tests.