4 ms·
I don't really get the point of states regulating a substance. That sounds like a recipe for crossed incentives, smuggling, and bad faith. It's bad enough for
by jfengel 3y ago
I don't really get the point of states regulating a substance. That sounds like a recipe for crossed incentives, smuggling, and bad faith.
It's bad enough for alcohol, and we do have a whole federal department to manage it. Why not just let the 21st century be the 21st century, with planes and roads that make state lines practically meaningless.
- godelski 3y agoThe US was more intended to be not too dissimilar from say the EU. The fed grew and took more power, but that was part of "the grand experiment." I'm not saying one way is right or wrong, but this is why people frame things as state issues. I mean we are talking about states with the land mass and economic worth of European countries.
- mrguyorama 3y agoHorse shit. We tried the loose federation thing and it nearly led to the end of the US before it really even started. The point of the constitution was a strong federal government. The supremacy clause is extremely clear that anything the feds make a law on IS the law, no matter what an individual state wants.
- godelski 3y ago> We tried the loose federation thing and it nearly led to the end of the US before it really even started You're talking about a period of time that is 100 years after the time I'm talking about.
- mrguyorama 3y agoYes and the period of what was essentially Governor run Fiefdoms of states was EVEN WORSE than the articles of confederation at building a state that wasn't going to have constant petty land struggles internally. A significant part of the building of the US was convincing those governors to give up their total power in exchange for survival. It was literally "We either come together and be strong or die separately"
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoConstitutionally only states should really have the power to regulate substances. That the federal government does so is largely an overreach.
- rileymat2 3y agoMaybe regulate the substances, but regulating the interstate trade of those substances which can be significant is certainly Constitutional. Sure, the power over interstate trade has also been stretched, but that is ubiquitous across all products.
- elcritch 3y agoNot just stretched, but convoluted beyond recognition. The prohibitionists were a bit fanatical but at least they did it properly and passed an amendment for it.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoThere was an amendment for that. (two, really) I'd expect some workaround to be done, like tying interstate funding to the drinking age. Would be sad to see the feds go after Oregon/Alaska in the same way.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>Constitutionally only states What part of the constitution limits congresses ability to regulate a substance
- supertrope 3y ago"Amendment X. The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people." The Federal government should only exercise enumerated powers. Thomas Jefferson struggled with the Louisiana Purchase because buying land is not an enumerated power. Of course this document also has a Necessary and Proper Clause and an Interstate Commerce Clause. In practice judges on special courts decide if they value drug prohibition or the semi-sovereignty of states more.