3 ms·
So I think that thinking was good 20 years ago but isn't fine today. The difference is really the environments we live in. 20+ years ago it really wasn't hard
by godelski 3y ago
So I think that thinking was good 20 years ago but isn't fine today. The difference is really the environments we live in.
20+ years ago it really wasn't hard to be private in a public space. You walk off the main street and if you couldn't see anyone then no one could see you, generally. Same would be true about audio.
But today there's cameras everywhere and microphones everywhere, so privacy is not verifiable by simple observation. Plus, you have a GPS tracker on you that's talking to all the GPS trackers that's on everybody else.
That's where the logic breaks down, but it requires subtly and a bit more nuance because the way we're tracked is covert and not as obvious. It can be automated and doesn't require someone to physically follow you. It can gather way more information that that person physically following you every could.
It's not that the former logic was bad, it's that it works on a certain set of assumptions. Assumptions that don't hold true today. The problem we face today with a lot of arguments we have (more than privacy) is that people tend to be working under different assumptions, assuming everyone else has equivalent ones. Additionally, our assumptions are frequently wrong and we end up fighting rather than discussion, which it's fine to disagree with.