5 ms·
It boggles my mind that this obscure, quasi-theological view of race has gained such purchase among supposedly mainstream Americans. Among the myriad problems
by rayiner 3y ago
It boggles my mind that this obscure, quasi-theological view of race has gained such purchase among supposedly mainstream Americans.
Among the myriad problems with this ideology is that it projects the experiences of (some?) black people with race onto a society where the majority of people who are not white are also not black. For example, the passages you quote above use “race” and “ethnicity” as synonyms, but they’re different both in theory and practice.
- opwieurposiu 3y agoCurrent elites think it is vital to keep the equity conversation about race, because it keeps the proles from thinking about class. They have been wildly successful in this regard.
- ddd00001 3y agoNah I don't think it's a conspiracy. I think they genuinely believe race is the most important thing ever and that focusing every facet of public discourse on race is good.
- Zetice 3y agoSure; for one thing, there is no biological concept of race. So we should only be talking about ethnicity and cultures, and not about "race" at all, as it isn't a term with meaning.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 3y agoGood luck defining race, culture, or ethnicity. They are all referring to tribes of nebulous constantly changing characteristics, that people can not only move between, but exist in multiple simultaneously.
- Zetice 3y agoUnfortunately, the racists got there first with their "one drop" policies. As is usually the case, it's the discriminators that set the stage, and the rest of us who have to act out the play.
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- whatdoyamean 3y ago[flagged]
- Zetice 3y agoThe thing you have to remember is that race, as a social construct, only exists as a form of oppressive categorization. It's never, historically, been used as merely "identification" or whatever else categorization might be used for in some benign way. It's always a weapon. So yeah, culturally it exists. Biologically it does not exist, however. And I have zero clue why CRT is on your mind here, or why you think it's "reductionist", and in fact would apply to various "white" people through history. Do you think CRT wouldn't apply to the Irish in the 1820s?
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- Zetice 3y agoCRT is not reductionist, it's observational; the white/black oppressor/oppressed dichotomy is how racism has played out in the United States in the 20th and 21st century. To be blunt, the US didn't institutionally endorse the enslavement of millions of Italians for hundreds of years. The black/white conflict is different from any other racial conflict in America.
- rayiner 3y agoYou’re agreeing with me. > The black/white conflict is different from any other racial conflict in America. More precisely, the conflict between British and Dutch enslavers and their descendants and enslaved Africans and their descendants is different from any other racial conflict in America. The ordinary prejudice faced by everyone from Germans to Vietnamese to Guatemalans is not merely different in degree, but different in kind. If you limit CRT to enslavers and their descendants, and the enslaved and their descendants, I agree CRT is observational rather than reductionist. But it hasn’t been so limited. “White” has been generalized to encompass Italians, Irish, etc., and “black” has been generalized into “people of color.” And it’s that generalization that I’m calling reductionist and nonsensical.
- the_lego 3y agoThat's like claiming color has no physical concept, because wavelengths vary continuously, and our language about color doesn't perfectly match the underlying physical reality. "What do you mean 'green'? Two sharp peaks at 520 and 540 nm? One 30 nm wide pseudo-Gaussian with mean at 530 nm? Is 564 nm still green, or is that yellow? What about 567 nm? It is a term without meaning." See also: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Principal_component_analysis_of_human_genetic_diversity https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Principal_compon...
- Zetice 3y agoIt is like that, except there's no underlying "wavelength" to support the concept of race. It's just the word "blue" with nothing else.
- the_lego 3y agoOf course there is - population-wide genetic variation, as my wikipedia link demonstrates.
- Zetice 3y agoNope, those are not real. There is no "population-wide genetic variation".
- SamReidHughes 3y agoYou must find it really confusing how smallpox killed off the Indians.
- defrost 3y agoWhat's confusing about an isolated population that doesn't have variola virus antibodies being more susceptible than a population with antibodies and a much longer generational history of exposure?
- 3y ago
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPeople’s eyes would probably gloss over if you start discussing prior probabilities and how everyone uses them for everything (whether rightly or wrongly), and it is an innate part of humans and probably most other animals.
- skissane 3y ago> For example, the passages you quote above use “race” and “ethnicity” as synonyms, but they’re different both in theory and practice. The idea that there is a clear distinction between race and ethnicity is very American. In much (most?) of the rest of the world, there isn’t. The Australian government officially refuses to take a position on what the distinction is - it prefers to just talk about ethnicity; when it acknowledges the concept of race at all, it treats it as roughly equivalent to ethnicity. I think most countries worldwide are closer to Australia on this issue than to the US
- rayiner 3y agoRace as a concept distinct from ethnicity arises out of slavery and segregation.
- skissane 3y ago> Race as a concept distinct from ethnicity arises out of slavery and segregation. Brazil also imported slaves from Africa, but its concepts of “race” have always been quite different - much more fluid - than those of the US. Brazil never had anywhere near as much segregation as the US. Indeed, I think US ideas about “race” weren’t caused by segregation, they pre-existed and caused segregation-Brazil never adopted those policies, despite the shared experience of African slavery, due to having different ideas about “race” from the start And there’s a lot about American ideas of “race” which can’t be explained by either slavery or segregation. I mentioned before the arbitrary boundary between “White” and “Asian”, drawn along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border - that seems to have no logical connection to either