5 ms·
How about teaching kids self control and concentration?
by nottorp 3y ago
How about teaching kids self control and concentration?
- kwanbix 3y agoBecause these things are addictive? You can say the same for drugs, alcohol, and most people that consume those are adults, how can you expect kids to do what adults can't? You see 90% of people in the buses, trains looking their phones like idiots (including me). It is very difficult because it creates addiction.
- mentos 3y agoReminds me of looking at old photos of people in bars or planes all smoking.
- nottorp 3y agoHave those adults been taught about self control and concentration in school?
- randomdata 3y ago> You see 90% of people in the buses, trains looking their phones like idiots (including me). Isn't that just making the best of a bad situation? I am guilty myself, but at the same time I forget that I even have a device when not subject to such drudgery. Addiction usually implies a greater compulsion. Which, too, explains why this ban is only targeted at schools and not in general like drugs. While there are some skillful teachers, most aren't worth your time. As such, the phones come out as a distraction. In my pre-smartphone youth we were doodling in our notebooks, or what have you, instead but the motivation was the same.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoYou werent doodling in your book while walking in public or mid pee in the urinal. You weren’t doodling to the point you have chronic neck pain and a screwed up posture. You weren’t getting mad or depressed at what you were doodling either.
- gonzo41 3y agoYeah, that fits. Leave the phone at home, or in a locker and go to class. How is that not also helping with self control?
- nottorp 3y agoThat's eliminating the temptation forcefully, not training to ignore it.
- gonzo41 3y agoYou enforce discipline from an extrinsic source until the expectations are understood and self discipline takes over. Works with dogs, soldiers and kids the same. Doesn't work with cats sadly. And the best thing you can do is model the behavior of putting your phone away and out of sight for things like meals and family time.
- tankfox 3y agoThis is exactly how we fought the war on drugs! I'm sure it will go great!
- vacuity 3y agoIt's sad how addiction implies "be more tolerating because it'll happen anyways and be worse if you aren't", though. I'm not saying that addicted people should just be thrown aside. At the same time, since addiction implies an altered mental state like insanity, addicted people are clearly a burden to society that can't be reasoned with. In general, people have their circumstances that lead them to do what they do, but addicted people may stay addicted even if their circumstances are somehow resolved. Addiction is a costly affair to individuals, their friends and families, and the state. We should try to rehabilitate addicted people and we should try to tackle the root causes (much easier spoken than done), but it's a lousy situation in the first place.
- pantalaimon 3y ago
- jackmott 3y agook, how?
- BitwiseFool 3y agoSuch a thing is easier said than done. While self control and concentration can be taught, it is probably the case that schoolchildren just aren't up to the challenge of resisting smartphones at such a young age. Especially when it seems like most adults aren't capable of exercising restraint when it comes to smartphone usage.
- throwaway71271 3y agosure, we can also teach them to not eat junk food while living inside mcdonalds, how hard can it be, its just self control.
- swayvil 3y agoYes. Forget the free internet. We win the moral battle. That's what really matters.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- awelxtr 3y agoIt doesn't work this way. How resisting the temptation of using a phone AT SCHOOL, a place where most kids don't want to be, will be rewarded so they can learn the benefits of self control? It makes no sense! It is already hard for most kinds understand that school is good for them to make it more difficult already and force them ignore the temptation of the phone. Really, most people who talk about exercising self control or improving it have never had to had self control in the firt place.
- bamfly 3y agoExactly. That's why I made my kids chain-smoke cigarettes for a month, then told them they couldn't have any more, but kept a pack in the open on the kitchen table. Gotta teach self-control.
- tachudja 3y agoI assume the logical conclusion to this is to allow kids access to all things we find addictive but have put behind an age gate, like cigarettes, booze, and car rentals