3 ms·
I'm increasingly inclined to see classical footnotes or endnotes as a preferable compromise. Simply hyperlinking text often provides little context as to where
by dredmorbius 3y ago
I'm increasingly inclined to see classical footnotes or endnotes as a preferable compromise.
Simply hyperlinking text often provides little context as to where that link is going, though alternatives (as with your own pop-up context cards, see also Mediawiki's use of same) are useful. I've played with sidenotes as an option, implemented in CSS (I've a few CodePens on this concept). That also works reasonably well (and can even be responsive to screen size).
There's also a fantastic quote of Walter Benjamin's I've just run across:
“Already today, as the current scientific mode of production teaches, the book is already an obsolete mediation between two different card file systems. For everything essential is found in the index box of the researcher who wrote it, and the scholar who studies it assimilates it in his own card file.”
-- Walter Benjamin - Attested Auditor of Books, in One Way Street (1928)
<https://writingslowly.com/2023/07/24/walter-benjamin-on.html https://writingslowly.com/2023/07/24/walter-benjamin-on.html>
The thought of books (or Web articles) as inter-process communication between author's personal datastors (Zettelkasten, databases, wikis, org-mode notes, ...) is a fresh and illuminating one.
- gwern 3y agoI don't like footnotes/endnotes at all, because they still incur the opacity of a link and require reader effort. Even a simple link-icon (to denote within-site links, before/after self-links etc) gives you more information than that! > I've played with sidenotes as an option, implemented in CSS (I've a few CodePens on this concept). One idea I've played with is having links be partially expanded and sort of 'docked' into the side, so you can glance over at any link and see the title & snippets. Crude mockup: https://gwern.net/doc/design/typography/sidenote/2022-11-16-gwern-gwernnet-dockedannotationsidebarmockup.jpg https://gwern.net/doc/design/typography/sidenote/2022-11-16-... It doesn't work with 1-column layouts on most monitors because not enough space, but could work with more newspaper-like layouts or a 2-column layout with the right column reserved for the bibliography/sidenotes-esque cards.