4 ms·
Remember the Left-Pad debacle? That was already 7(!) years ago, yet I still remember like it was yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11348798 https:
by userbinator 3y ago
Remember the Left-Pad debacle? That was already 7(!) years ago, yet I still remember like it was yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11348798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11348798
It's not surprising that this is continuing to happen in JavaScript, the language whose userbase could actually be considered largely computer-illiterate.
That's not to say other languages don't have the same problems, but in my experience those who have experience with lower-level languages are more likely to have come from being power users and thus have a reasonable amount of computer literacy.
In contrast, the JS world is full of people who, lured by the promise of a well-paying easy job, "teach" themselves via the most shortcut-filled way and churn out a torrent of barely-working code that relies on others' barely-working code. It's pure quantity over quality and no one really understands what they're doing.
- space_fountain 3y agoI kinda hate this take and to be clear this is coming from someone who did learn at the low level first: objective c then c++ with some fiddling with assembly and fpgas along the way. In my experience JS programmers are people who want to get things done and see results they can touch. It does have many inexperienced programmers, but because it's one of the better languages to learn if you want to get into programing. The people I saw learning it when I co-led an on campus club focused on encourage people to build things and a hacker mentality were interested in it because it was the path to building things they wanted to build not because it was the path to riches
- itisit 3y agoThe market asked for these developers, and it got them. Their inexperience is not a symptom of a decided ineptitude or nonchalance towards CS fundamentals. It’s a case of getting what’s required for a job (web apps and crud backends) and not much more.
- namaria 3y agoI'd argue that if you limit your learning to what you need to get a job and not much more, you are exemplifying decided ineptitude and a nonchalant attitude towards the science that underpins your trade.
- mschuster91 3y agoCapitalism doesn't reward anything more, which is the point. And academia has gone down the drain just as well, just look at how ridiculously insecure and underpaid most academic employment is, outside of the holy grail aka tenure track of course. Meanwhile, universities blow billions on fucking sports teams.
- rmbyrro 3y agoRequiring brick layers to learn the chemistry of cement wouldn't suit society's demand for brick laying services. It's not a matter of capitalism, it's a matter of priority. We at this forum are a tiny minority of people who have the time and mental capacity to learn science. Most people in the world are struggling to have quality food and a roof. Although not as essential as housing, the software industry also faces such challenges. Sure, every IT shop would love to have computer scientists, but they need some things done and there wouldn't be enough scientists if every developer was waiting to accomplish a full CS degree and get 5 years of high quality CS experience.
- namaria 3y agoI'm not talking about credentials or trade vs science. I'm talking about the attitude and disposition of knowing just enough and tuning out the rest vs being curious and digging deeper. This has nothing to do with society, markets or staffing practices. This is about how each one of us can approach challenges. Besides most people in the world are not struggling. Where do wealthy Americans get this idea that out there most people are poor and ignorant? Global poverty and vulnerability stands at around 15% of population.
- red-iron-pine 3y agono one said anything about growing them further, or limited their growth. but this app needs to ship now, and we need 3 more bodies to make that happen. in a perfect world they'd be from an actual tech school, but bootcampers who can spell C-R-U-D might be good enough.