24 ms·
Well said. I know there's money in tools because I've been making money making and selling tools for a long time. But not every kind of tool. A gdb replacement
by JohnFen 3y ago
Well said. I know there's money in tools because I've been making money making and selling tools for a long time.
But not every kind of tool. A gdb replacement would be a hard sell unless it managed to actually perform miracles. But specialty tools of the sort that can save a relatively small group of devs major pain and/or time? There's good money in that for a small business. That the market is too small to be attractive to large companies is just gravy.
- sanxiyn 3y agoTime-travel seems miraculous to me, but uptake seems very slow to me. I hope https://www.replay.io/ https://www.replay.io/ succeeds.
- Veserv 3y agoCommercially available time travel debugging is over 20 years old at this point [1]. So yeah, the uptake is pretty slow. [1] http://jakob.engbloms.se/archives/1564 http://jakob.engbloms.se/archives/1564
- coldtea 3y ago>Well said. I know there's money in tools because I've been making money making and selling tools for a long time Couldn't a succesful actor say the same? "I know there's money in acting, because I've been making money acting for a long time". And yet we'd instantly understand that doesn't refute the sense the statement was meant, and that acting isn't really the field you wanna pursue if you want to make money". Same for any other niche endeavor, where there are thousands more lucrative fields and niches, and much fewer succesful examples compared to other areas.
- smallnamespace 3y ago> acting isn't really the field you wanna pursue if you want to make money That depends on the person. By the same token, software engineering isn’t the right field for the average person (because most people don’t have the knack for coding), and yet some people find they do have that talent. A career is like dating, it’s mostly about finding a good fit, which means you also need to know yourself. Once you do, you may find a ‘bad’ niche is actually the right one for you.
- 7e 3y agoNo, it depends on supply and demand. Lots of people want to act. Lots of people want to make tools.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoAnd some are successful.
- coldtea 3y agoWhich is irrelevant when evaluating a job market. Some are succesful in any crap market, where the chances are that most will go under or utterly fail, and where the conditions and average salaries and profit margins and such are attrocious. "Some are succesful" as some kind of retort basically translate to "I don't care about market conditions, I have confidence in myself and I know I'll be one of the succesful ones". Which is all well and good, but it doesn't say anything about one's chances of success, or that job market's behavior in general. Besides, historically it's what every fresh-eyed kid fresh off the bus from Nebraska, still waiting tables 20 years later, believed too.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhat I reject is evaluating the a job maket and completely ignoring the market participant, treating them as interchanagable. Sure, many people suffer from self delusion, but that doesnt mean that their individual characteristics are meaningless. If Jeff Bezos wanted to make tools, with all the power and money he has, he would have a much better chance than the average market participant.
- coldtea 3y ago>That depends on the person Yes, that's the fallacy/issue I was addressing. It's a market, and we try to evaluate it as a market, and talk about its characteristics. Not about whether "if you're the next Brad Pitt you'd make millions".
- JohnFen 3y ago> Couldn't a succesful actor say the same? "I know there's money in acting, because I've been making money acting for a long time". Yes. That even one person makes money doing a thing is strong evidence that it's possible to make money doing that thing. Whether or not doing that thing is something you should do is an entirely different question.
- coldtea 3y ago>Yes. That even one person makes money doing a thing is strong evidence that it's possible to make money doing that thing. Which would be relevant if the question at stake was whether it's "possible or not". As opposed to the question whether people should focus on that market as a good market, where relatively more opportunities and money are than other IT areas. Or did you thought those writing the post didn't already know several examples of companies making money selling tooling, and they didn't change their point, because the possibility of it was never what they were talking about?
- rhelz 3y agoAll a gdb replacement has to do to succeed is not require the binary to be codesigned.
- funcDropShadow 3y agoWhat kind of tools do you build? I'd be interested in your opinion on what are the preconditions for tools to profitable.
- fmajid 3y agoIDA Pro competes with gdb and Ghidra and seems profitable enough: https://hex-rays.com/IDA-pro/ https://hex-rays.com/IDA-pro/ Then you have the people who sold shovels and pickaxes to prospectors during the Gold Rush