4 ms·
There no money in tools: The Dutch company ASML would like to talk to you. The article does actually say that in highly specialised niches tool making is fanta
by ggm 3y ago
There no money in tools: The Dutch company ASML would like to talk to you.
The article does actually say that in highly specialised niches tool making is fantastically lucrative. So, don't mistake the headline for ground truth.
Also there is good reason to believe tool making since flint knapping has been high status, and demands surplus production to liberate skilled labour to making tools which have immensely high use value: tools are magnifiers of human productivity and are worth a lot.
The point is that when commodities are cheap, and tools like gdb can be considered a commodity, the relative advantage of "a better one" has to be weighed up with using a screwdriver as a hammer. Thus printf() debugging.
- JohnFen 3y agoWell said. I know there's money in tools because I've been making money making and selling tools for a long time. But not every kind of tool. A gdb replacement would be a hard sell unless it managed to actually perform miracles. But specialty tools of the sort that can save a relatively small group of devs major pain and/or time? There's good money in that for a small business. That the market is too small to be attractive to large companies is just gravy.
- sanxiyn 3y agoTime-travel seems miraculous to me, but uptake seems very slow to me. I hope https://www.replay.io/ https://www.replay.io/ succeeds.
- Veserv 3y agoCommercially available time travel debugging is over 20 years old at this point [1]. So yeah, the uptake is pretty slow. [1] http://jakob.engbloms.se/archives/1564 http://jakob.engbloms.se/archives/1564
- coldtea 3y ago>Well said. I know there's money in tools because I've been making money making and selling tools for a long time Couldn't a succesful actor say the same? "I know there's money in acting, because I've been making money acting for a long time". And yet we'd instantly understand that doesn't refute the sense the statement was meant, and that acting isn't really the field you wanna pursue if you want to make money". Same for any other niche endeavor, where there are thousands more lucrative fields and niches, and much fewer succesful examples compared to other areas.
- smallnamespace 3y ago> acting isn't really the field you wanna pursue if you want to make money That depends on the person. By the same token, software engineering isn’t the right field for the average person (because most people don’t have the knack for coding), and yet some people find they do have that talent. A career is like dating, it’s mostly about finding a good fit, which means you also need to know yourself. Once you do, you may find a ‘bad’ niche is actually the right one for you.
- 7e 3y agoNo, it depends on supply and demand. Lots of people want to act. Lots of people want to make tools.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoAnd some are successful.
- coldtea 3y agoWhich is irrelevant when evaluating a job market. Some are succesful in any crap market, where the chances are that most will go under or utterly fail, and where the conditions and average salaries and profit margins and such are attrocious. "Some are succesful" as some kind of retort basically translate to "I don't care about market conditions, I have confidence in myself and I know I'll be one of the succesful ones". Which is all well and good, but it doesn't say anything about one's chances of success, or that job market's behavior in general. Besides, historically it's what every fresh-eyed kid fresh off the bus from Nebraska, still waiting tables 20 years later, believed too.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhat I reject is evaluating the a job maket and completely ignoring the market participant, treating them as interchanagable. Sure, many people suffer from self delusion, but that doesnt mean that their individual characteristics are meaningless. If Jeff Bezos wanted to make tools, with all the power and money he has, he would have a much better chance than the average market participant.
- rhelz 3y agoAll a gdb replacement has to do to succeed is not require the binary to be codesigned.
- funcDropShadow 3y agoWhat kind of tools do you build? I'd be interested in your opinion on what are the preconditions for tools to profitable.
- fmajid 3y agoIDA Pro competes with gdb and Ghidra and seems profitable enough: https://hex-rays.com/IDA-pro/ https://hex-rays.com/IDA-pro/ Then you have the people who sold shovels and pickaxes to prospectors during the Gold Rush
- 36870059 3y agoASML's crown jewels are not mere "tools", they are machines. It is bleeding edge technology and entirely irrelevant to a general discussion of economics of 'tool makers'. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Ge2RcvDlgw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Ge2RcvDlgw
- ggm 3y agoand GDB isn't a machine?
- nwiswell 3y agoIn the industry they are very literally called "tools". No one calls them "machines". E.g., "the fab is ordering another six EUV tools". Similarly a lathe or vertical mill is "a machine tool". They're ideally suited for a very specific task in the process of making a thing. It's possible for something to be both a machine and a tool. If we're being pedantic, the ASML tools (and indeed any modern wafer fabrication equipment) are also robots. More related to the business of tool making broadly, however, the entire industry of semiconductor wafer fabrication equipment (WFE) is quite profitable and margins tend to be generous. Much of the industry is very technical and does involve "bleeding edge technology", but not all of it. The publicly traded Japanese company Disco makes tools for wafer grinding[1], which are not really any more complex than your typical computer-controlled metal cutting machine tools, yet they are quite profitable[2]. Just look at those headline margin figures! It seems to be a matter of niche and competition. [1]: https://www.disco.co.jp/eg/products/grinder/dfg8560.html https://www.disco.co.jp/eg/products/grinder/dfg8560.html [2]: https://www.disco.co.jp/eg/ir/library/doc/film/20230420.pdf https://www.disco.co.jp/eg/ir/library/doc/film/20230420.pdf
- trollerator23 3y agoIn software tools. Hardware tools are hardware.
- PostOnce 3y agoThere are lots of profitable software tool companies, aren't there? Atlassian, JetBrains, Microsoft, most of them are smaller than this but still "money"; I live in open-source land, but everyone else I know works somewhere that spends money on all kinds of tools. It's just that the fruit in software tools doesn't hang so low, I think.
- evrimoztamur 3y agoIf your tool is an integral part of a larger chain, as is the case for ASML's machines being in the chain of silicon chips, that's a different story than a tool which simply eases the process by a small factor. UV lithography is the only way to make advanced chips required for various other tools and appliances, but an OS debugger (as the author puts it) is just a nicer printf. There's big money in one, and small money in the other.
- coldtea 3y ago>There no money in tools: The Dutch company ASML would like to talk to you. "You made a general argument. Here's a single counter-example, on a very tiny niche, compared to thousands of examples in your favor, making much more money in other areas of IT".
- Dalewyn 3y agoI mean, you're using a computer to shitpost here. Everything in that computer, let alone the computer as a whole, is a tool that made its manufacturer and any vendors involved lots of money.
- coldtea 3y agoYeah, I also wear clothes (kids go into garments/fashion), drink coffee (kids start coffee shops), and buy many other items besides. By this logic every market is a lucrative one, if people buy stuff from it. So, just go and build computers, companies make money selling them. Start the new Apple or Dell. It's almost as if this missed the point of TFA entirely, and as if "things are sold in that field and there are some player making lots of money in it" is useless by itself for evaluating a field/niche regarding to its money making opportunities. Let me introduce you to a wonderful concept: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opportunity_cost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opportunity_cost Not bad for shitposting eh?
- PostOnce 3y agoHere's another multibillion dollar example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lam_Research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lam_Research
- ggm 3y agoThe article specifically reaches into the whole "spanners are too cheap to be worth making" space. The article didn't say "except of course, those gold plated NASA spanners" or "ok: so this is a broad brush but there are notable exceptions" I called out an exception. I like the article. I think the point is well made. I would say it a bit differently: commodities are very hard to make profitably once the exemplar is good enough, and cheap enough. If you seek higher utility then don't be surprised if the people who use your Tool/Machine/Robot balk at the price, when their goal is met by the lower utility commodity. If you don't care about lead and tolerance, those fake resistors are just fine for hobbyist use. If your project needs lead free and 0.001% then you really need to pay the premium for originals, not fakes. And ASML is a niche, but an example of a generic problem in their line of reasoning. For almost any "industry" you care to mention from coathanger bending to lobster fishing, there is somebody making good profit selling what the coathanger-wrangler, or fisherman would call "a tool" ie: cute argument, but actually... sorry.. niches are everywhere.