2 ms·
I find myself growing tired of our trend of redefining words to make our favorite clichés apply to our favorite companies. Some examples: "The customer is alw
by nitrogen 15y ago
I find myself growing tired of our trend of redefining words to make our favorite clichés apply to our favorite companies.
Some examples:
"The customer is always right." -> "You're the product, not the customer."
"Software is made for users." -> "The publisher is the user, not you."
Sure, these things sound clever at first, but they only serve to increase our acceptance of these encroachments upon the rights of consumers and responsibilities of corporations by altering our vocabulary to fit these practices. Let's just stick with the traditional definitions (e.g. user: "the one sitting at the computer") and stop twisting words to accommodate things like DRM and privacy-invasive tracking.
- dredmorbius 15y agoI disagree with both your points. This isn't a redefinition of words. It's a clarification of the true situation. Again: if you're not paying for the product, and somebody else is, then you're the product, and your use of a system or viewing content, etc., is an intentional objective of the payer. You'd be well advised to be aware of this, because you're being manipulated. And the fact that someone else is paying for the system doesn't make it right. Just because I'm not paying for a DRM'd product (and very often you do pay) doesn't make it "right". In this case, usually, there are to goods in question: the information good for which you are the customer, that's covered by a DRM "service", for which the publisher is the customer. There are also goods for which there is no intrinsic monetary market, or for which the market is at best diffuse. Language is one such good (there are very few people whose paycheck is based on maintaining, debugging, and extending the English language, for example). Free Software is another, though there are both paid and unpaid contributors. And you might well ask what the objectives of those who are actively contributing are (propagandists and marketing types influence English, device manufacturers and standards promoters write significant amounts of Free Software).
- tjoff 15y agoI see "You're the product, not the customer." and "The publisher is the user, not you." as labels of warnings. For me that isn't twisting words to accomodate things like DRM and privacy-invasive tracking. If you tried to mask "You're the product, not the customer." as "The customer is always right." and "The publisher is the user, not you." as "Software is made for users." you'd be twisting words. If I'm the product or the publisher is the user I'm very careful with what I share or do on the service. One of the many reasons for why it wouldn't affect me much at all if google disappeared tomorrow.
- Jach 15y agoPersonally I like the trend, though like others I don't call them "redefinitions", it's more of a context switch and applying the phrase in a way its author didn't see. I like it because it takes seemingly clever or seemingly deep or seemingly insightful sentiments like "Programs exist for their users" and reveals their content-free tautological nature. The more tautologies we find the more we can focus on eliminating those from the conversation and talking about things that matter instead. Of course, sometimes the context switch doesn't reveal tautologies but actually harmful sentiments. You don't want a sado-masochist believing in the Golden Rule as a moral guideline for instance.