3 ms·
Is it unethical to have a society where only a small percentage can program computers?
Isn't this a fundamental skill just like reading/writing?
- yan 18y agoWhat makes programming computers a fundamental skill? What will forbid me from being a productive member of society if I don't know how to program?
- amichail 18y agoYou would never know what you are missing in today's society... It's kind of like not knowing the benefits of reading & writing. That's why it is unethical.
- yan 18y agoSo why isn't it unethical to not be a practicing medical doctor, dentist, physicist, mathematician, materials engineer, parent, charity donor, pilot, or an athlete. If your job, hobby or passion is in set J of all possible jobs and vocations, it doesn't make it unethical to not be J-j, where j is your job. And programming is nothing like reading and writing as you need reading and writing to be a functional adult. You absolutely can not survive and be affluent without reading & writing or know someone close to you who does. The same is not even remotely true for programming. As a matter of fact, if something requires a layman (or customer) to program, it means that one of us who creates these programs and products, to put it bluntly, fucked up.
- amichail 18y agoAnd programming is nothing like reading and writing as you need reading and writing to be a functional adult. ...in today's society. But certainly long ago people could get by without knowing reading & writing.
- noodle 18y agoum, no, definitely not. here are a few skills i would consider more fundamental than programming that are also lacking: * math * spelling * logic in addition, it would only be unethical if the society at hand were enforcing some sort of limitation. anyone can learn to program (or learn math/spelling/logic) if they want to. maybe its easier for some than others for various reasons, but everyone can.
- amichail 18y agoSpelling is not fundamental in an age of spelling checkers. What do you mean by math? Being able to do basic arithmetic well is not all that important in the computer age. Logic of course is important and it's something that would go well with programming skills.
- noodle 18y agogood point. perhaps we should allow people to design and engineer cars that know nothing of mechanics? or people to build space shuttles who know nothing of aeronautics? or people to build nuclear power plans without knowledge of nuclear physics? i mean, all of that is just totally taken care of by computers nowadays, amirite?
- amichail 18y agoWriting skills are still considered important even though most people will not be writing novels. It's kind of like that here with computer programming skills.
- brk 18y agoUnethical? How? I'm not aware of any limitations in society that prevent anyone from being able to learn how to program computers? Or are you suggesting that somehow computers should be dumbed down to the lowest possible common denominator?
- arockwell 18y agoI'm really confused by what you mean by unethical in the first place. Programming is not at all a fundamental skill, and I hope that as software gets better and better people will be able to do more with their computers without knowing how to program our configure some stupid setting. There's still too many simple tasks that are out of reach without some technical knowledge.
- tsally 18y agoI think it is important to differentiate between knowing how to program and having a fundamental understanding about how technology works. Knowing how to program is hardly a necessity; if we have legislators, judges, and law enforcement who cannot comprehend technology on a basic level, that is a problem. It is not so much unethical as it is self destructive.
- hopeless 18y agoOnly a small percentage can fix cars, build bridges, prepare meat, cook fresh food, knit/crochet/sew cloths, etc... so no, a programming minority is not the threat to our society that you might think
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoA human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects. Robert A Heinlein, Time Enough for Love
- inimino 18y agoArguably, programming is as enriching a mental facility as reading and writing, and to be without this tool due to an educational oversight is tragic. However, in a culture where lacking this skill is the norm (and many grew up without even a chance at it) you'll find this argument unpopular.