6 ms·
Sugary drinks tax could prevent decay and increase health equity: study
- Bluescreenbuddy 3y agoGet ready for people to fight tooth and nail. We tried this in Chicagoland/Cook county. Lasted about two months.
- damnesian 3y agoEspecially the "I have the right to shoot myself with my own gun" crowd.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- c22 3y agoWe have a sugar tax in Seattle. The primary opponents were fast food places. End result: the $1.50 hot dog and a soda combo at costco comes with diet soda now, so I no longer get it. Aside from that, I'm drinking as much soda as I ever did, I just have less money ¯\_(-_-)_/¯
- catboybotnet 3y agoIt was a time, to be sure. I remember hearing the ads in favor of the tax (something like a grandmother worrying about her grandchildren drinking too many sodie pops), and as soon as they came they disappeared.
- slybootz 3y agoSpent those two months buying my Dr Pepper in DuPage county
- umvi 3y agoInstead of a sugary drinks tax, how about ending corn subsidies that cause high fructose corn syrup to be so cheap? That would naturally cause soda to be more expensive
- rqtwteye 3y agoThat’s what I am thinking. I am ok with food subsidies but we should direct them towards healthy food.
- citrin_ru 3y agoI don't know exact numbers, but AFAIK even if HFCS will be 10x more expensive it will not increase drink price significantly because each can/bottle contains only a small (but still unhealthy) amount of it (and raw ingredients only a fraction of cost to begin with).
- lofatdairy 3y agoThis is Monash U in Australia and seems pretty explicitly focused on the Australian context. Maybe corn is as subsidized there as it is in the states but a cursory search makes me skeptical. At any rate, this forum does attract a fairly international readership, but if we wanted a US-centric study we could maybe look at the long term outcomes from cities that have levied taxes (nothing state level it seems like), such as this study in Oakland, CA: https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1004212 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo... I suppose we'd see something similar on a broader scale w/ a reduction in subsidies, but in terms of knock on effects and scale they're not _too_ comparable (i.e. SSBs are a single product, corn in general goes into a lot of different products, etc)
- kjkjadksj 3y agoBecause sucrose coke is sold for the same price. Not a lot of high minimum wages where sugar cane is cut.
- taminka 3y agoi mean, for example here in europe there’s no such iiuc, sugary drinks are still way too sugary and way too cheap
- gizmo686 3y ago1) The profit margin on soda is massive, and HFCS is only a small portion of the cost. 2) What corn subsidies? We are talking about Australia. I am no expert in Australian economics, nor agricultural policy, but my understanding after a bit of searching is that they do not subsidize corn https://farmers.org.au/blog/farm-subsidies-in-australia-the-facts/ https://farmers.org.au/blog/farm-subsidies-in-australia-the-... You could argue that the US subsidy is effecting Australia through the global market. However, to the extent that this is relevent, Australia'a recourse would be a tarif on such products entering the market; at which point you might as well tax that which you want to discourage. 3) The problem is not high fructose corn syrup. It is sugar water. Granted, the exact composition of the sugar does have some effect. For a given amount of sugar, excess free fructose is probably worse for you than roughly equal proportions of fructose and glucose. Having said that, fructose tastes sweater for a given amount of sugar. So I'm not sure how it plays out in general. Having said that, according to the FDA, HFCS is either 42% or 55% fructose, which is lower than I would expect. (Actually. HFCS-42 sounds like low fructose. Most natural food has a 50-50 split.). https://www.fda.gov/food/food-additives-petitions/high-fructose-corn-syrup-questions-and-answers https://www.fda.gov/food/food-additives-petitions/high-fruct... Having said that, I did find fairly consistent reporting that sodas are closer to 60% fructose. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0899900714001920 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089990071...
- guerilla_prgrmr 3y agoThe perfect tax. Raises money whilst also discouraging objectively harmful behaviour.
- aaa_aaa 3y agoYou forgot </sarcasm>
- justin_oaks 3y agoWhere does the money go? If it goes into the general fund and gets to be large enough, then government programs become dependent on it. The funds start to dry up if people actually stop engaging in the behavior. Then the government starts running low on funds they were dependent on. I've always thought that these kinds of "vice taxes" shouldn't go into the general fund. They should go toward things that are related to helping the cause. In this case, the funds could go into awareness programs, subsidies for healthy foods, etc.
- mightypirate 3y ago[dead]
- imchillyb 3y agoThis is a poor tax, nothing more.
- honeybadger1 3y ago100% truth, but you will have people here who say its smart.
- tboyd47 3y agoThen you make the public good dependent on citizens' self-harm. Just like all the "Master Settlement Agreements" with Big Tobacco.
- jader201 3y agoFor those not reading the article, this is in Australia.
- nightski 3y agoI don't even drink sugary sodas and I hate the idea of this.
- manojlds 3y agoDoes it increase equity? I always thought eating healthier is becoming more and more of a costly affair.
- hospitalJail 3y agoMy understanding is that fresh foods are cheaper than processed/unhealthy foods according to this website: https://efficiencyiseverything.com/food-nutrition-per-dollar/ https://efficiencyiseverything.com/food-nutrition-per-dollar... I suppose the counter to that is that you could drink oil, but that is a bit unrealistic. Something to consider is that not all fresh foods are equal. Lettuce is way healthier and cheaper than imported raspberries that need to be basically overnighted to maintain freshness. Seems like eating healthy is an education problem. Although even as myself, who I consider educated in the manner, I find myself overeating healthy foods out of hedonism and putting on weight.
- GoldenRacer 3y agoThere's also the convenience issue. If you work multiple low skill jobs just to make ends meet, you might not have the time to turn fresh produce into a meal. If you're trying to limit yourself to foods that require limited/no preparation and are cheap, you do end up getting a lot of unhealthy options that fill that niche. You can get around this. I've personally spent years of my life eating just rice and beans with a bag of frozen vegetables. You can get a really low priced rice cooker ($20-30) that you can spend <1 minute setting up (it'll steam the veggies while it cooks the rice) and then let it run while you're in the shower or doing something else. In the end you get a reasonably health albeit bland meal with less time spent prepping than actually eating. I get why it starts to make sense to just grab a $5 burrito at taco bell as a meal when you're rushing to your second job though.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIf you are pushed into water as a result that probably represents a small stimulus.
- gagged_s_poster 3y ago
- scarygliders 3y agoThis is, to put it bluntly, bollox. A prime example of a "health tax" such as this is the Scottish Nationalist Party's tax on alcohol - in a bid to increase health by putting a minimum pricing on alcoholic beverages. The result? Nothing has changed, there is still the same amount of health problems in Scotland caused by alcohol. Sugar taxes have also been proposed in the UK, and heavily combated. It just will not work. The best you can do is to highlight how bad sugar is to health in general, and hope it influences people to change their habits - I for one try to reduce my sugar intake whenever possible.
- joncrocks 3y agoThere is already a sugary drinks levy in the UK - https://www.gov.uk/government/news/soft-drinks-industry-levy-comes-into-effect https://www.gov.uk/government/news/soft-drinks-industry-levy...
- kjkjadksj 3y agoDo you have data? I have some showing sugar taxes do work: https://today.uic.edu/research-reveals-new-evidence-that-sugary-beverage-tax-impacts-are-sustainable-effective/ https://today.uic.edu/research-reveals-new-evidence-that-sug...
- meinmissoula 3y ago> The best you can do is to highlight how bad sugar is to health in general, and hope it influences people to change their habits We've been trying that for years and it's clearly not working. Obesity, diabetes, pre-diabetes, heart disease, diseases of chronic inflammation, etc are all at epidemic levels. Humans aren't perfect automatons that will make perfect choices if given information. We develop addictions, we prioritize the short-term over the long-term, we get tired and choose what's easy and available. We should align incentives to better outcomes. We restrict alcohol and nicotine and opioids. Taking steps to reduce the societal harm of sugar is a good thing for society.
- Philorandroid 3y ago> Humans aren't perfect automatons that will make perfect choices if given information. And yet, somehow, they will rationally conclude the best financial course to take is to realign to making healthier choices instead of switching to dollar-store sodas or making their own sugary drinks.
- javajosh 3y agoThis general pattern is so dangerous, politically. Using taxes to shape behavior opens up a potentially very invasive, nanny-like attitude towards individuals, and ultimately codifying what is vice and what is virtue in law. The slippery slope here is obvious: fining people for not going to the gym enough, a screen tax to curb excessive computer usage, etc. But ultimately the issue is a combination of hubris and distrust: hubris because you have to think you know best to implement these policies, and distrust because you take that decision away from individuals. (And don't get me wrong, THAT argument is also abused by providers of outright poisonous products. I'm arguing for deep reluctance to do things like this rather than the libertarian position of never doing it.)
- Rygian 3y agoIndividuals are already subject to a very invasive, predator-like attitude, courtesy of corporations for whom a higher market cap is the only key metric, and the long-term impact on public health is a minor concern. We're already sliding down very fast down the private equity slippery slope.
- Philorandroid 3y agoDo you mean to suggest adding another predator would address the first? That somehow, because there's a legal writ behind it, it makes it any more morally right?
- Rygian 3y agoNo. I'm defending the need for a nanny-like actor, under public oversight, and with opposite financial incentives to reduce healthcare expenditure by improving public health.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWhat about the opposite of paying higher taxes and health insurance premiums because you have to pay for other people’s type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and heart disease? Surely, those subsidies shape behavior just as much as a tax shapes behavior.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mc32 3y agoThis something I can get onboard with. It’s been like an Overton window of the palate. Things have gotten sweeter and sweeter over time. We need to claw that back so that our taste buds will relearn how to appreciate a small amount of sweetener instead of needing to be overwhelmed to just taste it.
- honeybadger1 3y agoPeople who ask for this should be ignored in a free society. Please move to some place where authoritarian leadership tells you what to think daily and allow us independent people with self-discipline to thrive. Edited because it did not convey my actual feelings on the topic, just a heated rant I corrected
- becquerel 3y agoI agree; that's why children should also be allowed to smoke cigars if they say they want to
- currymj 3y agoyes -- these authoritarians are causing problems in our society. we simply need to root them out and expel them all, then we the people could live in peace in a society free from authoritarianism...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- honeybadger1 3y agoIt's through allowing all free speech that we now know who we can ignore.
- loeg 3y ago> People who ask for this should be ignored in a free society. Please move to some place where authoritarian leadership tells you what to think daily and allow is independent people with self-discipline to thrive. > Edited because it did not convey my actual feelings on the topic, just a heated rant I corrected I don't know what this looked like before the edit, but it's still just a heated rant.
- ink_13 3y agoPigouvian taxes are the best taxes. Externalities? Those cost money now! Want less of a behaviour? Put a tax on it! Want to reduce your tax burden? Do less of the bad thing! "But I don't want to stop doing the bad thing!" That's fine! You can keep doing it. It just costs money now. "But that's unfair!" Is it? The societal goal is to reduce the bad thing. We don't want to ban it outright, and some kind of regulatory framework sounds complicated and expensive. This is the easiest and cheapest (from the government's perspective) way of reducing the bad thing. "People are going to just keep doing the bad thing anyway!" What an opportunity to raise the price! Sounds like extra money for roads, schools, and parks. Or maybe a chance to reduce reliance on other taxes.
- everdrive 3y agoI think there are at least two problems with this argument. The first is a classic —- if your tax base requires money made from a vice, you’ve got a stream of money which either requires that the vice continues to exist, or else a stream of money which you hope to lose in the in future. The second is a bit more basic. Who gets to decide what he vices are?
- jjoonathan 3y ago"You vill eat ze bugs and you vill like zem!" I'm all for a sugar tax, but I am fully aware that drawing lines is going to be difficult, you should be too, and it seems like a weird problem to gloss over because it's clearly the big problem here. What do we do with artificial sweeteners? I'm sure there will be vocal contingents saying we obviously should/shouldn't sin tax them. What about LaCroix? Same. I think the answer is obviously shouldn't/shouldn't, but I know people who get shouty because their fad micronutrient of the month isn't aggressively marketed by the FDA. It is possible to go too far: I grew up in a house that omitted salt from its cooking to a degree that I would now say constitutes a food crime, even though I'd fully agree that most prepared food errs on the side of too much salt. In any case, I fully expect that unless we exercise extreme restraint on this road, it won't be very long at all before someone will try to twist my arm into a dietary choice that I consider gross, insane, and completely detached from evidence-based reality.
- sunflowerfly 3y ago
- ck2 3y agoWe already have a realworld example of this with cigarettes. It doesn't work. Half of my neighbors sit outside and constantly smoke, regardless of the danger, regardless of the constant warnings, regardless of the tremendous expense via taxes. And the tax never makes it back into healthcare, it's abused by politicians. You want to end bad self-destructive behavior? Give people an education and motivation into giving a damn about their own bodies.
- SonicScrub 3y agoThe evidence strongly disagrees with your anecdote in relation to cigarettes. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8565856/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8565856/ And in relation to sugary drinks https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9161017/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9161017/
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoOf all the sin taxes, this is the one that directly disproportionally targets poor people the most.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoPoor people can least afford to deal with the related health issues. It’s not like there are mustache-twirling villains coming up with ways to punch down even harder here. Diets high in sugar are more likely to lead to painful and even dangerous oral health issues, pancreatic/kidney/liver issues, diabetes, and obesity with all of its knock on effects. It only has a negative effect for people who will never reduce the sugar in their diet, and those are the people who should be paying into socialized healthcare at a higher rate because they’ll need lots of benefits later. So really they’re saving to take care of themselves, making this a net positive long term. I know it’s harder than “just stop eating sugar” but feelings or preferences don’t change the facts of biochemistry. Until you can disprove the findings, the policy should reflect the state of the science. And by all means find more/better ways to incentivize or even subsidize healthier options for those on the low end of the socioeconomic ladder. That is absolutely one of the things taxes like this should fund.
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoI worked for a sugar drink company for over a decade in the poorest neighborhoods. They won't even notice the tax. They'll still buy the product. They'll just have less money to spend in other areas. But by all means push another tax on people who can least afford it.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoBut at what cost? Taxation is equivalent to theft and corporate destruction. Do you really want to be the person who destroys a corporation just so some kid doesn't get dental caries? Are you going to be the person to put the gun to Coke's head and pull the trigger? What about all of Coke's subsidiaries? Where does it end? Would you tax millionaires? Just because they make more money than average? Is this post parody?
- sixstringtheory 3y agoYou use evocative imagery to make an emotional, slippery-slope argument, but if by “putting a gun to Coke’s head and pulling the trigger” you mean reducing the profitability of a business that thrives by sewing seeds that will eventually blossom into negative outcomes for people, and fining them for any noncompliance with regulations, well then just let me know when you want to go for target practice!
- yowlingcat 3y agoYou know, people had a lot of complaints about Bloomberg's soda ban in NYC but for this reason, I understood where he was coming from.
- kbutler 3y agoAlthough my understanding of economics supports taxation as a mechanism of changing behavior (marginal changes in the economic jargon not meaning "minimal"), my understanding is that cigarette taxes haven't had much effect changing behavior, possibly because of addiction, possibly because the taxes aren't high enough. There's also the complication that the excise taxes become a recurring source of revenue, causing a new addiction.
- Eumenes 3y agoI use to be pretty libertarian in my views on sugary drink and fast food taxes ... but at this point, its a major blight on society and people truly can't help themselves. My spouse works in healthcare and often is involved in caring for diabetes patients - they literally pick soda and sweets over limbs. They'd rather consume mountain dew and ice cream vs keeping their arms and legs. Even when doctors prevent food/drink orders with sugary crap, their friends/family bring in more garbage. The number of obese people walking around and density of fast food places in urban areas is utterly disgusting. Explore around google maps in big urban areas, or even small ones - you can easily find 20-30 fast food places in towns of less than 30k people. Easy property tax revenue I guess?
- gnicholas 3y agoAh yes, increasing ‘health equity’ by levying a tax that disproportionately hits poorer people. Sin taxes are a tricky thing!
- sixstringtheory 3y agoAlready addressed this argument in another reply so I’ll just link it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36865508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36865508
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stickyricky 3y agoI love the language we choose to communicate ideas. "Increase health equity" is such an interesting phrase. I'd like to propose others: - Sugary drinks tax could reduce diversity in health outcomes: study. - Sugary drinks tax could boost diversity in healthier lifestyles: study. Or perhaps a more stodgy, economical way of thinking: - Sugary drinks tax could incentivize participation in health initiatives: study. Or perhaps an article shared on facebook: - BOOM! SUGARY DRINKS TAX PUTS COUNTRY BACK ON TRACK!
- gorwell 3y ago"equity" is being used as though it's a magic key word and as though it's not the road to hell. Is it getting confused with "equality"? Equality: Equal opportunity, everyone treated the same Equity: Equal outcomes, people treated differently in order to achieve equity The only way you get equity is through extreme top down authoritarian control and force. Think about what you'd have to do to enforce equity with one's own relatives, or even brothers and sisters, let alone society wide.
- Philorandroid 3y agoJust Mandate the Good Ideas™ The comments suggesting people would just decide to have fewer sugary drinks to save money seem to be forgetting how humans act when something they like is made less available. It will be a wake-up call to exactly no one. Cheaper brand-X sodas would fill the void left by more expensive ones, enterprising individuals might even make their own sodas or switch to lemonade, etc. The perceived scarcity might even lead more people who don't normally drink soda to start. I'd think that incentivizing the proliferation of taste-alike low/no-sugar sodas would have a much better outcome anyways. Tax credits to businesses that adequately serve and promote low-sugar sodas could be a good start.
- mistermithras 3y agoSeattle has such a tax. It has done nothing to stop people from purchasing that foul stuff, however. They simply go to a neighbouring city and purchase it there - for less.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoIt’s not really cheaper though, as you spend more time and resources traveling for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]