The case is about whether Ms Luke was operating the PayPal account she created. I don’t doubt her story, but if you can claim the account is yours when it suit

The case is about whether Ms Luke was operating the PayPal account she created. I don’t doubt her story, but if you can claim the account is yours when it suits you (“where’s my stuff?!”) is it fine to claim it’s not yours when it doesn’t (“these transactions were done by someone else!”)? Is there a contradiction there? Perhaps not: I doubt you can use a PayPal database row to enforce a contract — you’d need an invoice or order confirmation — so neither should another party be able to use the PayPal db to convict you of fraud. Was there other evidence against Luke?