4 ms·
"Identity Theft" shouldn't even be a thing. Someone falsifies documents and takes out a loan or something that should not have been approved. That's bank fraud
by ryandrake 3y ago
"Identity Theft" shouldn't even be a thing. Someone falsifies documents and takes out a loan or something that should not have been approved. That's bank fraud and should be an issue entirely between the fraudster and the lender/bank.
Somehow banks have re-named it from "bank fraud" to "identity theft," deftly shifting responsibility onto some unrelated third party, who now has to deal with it. "Your identity was stolen! That makes you the victim. Now go help fix it!"
Banks should not be able to shift the blame. They did a crappy job and lent money or opened an account for someone they shouldn't have. They are the ones who should bear the burden of mopping up their mistake.
- jaredandrews 3y agoYes thank you. This is my "actually it's GNU + Linux" tic, please fellow Americans (and I would be interested in learning if this problem exists in other countries) do not accept the framing that a bank giving a loan to someone they thought was you is _your problem_! It's their problem! We should not be normalizing this phrase or practice.
- codetrotter 3y ago> I would be interested in learning if this problem exists in other countries In Norway you can voluntarily register as not wanting to allow credit assessments to be performed on you. This in turn can help a bit because it results in most attempts at making loans in your name not being possible. https://www.datatilsynet.no/regelverk-og-verktoy/sporsmal-svar/kredittopplysning/hvordan-sette-sperre/ https://www.datatilsynet.no/regelverk-og-verktoy/sporsmal-sv... There are four companies in Norway that do credit assessments. You have to individually register your desire to not allow credit assessments for your name with all four of these. https://tfinans.no/blogg/frivillig-kredittsperre https://tfinans.no/blogg/frivillig-kredittsperre But then, what protects you against someone simply requesting that your credit is unlocked and then taking loans in your name after all? Well, from what I gather one would have to use BankID to confirm that credit is to be unlocked. So even if someone steals my passport, they will not immediately be able to unlock my credit. They’d have to jump through a bunch of hoops to also steal my BankID.
- jacquesm 3y agoInteresting. This should be adopted by the EU. (I know Norway is not a member state but this makes good sense and that's why I would love to see the EU to adopt it.)
- Hamuko 3y agoI imagine they already exist in EU states. I got one in Finland after my ID card was stolen and someone was trying to buy stuff on credit with my ID. Paid a small fee of like 10€ to get a two-year credit freeze. They also give you a certificate from it that you can use to verify that the black mark in your credit history is a voluntary block. Never actually had to use it, was a student back then and I didn't have any credit to apply to, mobile phone plans to buy, apartments to rent etc.
- vasco 3y agoI disagree with this system, banks can instead require the exact same Auth process they'd use to unblock your "no credit" request when they want to start a new credit for anyone. Why would there be more checks to "remove block" than to "start credit"? I can think of one reason that's good for the banks. The "locked" state should be the default, whatever extra checks they need to do to a person that has it "frozen", that should just be the default to start any credit! If anyone has some dire need for easy credit all the time they can do the opposite and go to some "light checks" state like TSA pre-check.
- piva00 3y agoIn Sweden all banks require me to sign off credit requests through BankID as well, so the check can be performed but I need to ultimately sign it.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoYou can do this in America. It’s called a credit freeze. A problem is credit freezes can also be fraudulently lifted, but serve as a decent barrier for most run of the mill mass frauds. They’re virtually unknown and require you to independent contact each individual credit bureaus to both freeze then unfreeze. https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/what-know-about-credit-freezes-fraud-alerts https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/what-know-about-credit-fre...
- dctoedt 3y ago> the framing that a bank giving a loan to someone they thought was you is _your problem_ Brings to mind the tale that jaywalking laws were the creation of early-days automobile manufacturers and dealers who wanted to clear the streets for the vehicles they wanted to sell. [0] [0] https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history
- sqrt_1 3y agoClassic skit on identity theft by Mitchell & Webb https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- YeBanKo 3y agoThis is a spot on. Now how do we make force a change on the legal framework to make this mind shift happen?
- gorgoiler 3y agoThe case is about whether Ms Luke was operating the PayPal account she created. I don’t doubt her story, but if you can claim the account is yours when it suits you (“where’s my stuff?!”) is it fine to claim it’s not yours when it doesn’t (“these transactions were done by someone else!”)? Is there a contradiction there? Perhaps not: I doubt you can use a PayPal database row to enforce a contract — you’d need an invoice or order confirmation — so neither should another party be able to use the PayPal db to convict you of fraud. Was there other evidence against Luke?
- wjnc 3y agoYou’re right, both morally and legally. My friend a government law professor told me that in the EU you could probably even construct a pretty solid case arguing this. The argument would be that If there is not a single slip of evidence tying you physically to the money Except your PII Then the banks anti-money laundering should have catched it. That gets their attention right away since the fines in that cases are proper billions. If they don’t settle, you go for the kill and settle that PII is not uniquely tied to legal intent (heck, it wasn’t you! The intent is missing and that’s what you point out as well.) The problem is that that case will take you 7+ years, all the way to the various supreme courts (local, European). It’s why Max Schrems is a hero, except banks are worse adversaries than government regulators. This whole digital world has had some impact on our two thousand years plus of contract law. It’s sad judges don’t go back to the basics in these cases. Show me the contract (into the abyss).
- Semaphor 3y agoI’m not sure what the exact rules and regulations are, but at least in Germany you should be well protected. The German Wikipedia entry [0] is a bit confusing, as it both has damages (I checked the primary source, no further information) but also a section how it will not be your issue as the other party was defrauded, so I can only guess it’s people who simply paid (fraudulent online shop orders or fraudulent withdrawals) without fighting back. [0]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identit%C3%A4tsdiebstahl https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identit%C3%A4tsdiebstahl
- blitzar 3y agoI thought I was depositing a billon dollars with the real bank, turns out it was fake. The bank now owes me a billion dollars. This works for me.
- parentheses 3y agoIn a nutshell, KYC!
- Affric 3y ago> They are the ones who should bear the burden of mopping up their mistake. This is true to a large extent but having worked in resolving "identity theft" I can say that it is complex. In a place like the UK the requirements for a bank loan are pretty stringent but here in Australia they are much much lower and people hate friction. Authentication is a hard problem. Knowing someone's creditworthiness is a hard problem. There are a also many of people out there who are willing to claim "identity theft" has occurred to mean that it is complicated. Most of the time for people whose identities had been stolen it was fairly easy to remove based on the most cursory evidence (which often I only had access to because I had access to air gapped data that was kept for far longer than the 7 years it was meant to be kept). The status quo exists because it inconveniences just few enough people and is an acceptable amount of risk to the powerful. One side of politics will denounce anything that looks after the interest of both these groups as too much "red tape" and the other will denounce it as "discriminatory". For comparison I look to the family violence measures we introduced here in the last decade. It was a battle which took years of firmly but politely refuting the opposing ideas "family violence victims should never have to justify themselves to a credit provider" against "credit providers should never increase their risk without having charged more up front". A compromise model was found where the credit providers effectively pay for the losses but in reality they just charge it back to their customers. Right now paying for identity theft is a lottery. In future it's going to be internalised up front. This will be good for the victims but for the rest of us its an increased cost.