8 ms·
> When Google can do something that every one of it's users hates I don't think this is remotely the case. Quite a few tech-savvy people I know (some of them
by kelnos 3y ago
> When Google can do something that every one of it's users hates
I don't think this is remotely the case. Quite a few tech-savvy people I know (some of them software developers) use Chrome and mostly don't care about whatever Google does with it. I mention "manifest v3" and get a blank stare. I talk about advertising and ad blockers, and most people don't care, with some of them not even using ad blockers.
We really live in a bubble, here on HN. Most people think of privacy as some abstract thing that they have little control over, and are mostly fine with that. And some are even also fine with government erosion of privacy, in the name of "save the children" style arguments, and of corporate erosion of privacy, in the name of getting free stuff in exchange for their personal information.
It's a sad state of affairs. If most people really did care strongly about these sorts of issues, then I think it would be baffling why we haven't seen more change here -- after all, Firefox is a perfectly viable alternative to Chrome that very few people use. But the lack of change is no surprise: most people don't care.
- lima 3y agoI'm a tech-savvy person and I consider Manifest v3 an improvement (improves security + performance), and Firefox implements it as well as things like declarativeNetRequest[1]. [1]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/WebExtensions/API/declarativeNetRequest https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/Web...
- gruez 3y agoManifest v3 itself is an improvement and is probably non-controversial. I can't see why anyone would think deprecating manifest v2 along with removing webRequest is a good thing. The latter is what everyone is mad about when they talk about "manifest v3". I'm not sure whether you're trying to making a nitpick point about the difference between the two, or you legitimately think the latter is a good thing.
- hn92726819 3y agoCan you expand on the security improvements of v3? This is the first I've heard this. As for performance... That sounds dubious. Declarative blocking surely will be faster than v2, but what is being blocked by v2, I would imagine, is generally way slower than the difference between v2 and v3. At the end of the day, I don't see the performance of my browser negatively impacted by uBlock Origin, I see it saving CPU, bandwidth, memory, privacy, etc. I'd be willing to bet that whatever isn't blocked by v3 is sifnificantly slower than whatever supposed slowness there is with v2 (in general).
- plorkyeran 3y agoGoogle's PR has claimed that manifest v3 has security and privacy improvements, but it's pretty straightforwardly a lie.
- j16sdiz 3y agoV3 security is like closing a window in a room with fully open door --- it's good if we have someone watching the door , and we don't.
- neilv 3y ago> We really live in a bubble, here on HN. Multiple bubbles on HN. Obviously, most of us are complicit in some techbro business conventions today that, 30 years ago, would've gotten us shunned by our peers, and reported to the authorities. (Not that current phenomena weren't foreseen. SF writers had already been all over it. Anecdotally, Internet-savvy techies were often informed by various forward-looking thinking and by world history, and tended to act like stewards rather than exploiters.)
- flyinghamster 3y agoEven in 1985, there was the RISKS list... and it's still around. Archive: https://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/ https://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/ So much of our current hellscape was foretold long ago.
- anderspitman 3y agoI don't see a huge difference between Firefox and Chrome these days, as they implement everything Google tells them to (and pays them to)
- the_third_wave 3y agoI can still block content in any way I see fit on Gecko-based applications, not so much on Blink-based things. There are many things about Firefox-the-browser and Mozilla-the-organisation which could do with an overhaul but as it stands it is still my go-to browser. I only use Blink-based things to test and for those (annoying) sites which insist on it in which case I first try Bromite, then Ungoogled Chromium. If it still does not work it is not worth visiting. I do not have Chrome installed on any device and have never felt I was missing out.
- K0nserv 3y agoThis just isn't true, have look through https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/ https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/ and check the authors of some of the proposals Mozilla are negative about. There's even a post on front page right now about Mozilla's position on the very proposal we are discussing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36857032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36857032
- ineptech 3y agoI don't buy this. I'm sure most iphone users don't care when you ask them about privacy or manifest v3 as an abstract concept, but remember what happened when Apple tried to push a U2 album to them? They lost their collective shit. They may not write blog posts about privacy or donate to the EFF, but they have deeply personal relationships with "their" phone and they absolutely hate being reminded that it isn't really theirs. If this weren't true, Apple could just start inserting ads into every iphone's Safari window tomorrow, and Youtube could serve the ad in the same stream as the video to defeat adblockers, and they'd make a bunch of extra money with no downside. The fact that they don't do this suggests that Apple and Google understand this: people only tolerate restricted platforms that do a convincing job of pretending to be unrestricted. In practice, this means that step 1 of Google foisting off user-hostile stuff on us is getting Firefox to include it too, which is presumably why they spend so much money on it.
- nl 3y agoNo one I knew really cared much about the U2 album except that it was a bad album and they didn't want it in their collection. From the people I know there no one upset about the power dynamics - everyone who complained would have been 100% happy if Apple had given them an album they liked.
- TylerE 3y agoAnd also, in a bug I'm not sure was entirely on Apple, when plugged into many car stereos iTunes would start playing the first song in your library, so users were annoyed because everythime they'd plug their phone into their car to charge it would start playing a 3rd tier U2 album.
- pessimizer 3y ago> mostly don't care about whatever Google does This is not support, this is lack of awareness or apathy.
- alex7734 3y ago> after all, Firefox is a perfectly viable alternative to Chrome that very few people use I don't use Firefox because it's slower than Chrome and because their behavior regarding limiting which extensions are available in phones, requiring signed extensions, Firefox Pocket, ads in new tab page, etc, does not exactly give me confidence that Mozilla truly has my interests in mind. In fact I bet they'll implement the nightmare DRM API once it's done swiftly and without complaint lest their money flow suffer. If Mozilla ever decides to stop screwing around, clearly position themselves as an ally of the consumer, clearly express support for adblockers and put resources into making the browser faster and better and more customizable instead of whatever makes their CEO richer then I'll switch to Firefox even if it is a bit slower or has some flaws. In the meantime uBlock works right now in Chrome which makes it usable, so since Chrome is the fastest right now, Chrome it is.
- fabrice_d 3y agoMozilla just took position against this DRM API: https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/852#issuecomment-1648820747 https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/852#is... Also, Firefox just passed ahead of Chrome on some JS speed benchmark, so you should get ready to switch back!
- alex7734 3y agoThat's nice to know, I'll give it a try soon then!
- Tingling7497 3y agoIt's for nightly currently (+2 from prod version), but I'm using dev on my work computer and base prod on my private one, and it's _fast_. Just setup ublock origin to filter annoyances as well, and it actually quite quickens the browsing experience. PS Chrome is faster because it cheats and takes shortcuts in loading CSS. Check it out, it skips some frames when loading, to show the page faster.
- worrycue 3y ago
- mistrial9 3y agothis argument is inadequate because it only examines and explains one side of a multi-part system. The users of consumer electronics as a mass at a point in time is not sufficient, even if well described, to explain important changes of the system over time. When you talk about communications technology adopted at a societal scale, changes in norms and routine have ripple effects. Most certainly one of those is a change in asymmetric power relations by central communications companies, versus the user of their systems who get strictly limited information views of what is happening with their phone calls or emails. When you have asymmetric power relations with market advantage and secondly literal surveillance at stake, a unilateral change in the service agreement is not a small "oh well" matter. This single statement "people do not care" does not show all the players, and most especially does not show the players making decisions, the management of the companies making more money or new revenues with new decisions.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>Firefox is a perfectly viable alternative to Chrome that very few people use. The problem is that it isn't. Do you know why Firefox managed to usurp IE6 in the first place? Because it won the adoption and appeal of tech enthusiasts and professionals. Mom and pop (read: the general population) switched to Firefox from IE6 because their tech nerd kids installed it for them, and the enterprise largely moved off of IE6 dependence because the general population moved off. But the Firefox today is not the Firefox that defeated IE6. Mozilla steadily eroded and destroyed every single thing tech enthusiasts and professionals loved about Firefox, to the point it practically became just a Chrome ripoff. At that point, why bother? Chrome's right there, the real deal. Not to mention Mozilla happily takes money from Google with no shame at all so their CEO can get her fat paychecks. Firefox is not a viable alternative, Firefox is literally controlled opposition to pedantically argue Chrome is not a monopoly. Not even the Intel and AMD x86 duopoly is this blatant.
- SoftTalker 3y agoFirefox did not defeat IE6. That was Chrome. Firefox has basically been a fringe browser since Netscape imploded. The original reason Google started the Chrome project was that the stagnation of IE6 was a barrier to implementing the web software they wanted to build. At least that's what they told us.
- Dalewyn 3y agoNo, it was Firefox that defeated IE6. Chrome came and defeated Firefox; Firefox's reign was rather shortlived. It seems this particular moment in history has been either forgotten or rewritten, judging from this thread and another one from yesterday.
- acomjean 3y agoThis is true. As someone who had a work time card I could fill out on Solaris using Firefox. This the new time card website came out that was “ie” only and we had to log onto a virtual NT server do our time card. Ugh. It was a nightmare. Then slowly Firefox came back. It was short lived majority but I still use it. I rather like it.
- onethought 3y agoIf I don't want to be tracked, I won't use chrome. If I don't care then I'll use it. Just like I'll have some conversations on WeChat but if I want to talk about Chinese politics maybe I'll do that on another platform. I don't really see the erosion in the corporate space. The erosion of privacy is happening at the government level. With "forced backdoor" laws and/or just outright forking the internet backbone (ala PRISM). I've never really understood "Corporate erosion of privacy"... It's opposite, Privacy is literally a USP of Apple products. They had to back out changes that hinted at an erosion of that trust with the on-device processing of Photos for cloud-sync. People are more aware than ever.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"Exactly how the rest of the world feels about this is not necessarily relevant, though." This quote is from page 2 of the article. It is common for certain HN commenters to remind us that HN is a bubble. True. However, the author of this article is not necessarily in this bubble. But, honestly, what difference does it make whether HN is a bubble or not. Google is a bubble. The Register, another entity outside the HN bubble, calls Google "The Chocolate Factory".^1 Does it matter that Google is a bubble. 1. Of course it's also common for certain HN commenters to try to broadly dismiss all journalism, on a news aggregator site no less. Maybe there is a pattern here. Would anyone outside the HN bubble try to discredit the observations about so-called "tech" companies mabe by those inside it. (Besides those with vested interests in so-called "tech" companies.) All evidence I've seen since 2009 points to the contrary.
- ChrisCinelli 3y agoThe reason HN is a bubble is because people here actually get and interested in real tech news. If a journalist would explain these news to the masses AND the news has a way to reach the masses. These days these kinds of news do not make it to broadcasted news and most people do not watch the old broadcasted news. The news currently get people attention from the news feed on Android and Apples phones. Those feeds recommend only the kind of content you usually interact with. No many people gets tech articles. And you can even argue that there is some extra filters on what news get on the feed in first place.
- darreninthenet 3y agoI have to disagree with Firefox... in terms of functionality and configurability it's by far and away my preferred browser but in terms of performance it just crunches to a crawl on my Mac. Load times of pages are absolutely fine but changing tabs crunch , scroll down the webpage judder freeze whereas Edge is just silky smooth. Maybe it's an extension or three I'm running but I just want to use the bloody thing not sit there and figure out what extension is not working nicely (and then potentially find out it's none of them) on one platform but is fine on another. Every so often I go back and have look to see if it's improvised but it hasn't in the last few years for me.
- bayindirh 3y agoUsing Firefox on a couple of Macs (one of them is >8 years old), and a couple of Linux systems. Setting aside the fact that it's as fast as or faster than Chrome, it doesn't crawl any of my machines with >500 tabs (this has 562 as of now). If you want to dig into your performance numbers there's "about:performance" to see what is using your processor and RAM.
- darreninthenet 3y agoDid that and weirdly nothing seems to be excessive... indeed the Macs own performance monitor doesn't suggest anything is particular excessively using cpu or ram but here it is juddering away especially when scrolling pages. Three year old Mac btw... everything else runs pretty well... if I get a chance I might fire up Firefox in Parallels and see if it's a Mac issue
- bayindirh 3y agoWhen you write "about:performance" to your address bar, and press enter, you should access to the internal performance monitoring page of Firefox. That should list every tab and extension by RAM use and power impact. Give it a go.
- darreninthenet 3y ago
- jchw 3y agoYeah, because you called it manifest V3, not gimping adblockers, which is what it actually was. How many of Google's users love that they're gimping adblockers? Same for Web Environment Integrity API. Nobody knows what those jargon terms means. That's part of how enshittification works. If everyone knew how badly they were being fucked, this would never work.
- boppo1 3y agoI actually don't understand it well. What does it mean? I can't browse the web from xubuntu any more? I believe it's scary, but can't seem to actually sell myself on that. If it's so bad, why can't we bring a monopoly lawsuit against them over chrome/chromium? This is pretty similar to what Microsoft did, isn't it?
- jchw 3y agoThe problem with remote attestation is that there's no bound to exactly how bad it could become. If you can get enough of the internet on browsers that support remote attestation, to the point where it's an acceptable loss to simply reject anyone who does not have a browser that does support remote attestation, you can theoretically assert full control over the end user. What will actually happen? Nobody knows for sure. The most likely outcome is that you will not be able to do banking, watch Twitch streams, etc. on anything other than Chrome, Firefox and Edge, on Windows and macOS. Linux will probably be relegated to the legacy web that does not enforce remote attestation. Alternate browsers like Librewolf, Brave and Mullvad Browser will just disappear as if they never existed. You can not browse Tor on clearnet websites anymore, as if you really could anyways. Etc, etc. > If it's so bad, why can't we bring a monopoly lawsuit against them over chrome/chromium? This is pretty similar to what Microsoft did, isn't it? Microsoft of today is doing things blatantly in the open, that Microsoft of 199x would never dream of doing. The difference now is that all of the major computer manufacturers are basically going the same way, just at different rates. The legal system is not coming to rescue us.
- nintendo1889 3y ago'The Four Horsemen of the Info-pocalypse: child pornography, terrorism, money laundering, and The War on Some Drugs.' - Jacob Applebaum - Cypherpunks